FanGraphs Baseball


RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. I just thought it was funny, that as I was reading, I thought back to this other article I read, about the “Ray Lankford All Stars”, and there he is on your list.

    Comment by Shaun — March 12, 2009 @ 8:13 am

  2. Mike Cameron – due to be forgotten by everyone but the sabermetric segment of Mariner fans, who adore the defensive wizardry he displayed.

    Comment by pygmalion — March 12, 2009 @ 8:31 am

  3. Amos Otis and Frank White.

    Comment by Ron — March 12, 2009 @ 8:39 am

  4. Sanders may be forgotten by loads of fans, but he was a big part of the clubhouse atmosphere that existed during the Cardinals’ dominant run in the NL during his time there. He was well-known for keeping the clubhouse loose while noted workaholics/serious guys like Rolen and Pujols kept the focus.

    Additionally, he was a pretty great weapon for a sneak attack; after a pitcher would battle through the MV3 of Pujols-Edmonds-Rolen, he would exhale in reilef, only to see the big bat of Sanders threatening to take one deep.

    I also thought of him when you posted your comment about Bradley and one-year deals. Nice work bringing him up and showing that his contributions have been somewhat unfairly overlooked.

    Comment by Irishman — March 12, 2009 @ 8:45 am

  5. I know this person won some mvp awards and silver slugger awards, but he was never really noticed very much. — Juan Gonzalez.

    Comment by Jason — March 12, 2009 @ 8:46 am

  6. Juan Gonzalez not a malcontent? Tell that to Tigers fans.

    Comment by Kevin — March 12, 2009 @ 9:13 am

  7. I nominate Ryan Klesko.

    Comment by Matt — March 12, 2009 @ 9:20 am

  8. How about Dante Bichette?

    274 homers
    152 steals
    .359 WOBA

    Comment by Karl — March 12, 2009 @ 9:23 am

  9. also, Tim Salmon?

    299 homers
    .382 career WOBA

    Comment by Karl — March 12, 2009 @ 9:27 am

  10. Bichette would be a fine inductee… Salmon I’m not sure of because, for a while, he was the face of the California/Anaheim franchise… he might be too famous.

    But keep the suggestions coming, guys… I’m not claiming to have identified ALL worthy members, just the ones that initially stood out.

    Comment by Eric Seidman — March 12, 2009 @ 9:29 am

  11. Kent Hrbek

    293 homers
    128 OPS+

    I’m not sure how many people outside of Minnesota or Atlanta remembers him.

    Comment by Karl — March 12, 2009 @ 9:33 am

  12. Two more potentials before I go to class:

    Raul Mondesi
    Danny Tartabull

    Comment by Karl — March 12, 2009 @ 9:37 am

  13. As a Cards fan, this made me think of Bernard Gilkey. In my mind he hit 200 HR, but I guess his decline was a lot quiker than I had remembered. Still, he was in that vein.

    Comment by JDB — March 12, 2009 @ 9:42 am

  14. This reminds me a lot of an essay Bill James wrote in the last HBA on the anatomy of an underrated player. There were ten traits in all, I think, but two of them were:
    a.) A player who has their career broken up into chunks – a positional switch, a change in teams, etc, will often go underrated. Reggie Sanders’s team-flopping is well documented.
    b.) A player who does lots of things very well but does not excel in any of them.
    James was writing about his vote for most underrated player of all time: Darrell Evans. I’ll throw him into the hopper. Career 119 OPS+.

    Comment by Lyons — March 12, 2009 @ 9:48 am

  15. Cliff Floyd

    Comment by Josh — March 12, 2009 @ 9:50 am

  16. Love the idea.

    I nominate Bernie Williams and the aforementioned Steve Finley. Both great guys.

    Comment by CH — March 12, 2009 @ 9:53 am

  17. Karl, go to class.

    Comment by Richie Abernathy — March 12, 2009 @ 9:54 am

  18. Danny Tartabull is too famous – Seinfeld.

    Comment by Jamie — March 12, 2009 @ 9:57 am

  19. How about some more outfielders? I can’t think of any infielders.

    Jay Buhner
    Brian Giles
    Andy Van Slyke
    Pedro Guerrero

    Comment by Jed MC — March 12, 2009 @ 10:24 am

  20. Jesse Barfield. Didn’t quite have 100 SB. Fantastic arm.

    .256/.335/.466, OPS+ 117.

    Ron Gant (maybe a little too well known?) .256/.336/.468, OPS+112

    Comment by Jon — March 12, 2009 @ 10:28 am

  21. Some I could think of, tried to do some infielders:

    Travis Fryman
    Robin Ventura
    Cliff Floyd
    Tino Martinez
    Edgardo Alfonzo
    Mike Sweeney
    Tony Fernandez

    Comment by bpasinko — March 12, 2009 @ 10:55 am

  22. oh Devon White too, maybe he was too popular on the championship teams, same goes with Tino above

    Comment by bpasinko — March 12, 2009 @ 10:57 am

  23. Jeromy Burnitz?

    Comment by Brian Recca — March 12, 2009 @ 10:58 am

  24. I don’t know the Mets television station SNY talks about Edgardo Alfonzo all the time. He might be too famous in the New York area, Met fans love the guy.

    Comment by Brian Recca — March 12, 2009 @ 11:00 am

  25. Boring name, boring dude

    George Foster
    Frank Howard
    Larry Walker
    Brett Butler – nice alliteration though
    Kevin Brown
    Dave Parker
    Jack Clark

    Two guys named Evans

    Dwight Evans
    Darrell Evans

    Holy trinity of boring first basemen

    Will Clark
    Mark Grace
    John Olerud

    The Harold Baines group

    Harold Baines

    If Only I’d Hit One More Homer…

    Andres Galarraga

    Comment by Mike — March 12, 2009 @ 11:03 am

  26. I think you guys might be largely missing the point… we’re not looking for just underrated players with good numbers.

    We’re looking for guys who were humble, had good but not great numbers in numerous areas (Brett Butler never hit HR, etc), but who are forgotten by numerous circles… so people like Tino and Alfonso don’t count because they are still highly regarded in New York.

    Comment by Eric Seidman — March 12, 2009 @ 11:06 am

  27. Just an observation, but check out the skin color of a disproportionately high number of the players mentioned here. If these guys were white they would probably be better known to the casual fan because the media would have went wild with stories about them as “consummate pros”, “lunch pale and hardhat guys”, “soft-spoken leaders”, “scrappy everyman” or some other BS.

    Comment by MItch — March 12, 2009 @ 11:10 am

  28. I don’t know, there are a bazillion forgotten white guys.

    And if we are just looking at power/speed combos, not many white dudes have that

    Comment by Mike — March 12, 2009 @ 11:15 am

  29. How about?
    Marquis Grissom
    Dean Palmer
    Kevin McReynolds
    Tony Clark
    Matt Stairs

    Comment by Brian Recca — March 12, 2009 @ 11:18 am

  30. Mitch what the hell are you talking about? There are just as many white guys as black guys.

    Comment by Brian Recca — March 12, 2009 @ 11:21 am

  31. I second:
    Tim Salmon
    Devon White
    Brian Giles
    Raul Mondesi

    and how about Bret Boone and Todd Zeile

    Comment by Jeff — March 12, 2009 @ 11:24 am

  32. For the second time – Tim Salmon is too highly regarded by the Angels fanbase. And Mondesi?? Does anyone remember the Ramirez-like crap he pulled on Pittsburgh… he’s not making this club.

    Comment by Eric Seidman — March 12, 2009 @ 11:27 am

  33. One guy that always comes to mind for me is Rusty Greer. He doesn’t have the career statistics because his career was cut short by injuries, but he was well know for being a great guy off the field and played the game the right way on the field. He was one of the most integral parts on the powerful Rangers offenses of the 1990’s but didn’t get as much credit as others such as Juan Gonzalez, Ivan Rodriguez and Will Clark.

    Some others that come to mind for me are:

    Bobby Bonilla
    Raul Mondesi
    Chili Davis
    Ruben Sierra
    Ron Gant
    Greg Vaughn
    Geoff Jenkins
    Raul Ibanez
    Aubrey Huff
    Vernon Wells
    Eric Chavez
    Todd Zeile

    Comment by Chris — March 12, 2009 @ 11:32 am

  34. Lovin’ the Chili Davis pick

    Comment by Brian Recca — March 12, 2009 @ 11:38 am

  35. A few others I thought of, all consummate professionals:

    Jay Bell
    Jeff Conine
    Wally Joyner

    Comment by Chris — March 12, 2009 @ 11:46 am

  36. That’s the thing, few remember his Pittsburgh drama. Cameron failed a drug test – people are going to remember that more than Mondesi’s issues. Drama is drama. What about Ray Lankford supposedly wearing out his welcome in St. Louis? The list gets thinner.

    Comment by Jeff — March 12, 2009 @ 11:59 am

  37. Jeff Conine’s the perfect pick.

    More perfect, though?

    B.J. Surhoff and Terry Steinbach.

    oh, and Dan Plesac.

    Comment by Alex — March 12, 2009 @ 12:01 pm

  38. I don’t know about Conine. He was “Mr. Marlin” in South Florida, so he may miss due to his (albeit regional) popularity.

    Comment by Joe — March 12, 2009 @ 12:13 pm

  39. I thought about B.J Surhoff, his numbers aren’t anywhere near Reggie Sanders. And since we are using Sanders as the model I think Surhoff would be left out. I still say Marquis Grissom for sure.

    Comment by Brian Recca — March 12, 2009 @ 12:33 pm

  40. I have a feeling you don’t know what disproportionate means.

    Comment by Ddavid — March 12, 2009 @ 1:08 pm

  41. So many Braves on here:

    Fred McGriff (no. 1 comp on baseball ref is McCovey)
    Julio Franco?
    David Justice (though he played for the Yanks)

    Comment by Ken — March 12, 2009 @ 1:47 pm

  42. Would Lou Whitaker count? Willie Davis? Robin Ventura?

    Comment by Aaron B. — March 12, 2009 @ 2:04 pm

  43. I don’t think Luis Gonzalez should qualify for this list. His 2001 season was too huge to be boring and I still consider him the all-time face of the Diamondbacks.

    Comment by Pat — March 12, 2009 @ 2:09 pm

  44. Kevin McReynolds for sure.

    Comment by Lukas — March 12, 2009 @ 3:14 pm

  45. Marquis Grissom is one of only a handful of guys with 200 HR and 400 SB.

    Others are Barry Bonds, Bobby Bonds, Joe Morgan, Paul Molitor, and Rickey Henderson.

    Comment by Sabertooth — March 12, 2009 @ 3:20 pm

  46. His name is Chili. That’s not boring.

    Comment by Sabertooth — March 12, 2009 @ 3:22 pm

  47. Pat Sajak remembers Hrbek.

    Comment by Sabertooth — March 12, 2009 @ 3:24 pm

  48. I think Lou Whitaker should count. The guy is insanely humble, and was so overlooked that he was booted from HoF consideration because he didn’t get the 5% necessary votes to stay (despite being a top 15 all time 2nd baseman).

    Comment by Kevin — March 12, 2009 @ 4:12 pm

  49. And Boone is huge with Seattle fans. That, and he was an egotistical fella.

    Comment by Sentinel — March 12, 2009 @ 5:52 pm

  50. I disagree with the Mike Cameron pick. You’d be surprised to know that he’s a favorite for many M’s fans. He’s borderline, at best.

    Comment by Sentinel — March 12, 2009 @ 5:55 pm

  51. This. I would suggest eliminating any player who had some sort of ridiculous single season.

    Pretty much everyone who follows baseball knows who Gonzo is, and what he has/hasn’t done.

    Comment by FairweatherFan — March 12, 2009 @ 5:57 pm

  52. What about Bobby Higginson? He falls just short of all of the aforementioned criteria: 187 HR, 91 SB, +113 OPS

    Comment by Dan Librot — March 12, 2009 @ 6:42 pm

  53. I think Julio will always be remembered just because he played for so many damn teams and played for soooo long.

    Comment by Eric — March 12, 2009 @ 6:52 pm

  54. As an Angel fan in socal I can assure you Tim Salmon is very much appreciated and known out here.

    Comment by So Cal — March 13, 2009 @ 12:14 am

  55. David Justice was married to Halle Berry. Thats well known.

    Comment by So Cal — March 13, 2009 @ 12:20 am

  56. Dean Palmer .251/.324/.472 OPS+107 275 HR only 48 SB’s though

    Brian Downing .267/.370/.425 OPS+ 122 HR 275 SB’s 50

    Comment by So Cal — March 13, 2009 @ 12:24 am

  57. Jay Buhner, doesn’t have the SB numbers, but I believe he was overshadowed enough by Junior, Big Unit, A-Rod, & edgar to be inconsideration.

    Dean Palmer & Bobby Higginson.

    Shawn Green is hard for me to accept in the BSCBS. I remember from my Strat-o-matic days that green had a 4-5 year run where he was a dominate player: 30-40 HR, good defense, good SB numbers, 3 top 10 MVP voting. It’s just hard for me to find BSCBS candidates because I’ve played Strat-O for 15 years and I had a lot of these “underrated” BSCBS players as starters on my teams over the years.

    Comment by John — March 13, 2009 @ 10:04 am

  58. Buhner was a Seinfeld reference, which probably eliminates him. Lou Whitaker though, wow, as good as Ryne Sandberg but never received the accolades. Completely deserves to be in the HOF.

    Comment by JD — March 13, 2009 @ 10:14 am

  59. Well i don’t’ watch Seinfeld, so that explains my “ignorance”. I guess I’m in the minority though.

    Comment by John — March 13, 2009 @ 11:07 am

  60. Let’s shift the criteria around. After careful consideration, here is what we should be looking for:

    1) Player bounced around the league, playing for several teams.
    2) Player could play several seasons with one team but not have a huge impact (IE, Sanders on the Reds for 8 yrs but not really an impact player)
    3) Player has solid numbers but no shot at the HOF

    Now let’s compile a list.

    Comment by Eric Seidman — March 13, 2009 @ 11:09 am

  61. How about Rupert Jones? Not the greatest stats (147 HR, 143 SB), but seems to fit otherwise.

    Comment by Jim — March 13, 2009 @ 12:07 pm

  62. Randy Winn?

    .288/.347/.425; 104 HR; 125 SB; generally good defense….easily forgettable.

    Comment by TomG — March 13, 2009 @ 12:08 pm

  63. Jimmy Wynn

    Comment by jjcole — March 13, 2009 @ 12:15 pm

  64. It’s sounding more and more like Ron Gant’s a safe bet.

    And how about Benito Santiago?

    Comment by Alex — March 13, 2009 @ 12:16 pm

  65. While probably a little too popular for the RSCBS, I have a feeling people are soon going to forget how good of a player Moises Alou was at his (healthy) peak.

    Comment by TomG — March 13, 2009 @ 12:34 pm

  66. Dave Magadan

    Comment by TomG — March 13, 2009 @ 12:40 pm

  67. By all accounts LuGo (no not Julio, but Luis) has the lifetime numbers and the personality, but he was a famously late bloomer changing for a gap power doubles guy to someone who hit what 57? HRs in area that would make anyone skeptical. So between that and a top 3 finish in the MVP ballot that year (I think second but thats just off the top of my head) he doesn’t seem to fit as well as Lankford. I dont think Burks would be on the list if not for his back derailing his career which seemed destined to be filled with All Star games, at least to someone who was growing up around Boston when he was making an impact.

    Comment by cpstraight — March 13, 2009 @ 1:17 pm

  68. sounds like eric is a small-RSCBS guy

    Comment by John — March 13, 2009 @ 2:39 pm

  69. Strong second for Randy Winn… looking at the career Value page you can see that he was very quietly very valuable for multiple teams for a decade without being the face of any of them… except maybe that terrible D-Rays team he played for.

    Comment by Spike Friedman — March 13, 2009 @ 3:49 pm

  70. Even on the D-Rays he wasn’t the face. By the time he started to come into his own, Carl Crawford showed up. I’ll give that a third.

    Comment by Kevin — March 13, 2009 @ 4:05 pm

  71. HOJO!

    228 HRs, 231 SBs, 117 OPS. He did play the bulk of his career in New York, so he was slightly more famous than some of these other names, but absent the nickname and hotel chain (not related, but still), I don’t know how many people really remember his career.

    Comment by BSK — March 13, 2009 @ 6:22 pm

  72. I have a few names to consider. My favorite “forgotten” star is Bob Johnson. He only played for 3 teams, so he might not qualify, but his 138 OPS+ is pretty good and is accompanied by 288 home runs and 96 stolen bases. Some others include:

    Gene Woodling: 123 OPS+, 147 home runs, light on SBs with 29

    Howard Johnson (4 teams): 117 OPS+, 228 HRs, 231 SBs. But he was on
    a NY team so he may not qualify.

    Earl Torgeson: 5 teams, 117 OPS+, 149 HRs, 133 SBs

    Larry Hisle: 3 teams, 123 OPS+, 166 HRs, 128 SBs

    Tommy Davis: 9 teams, 108 OPS+, 153 HRs, 136 SBs. But the batting
    title may disqualify him

    Dan Driessen: 5 teams, 113 OPS+, 153 HRs, 154 SBs.

    Comment by Bob R. — March 13, 2009 @ 8:03 pm

  73. Ventura’s too well known for getting knuggied by Ryan upon charging the mound.

    Comment by Kevin S. — March 13, 2009 @ 8:49 pm

  74. Tenace, anyone?

    Comment by Ddavid — March 13, 2009 @ 11:12 pm

  75. I can’t for the life of me explain it, but one of the very few baseball cards I can vividly remember owning — and as such, probably hold in too high regard a player who retired when I was six years old — was one of Carney Lansford. 151 HR, 224 SB, .337 wOBA, 111 OPS+. Plus, he played for three teams. And he had a bright red moustache, which must count for something.

    Comment by Jason J — March 13, 2009 @ 11:47 pm

  76. Mike Greenwell? Does he get DQ’ed because everybody knows Canseco robbed him of the ’88 MVP? I think people don’t realize how valuable he was outside of that. Even though he played his whole career in Boston, he was overshadowed by Clemens, Vaughn, etc. He didn’t have a very long career (5166 PA), but he posted an OPS+ of 120 and an EqA of .283. Except for the career length, he was very similar to Sanders, who posted an OPS+ of 115 and an EqA of .282. Both were a little below average defensively.

    Comment by Kevin S. — March 14, 2009 @ 1:09 am

  77. LLoyd Moseby?
    Tim Wallach?
    Vinny Castilla?
    Chet Lemon?
    Mike Deveraux?
    Gary Gaetti?
    Hubie Books?

    I agree with Whitaker, McReynolds, Zeile and Grissom

    Comment by sergio — March 14, 2009 @ 1:55 am

  78. I find it hard to assimilate all the categories of qualifications. Some seem to be looking for broad based skills, power and speed combined. Others consider nomadism, suggesting a player has to have had a long stretch when he rarely played for a team more than a year or two. Then there is the non-controversial issue, something I often do not know at all.

    But in looking back at some players I remember, two seem reasonably close to filling all the criteria. The first is Tony Phillips. I do not recall him being particularly controversial or difficult. In the last 6 years of his career he played for 7 different teams. Not a power hitter, he still hit 160 home runs (27 one year) and 360 doubles. Not a great speed guy, he still stole 177 bases. And his career OPS+ was 106, which included an 8 year stretch between 101-130. Five times it was over 120.

    He was excellent at getting on base, with a career .374 OBP and three years over .400. In five seasons he walked over 100 times. And on top of that he was very versatile. While not a particularly good fielder, he was good enough to spend 100 or more games at 5 different positions (2B, LF, 3B, SS, RF) and 97 in CF. In many ways, he was a poor man’s Tim Raines (OK, an impoverished man’s Tim Raines.)

    The second player was Reggie Smith. I won’t review his stats, but they are very good, especially his 137 OPS+. He only played for 4 different teams, so perhaps he does not qualify, but it seems to me he was always excellent while not quite a star and overshadowed by teammates on Boston and the Dodgers. He did receive accolades while playing, including 5 all-star game appearances, but is he really remembered any longer except by aficionados of the game’s history? In his only year on the ballot, he got 3 votes for the HOF (.7%).

    Comment by Bob R. — March 14, 2009 @ 5:39 am

  79. With no individual comments except their OPS+, these players moved around a bit and had at least 5000 ABs.

    Gene Woodling: 123
    Toby Harrah: 114
    Johnny Callison: 115
    George Hendrick: 116
    Rico Carty: 132
    Mickey Vernon: 116

    Comment by Bob R. — March 14, 2009 @ 8:04 am

  80. Trying to think of someone that really bounced around a lot, Roberto Kelly came to mind. Similar to Sanders in that he started his career with a fairly lengthy time with one team (6 years with the Yankees) before bouncing around the league playing for eight different teams in eight years being traded mid-season three times.

    Career .290/.337/.430 with 124 HR and 234 steals and capable of playing all three outfield positions.

    Some of the earlier suggestions that I still think ring true include:

    Bobby Bonilla
    Jeff Conine
    Chili Davis
    Todd Zeile
    Ruben Sierra
    Ron Gant

    Comment by Chris — March 14, 2009 @ 4:30 pm

  81. Based on updated criteria (with no speed requirement), Matt Stairs is an excellent choice. OPS+ of 118 over 16 seasons for 11 teams. According to Baseball Reference, he made the top-20 in MVP voting exactly once, with a 17th place showing in 1999. My fellow Californians seem to be completely ignorant of Stairs’ contributions for the A’s from 1996-2000. That five year stretch represents his longest run on any one team.
    The Matt Stairs World Tour: Montreal, Boston, Oakland, Chicago (Cubs), Milwaukee, Pittsburgh, Kansas City, Arlington (Rangers), Detroit, Toronto, Philadelphia.
    Bonus: Matt has a cool nickname: “Wonder Hamster”. Double-Bonus: Matt’s good deeds are so unrecognized that:
    If you type “Wonder Hamster” into Google, you get about a bajillion links about an obscure thirty second long Weird Al song before a single mention of Mr. Stairs.

    Possible Caveat: I’m not sure if his big homer for Philly has made him a local hero around those parts.

    Comment by Joe D. — March 14, 2009 @ 9:10 pm

  82. definitely tenace he was better in value across the board than rice in peak and per-season but no one other than bill james people give a crap about him

    Comment by John — March 14, 2009 @ 9:32 pm

  83. Von Hayes? May have spent too long in Philly, but 143 HR, 253 SB, 113 OPS+.

    Rondell White? He’s been a mercenary since the start in Montreal. 198 HR, 94 SB, 108 OPS+.

    Jose Cruz (Jr)? 204 HR, 113 SB, 102 OPS+

    Brian Jordan? 104 OPS+, 184 HR, 119 SB, but maybe fame due to the whole “two sport” thing – but then again, people might forget him and remember Deion and Bo.

    I was also thinking Glenallen Hill, Jeff Leonard, Preston Wilson, Juan Encarnacion, Jim Eisenreich and Joe Orsulak, but they don’t have the numbers of some of the other guys on the list (yes, I always enjoyed the vagabond fourth outfielder types). Eisenreich might be too famous due to the whole “miss three years due to Tourette’s” thing anyway.

    Comment by Eric — March 15, 2009 @ 9:12 pm

  84. gentleman, i offer you Bobby Grich

    Comment by brandon — March 17, 2009 @ 4:46 pm

  85. Im young so perhaps he is more famous than i realize and i vaguely remember something about him beating a murder rap but Cesar Cedeno might belong on this list.

    Comment by brandon — March 17, 2009 @ 4:49 pm

  86. the publish seems to be very good and very much useful to that are along with repetitive searches for these kind of articles. a person really much.

    Comment by 10 minute solution dvd — April 29, 2010 @ 3:59 am

  87. Unquestionably believe that which you said. Your favorite reason appeared to be on the web the simplest thing to be aware of. I say to you, I definitely get irked while people consider worries that they just do not know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top and defined out the whole thing without having side-effects , people can take a signal. Will probably be back to get more. Many thanks Izola Gallardo

    Comment by Izola Gallardo — July 18, 2011 @ 10:59 am

  88. Moises Alou is way too easily remembered for his technique to harden his hands and for his time with the Cubs.

    Comment by glassSheets — July 18, 2011 @ 12:49 pm

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Close this window.

0.224 Powered by WordPress