2008 Amateur Draft Review: The AL West

The 2011 amateur draft is just over a month away (June 6-8) so we’re breaking out some pre-draft coverage with a review of the 2008-10 drafts. We kick things off with a look at the American League West. The AL Central will be up next.

The first three rounds are listed for each team, plus any other above-slot signees.
(X = Signed to Over-Slot Deal; S = Supplemental Round; DNS = Did Not Sign)

The Texas Rangers
1st. Justin Smoak, 1B, South Carolina
2nd. Robbie Ross, LHP, Kentucky HS
3rd. Tim Murphy, LHP, UCLA
7thx – Matt Thompson, RHP, Texas HS

Notes: This was a solid but unspectacular draft for the Texas Rangers. The club nabbed first baseman Smoak, who was later flipped in a trade with Seattle for the rental of Cliff Lee. It didn’t result in a World Series ring for the Rangers but the veteran left-hander provided 3.1 WAR in 15 regular season starts and a 1.42 FIP in the playoffs. Smoak was amongst an impressive group of ’08 college first basemen that also included Yonder Alonso (Cincinnati), Brett Wallace (Oakland), David Cooper (Toronto), Ike Davis (New York NL) and Allan Dykstra (San Diego). Ross is one of the club’s top pitching prospects despite on going concerns about durability stemming from his modest pitcher’s frame. The club recently promoted Cody Eppley to the Majors. The control specialist will work out of the bullpen. He was drafted in the 43rd round out of Virginia Commonwealth University. Other sleepers from this draft include Thompson and Joe Wieland (fourth round).

The Oakland Athletics
1st. Jemile Weeks, 2B, Miami
2nd- Tyson Ross, RHP, California
3rd- Petey Paramore, C, Arizona State
7thx – Brett Hunter, RHP, Pepperdine
10thx – Rashun Dixon, OF, Mississippi HS
28thx – Dusty Coleman, SS, Wichita St.

Notes: Oakland continued its well-publicized, college-centric approach to the draft in ’08. Weeks remains one of the club’s top prospects but his development has been relatively slow for a top college talent (He’s in his fourth pro season and currently performing well in triple-A. If all goes well and he avoids major injuries Weeks could be set to take over second base from Mark Ellis in 2012. Second rounder Ross looks like a useful big league pitcher but I’m not sold on what his overall ceiling will be, as he’s currently working as a swing man. As a Canadian and a fan of the Jays in the 80s and early 90s, I will always remain a fan of the Barfield family. Long-time Jays right-fielder Jesse Barfield‘s son Jeremy Barfield doesn’t get a lot of press but he’s put up respectable numbers in the low minors and deserves monitoring. He’s producing solid numbers in double-A early on in 2011. Dixon flashes impressive tools but he needs to make more contact (career K-rate is above 30%). Hunter’s career was derailed by control issues.

The Seattle Mariners
1st. Joshua Fields, RHP, Georgia
2nd. Dennis Raben, OF, Miami
3rd. Aaron Pribanic, RHP, Nebraska
14thx – Luke Burnett, RHP, Louisiana Tech

Notes: This was a pretty ugly draft. Using a first-round pick on a senior college reliever – which also cost $1.7 million – seemed wrong right from the get-go. Fields put up OK numbers in double-A but he’s also struggled mightily with his command for a guy who was supposed to be “near-MLB ready.” He doesn’t look like someone that is going to be a high-leverage reliever in the Majors. Second rounder Raben looks like a triple-A vet in the making. Pribanic was traded to Pittsburgh and doesn’t strike anybody out but his ground-ball ways could help him find his way into a big league bullpen at some point.

The Los Angeles Angels
1st. None
2nd. Tyler Chatwood, RHP, California HS
3rd. Ryan Chaffee, RHP, Florida JC
3S. Zach Cone, OF, Georgia HS (DNS)
11thx – Rolando Gomez, SS, Florida HS

Notes: The free agent signing of Torii Hunter the previous winter gave the club’s first round pick to Minnesota (They selected college right-hander Carlos Gutierrez). The club nabbed a nice pick in the second round in Chatwood, who moved through the minor league system rather quickly and has made three starts at the MLB level in 2011, although he’s not ready for the Majors (6.05 FIP, 5.50 BB/9). Hopefully this desperate move won’t stunt his further growth. Third rounder Chaffee has been a bit of a disappointment as he’s struggled with both his command and control. In fairness, he’s also pitched in some leagues that heavily favor hitters. Lefty Will Smith was an astute pick-up in the seventh round but he was traded to Kansas City and has the ceiling of a middle reliever or fourth/fifth starter. Michael Kohn, a 14th round, has provided excellent value for his draft position and has already pitched in parts of two MLB seasons (2010-11). His ceiling, though, is that of a middle reliever.

Print This Post

Marc Hulet has been writing at FanGraphs since 2008. His work focuses on prospect analysis. Follow him on Twitter @marchulet.

11 Responses to “2008 Amateur Draft Review: The AL West”

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
  1. Jack Weiland says:

    What did they get for Pribanic? I seem to recall this trade, but can’t think of the return.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

    • Josh G says:

      I believe he was part of the package that got Jack Wilson

      Vote -1 Vote +1

    • john sparrow says:

      jack wilson and ian snell

      Vote -1 Vote +1

      • matt w says:

        Yep. Wilson + Snell for Pribanic, Brett Lorin, Nate Adcock, Ronny Cedeno, and Jeff Clement. Adcock might wind up as the best player in the deal.

        Vote -1 Vote +1

      • Jim says:

        Well, Adcock might have the best chance to make something of himself, I think, yes–what with:

        1. Ronny Cedeno sucking and Pittsburgh rebuilding, and Cedeno now apparently on the outs with their acquisition of Brandon Wood.

        2. Jack Wilson on the downside of his career and is just a stopgap for the M’s until Dustin Ackley arrives.

        3. Ian Snell performing horribly with the 2010 Mariners–so horribly that he was outrighted off their 40-man roster and went to AAA, then was outrighted again at season’s end and became a free agent, signing a minor league contract with the Cardinals this spring, and then retiring after a not-so-great spring. And apparently, he now wants to pitch again, oy vey.

        4. Of the other 2 minor leaguers acquired by the Pirates in the deal–Brett Lorin and Aaron Pribanic–there have been mixed results.

        Lorin was injured for most of 2010, but will get a chance to regroup in 2011 with high A Bradenton. Pribanic is slowly advancing(he’s at AA this year), but has proven to be somewhat hittable(he allowed 157 hits in 154 IP at Bradenton last year, but posted a decent 3.33 RA).

        It’s probably down to either Adcock, who’s now with the Royals as a Rule 5 pick, or Pribinac, still with the Pirates, as the “best player” in the deal. Still too early to tell, IMO. :)

        Vote -1 Vote +1

  2. brendan says:

    I think brett wallace is with houston now. he was not drafted by the A’s, rather he was obtained from toronto via trade in the carlos gonzalez matt holliday deal.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

    • bob says:

      Wallace was obtained from St. Louis (and drafted by St. Louis) as part of the Holliday deal….then flipped to Toronto for M. Taylor and Toronto then flipped him to Houston.

      Vote -1 Vote +1

  3. NBarnes says:

    That Seattle draft is/was hilariously terrible.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

    • Matt says:

      Uggh… They should have fired Bavasi June 4 instead of June 16, 2008. No, actually, they should have fired him November 7, 2003.

      The M’s sure could use a Jordan Lyles, Mike Montgomery, or Lonnie Chisenhall right now. Hell, Jaff Decker would be great.

      Vote -1 Vote +1

  4. Anonymous says:

    Any chance we could get the overall pick number included in brackets next to the round name? Even if it’s just for the first round guys.

    I mean, I could look it up myself, but like almost everyone, I am very lazy.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Current ye@r *