FanGraphs Baseball


RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. Oh nice, another pointless snarky post on FranGraphs…if only I could demand the last few minutes of my life back.

    Stay pointless my friends.

    Comment by Ian — November 18, 2009 @ 4:16 pm

  2. First the no-commenting on Cantu, now the speechlessness on Cody Ross? Do I sense an anti-Marlins tinge, Mr. Matt K? I’m watching you…

    You could say this on Cody: “Fans chant his name a lot in South Florida. And he’s not a bad hitter.”

    Comment by Michael — November 18, 2009 @ 4:58 pm

  3. Robbie Cano should have an award all to himself for unclutchitude in 2009.

    A wRAA of +23.1, and a RE23 of -7.4.
    Essentially the Yankees could’ve had another 3 wins if Cano hit in key spots better, which in any given season, he could. That’s a bit…scary.

    Comment by Joe R — November 18, 2009 @ 5:12 pm

  4. Agreed. What was I supposed to learn from this? If nothing else, I come here to be entertained and this post didn’t do that either.

    I’m all for sabermetrics, but posts like this make me cringe a little bit.

    Comment by Evan — November 18, 2009 @ 9:42 pm

  5. Any idea how this list would compare to a simpler list of RBI% (RBI/total RBI opportunities)? That’s not a stat I’ve seen often, but it’s pretty simple and foolproof. I would suspect that there is some agreement, but your list probably classifies hitters more closely to their overall abilities.

    Comment by Jeremiah — November 19, 2009 @ 10:44 am

  6. (click the name link for more info)

    Despite the fact that the BBWA got it right with Tim Lincecum, Zack Greinke, Joe Mauer and technically Albert Pujols, they are still a bunch of morons. Somehow, Hanley Ramirez, Ryan Howard, Prince Fielder, Troy Tulowitzki, Andre Ethier and Pablo Sandoval all ended up with more MVP votes than Chase Utley. At 7.6 Wins Above Replacement (WAR), Chase Utley was the second most valuable hitter in the NL (behind Pujols, at 8.4 WAR) and the seventh most valuable player overall. A strong balance between fantastic defense at 2B and quality hitting at the plate makes Chase Utley one of the most valuable assets in baseball (based on his production and salary, Fangraphs ranked Utley as a top ten asset earlier this year). Utley does many things very well. He can hit (28+ HRs in 4 of the last 5 seasons, .390 career wOBA), field (career +15.5 UZR/150 at 2B), and run the bases (23 SB last season, 0 CS). He tied Reggie Jackson’s World Series homerun record this year. And, as evidenced below, he can even fly.

    But Chase Utley gets no love.

    At first glance, Pujols appears to deserve the MVP. His monstrous bat was second to none (+16 Runs Above Replacement (RAR) compared to Mauer, the AL MVP) and his defense is solid (it has averaged just under +5 RAR per season since 2002). However, Albert Pujols plays first base. Yes, WAR accomodates this with a -12.4 Positional Adjustment to Pujols’ cumulative RAR, but there is something more to be said when the WARs are close and the positions played by two players require significantly different levels of skill.

    “But DME,” you say, “Pujols has a +8.4 WAR and Utley has a +7.6 WAR. That’s a chunky +8 RAR difference.” True, in theory, but WAR does not encapsulate every aspect of a player’s value (and no, I’m not talking about Grindiness Per Nine Inning (G/9)). WAR does not encapsulate baserunning skills. Because WAR is derivative of wOBA, which already accounts for SB%, the additional “Baserunning RAR” (BRAR) is calculated by (EQBRR-EQSBR). According to Baseball Prospectus, Chase Utley was the second best baserunner in the majors last season (behind Michael Bourne) and his BRAR was +5.32. Albert Pujols was not even a top 500 baserunner and his BRAR was -0.62.

    This makes the difference between Utley and Pujols’ end of season cumulative RAR’s within two runs of each other. Such a difference is pretty marginal. Factor in Pujols’ +13 PA’s and the fact that Chase Utley’s team made it to the World Series (where Utley raked), and I would have to tip my hat in favor of Chase Utley, who plays in a much tougher division, for the NL MVP award. By no means is it a travesty that Pujols got the honor. It is a travesty, however, that Utley did not even finish top 5 in NL MVP voting.

    This only goes to show that even when the BBWA gets it right, they still manage to get it wrong.

    Comment by David MVP Eckstein — November 24, 2009 @ 6:40 pm

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.

Close this window.

0.266 Powered by WordPress