FanGraphs Baseball


RSS feed for comments on this post.

  1. I dont remember, did older brother Upton make the list?

    Comment by Beau — July 20, 2009 @ 11:08 am

  2. BJ was earlier on the list, I think in the 40s or so.

    Longoria’s agreement to his contract can be traced back to the influence of friend Eric Hinske who said something about not passing on the first million he makes.

    Comment by JZ — July 20, 2009 @ 11:10 am

  3. Well, Hinske really fucked him over on that one.

    Comment by Nick — July 20, 2009 @ 11:11 am

  4. Same franchise as Baldelli, though. Wouldn’t Rocco have enjoyed a 6 year / $24,000,000 contract now?

    Comment by Joe R — July 20, 2009 @ 11:16 am

  5. Enjoyed the series, Dave. Only gripes are with Tulo at #15 IIRC (on the talent part of the equation) and Strasburg (on the technicality that he can’t be traded anyway; other parts of the assessment were spot on in my view). As usual, good stuff.

    Comment by Big Oil — July 20, 2009 @ 11:26 am

  6. Longoria could always hold out for a renegotiation down the line if his pay becomes too abstractly low in comparison to his peers. The Rays don’t have to agree, but if he blossoms into the true superstar franchise player, they might bow to his desires at some point. It’s a rare instance, but it has happened before in the past.

    In any case, that’s one helluva top 4. Wieters seems inflated to me, but the guys in the top 4 slots are hands down the best players and contracts in baseball. Great work, Dave, and although I have doubts on a few players’ values in the real world baseball trade market in comparison to where you value them, this is one giant undertaking and a few quibbles are bound to exist for any writer and reader in a piece with this scope.

    Comment by Bodhizefa — July 20, 2009 @ 11:31 am

  7. 0.5 Sandoval


    Kind of surprised that the man with no home (Zobrist) did not pop up. I know SSS, but the kid is showing he can really hit. When an organization has two “starters” sitting on their bench to begin the year it really just isn’t fair.

    Comment by Steve C — July 20, 2009 @ 11:33 am

  8. Is there something wrong with the ZiPS RoS projection? Currently Longoria has a wOBA of .376 and ZiPS projects a .370 from here on out, yet it projects him to finish the year with a .377 wOBA.

    Comment by Davidceisen — July 20, 2009 @ 11:35 am

  9. This list was crap.

    But seriously, awesome work. I look forward to this series every year.

    Comment by There is no God but Pablo Sandoval and Barry Lamar is his prophet — July 20, 2009 @ 11:36 am

  10. There’s a difference between passing on the first million and passing on the 140th million. Taking an expected pay cut to lock up $10M to $20M through arbitration is smart. Agreeing to three years of free agent options was not. In six years, $14M a year will be a steal for a 5 WAR player. If Longoria’s a scrub by some chance, or injured, the Rays are off the hook for paying him.

    Comment by Sky — July 20, 2009 @ 11:40 am

  11. Dave – just wanted to say thanks for this series… It’s always one of my faves!

    Comment by Jerry — July 20, 2009 @ 11:55 am

  12. I think Longoria is somewhat overrated as a hitter. He isn’t anywhere near Pujols/Mauer/Fielder level. That contract is ridiculous though, and understandably puts him at #1. Plus, his defense is great.

    Comment by Kevin — July 20, 2009 @ 12:00 pm

  13. I *think* he’ll be ok.

    Comment by Sunking1056 — July 20, 2009 @ 12:13 pm

  14. Quote: “I think Longoria is somewhat overrated as a hitter”

    Did you happen to see what he did in his first 200 ABs this season??? 13 HRs, 55 RBIs, 23/50 BB/K. I would like to see him strike out a bit less, but that’s nitpicking.

    I personally think his hamstring injury is worse than he is letting on and is the cause for his recent bad stretch.

    Comment by Shizane — July 20, 2009 @ 12:23 pm

  15. Do people think he’s that good? If so, I agree with you.

    But the total package is well beyond Fielder’s level, nearing Mauer’s and, well, Pujols is Pujols.

    Comment by Sky — July 20, 2009 @ 12:34 pm

  16. how can you not have Miguel Cabrera on your list compare his stats

    Comment by paul — July 20, 2009 @ 12:44 pm

  17. Zobrist was among the Honorable Mentions.

    Comment by Chris — July 20, 2009 @ 12:47 pm

  18. Look at his contract.

    Comment by Brad — July 20, 2009 @ 12:49 pm

  19. 2009: 15 million, 2010: 20 million, 2011: 20 million, 2012: 21 million, 2013: 21 million, 2014: 22 million, and 2015: 22 million.

    141 million over 7 years, which is probably exactly what he is worth, but that doesn’t make him a valuable trade asset.

    Comment by Davidceisen — July 20, 2009 @ 12:51 pm

  20. Great list Dave, can’t say I agree with everything, but I think you nailed the top 10 pretty much exactly right. I can’t wait to see some of these younger talents hit their primes in the next few years. It’ll be an exciting time in baseball.

    Comment by Michael — July 20, 2009 @ 12:59 pm

  21. I love the trade value write ups, good job Dave.

    Comment by JI — July 20, 2009 @ 2:18 pm

  22. Yeah, baseball players cost money. The ones who cost a lot of it hurt a team’s flexibility. Cabrera’s a great player, and he’s paid like a great player. Only a handful of teams could afford to match that salary if Detroit ever tries to dump him. In such a scenario, the Tigers aren’t getting many assets in return, and they certainly wouldn’t net any player who cracked this top-50.

    Comment by JH — July 20, 2009 @ 2:32 pm

  23. He doesn’t have the offense of those guys, but he still has a chance to develop to that level (remember he’s still only 23). You’re right though. He’s a merely great hitter and not truly elite. His real value comes from his contract and the fact that he gives the Rays shortstop-quality defense at 3B.

    Comment by JH — July 20, 2009 @ 2:34 pm

  24. In other undervalued players news, I have to represent the Brewers here and say that I’m surprised Yovani Gallardo didn’t even make the honorable mentions. He won’t be a free agent until 2014. Seeing guys like Max Scherzer and especially Robinson Cano on the list makes me wonder why he wouldn’t fit in anywhere.

    Comment by Jordan M — July 20, 2009 @ 2:43 pm

  25. Once again, top notch work as always Dave. I look forward to next year’s trade value write up. (And also, the Organizational Rankings the next time you get around to write it) Your writing is what makes baseball extra enjoyable for me. Thank you.

    Comment by YC — July 20, 2009 @ 2:49 pm

  26. Another way to look at this list is by thinking of it as a draft with the entire player pool with their current contracts. Would you take Zobrist ahead of any of the 50 plus HM’s on here?

    Doubt it….same could be said for anyone else people think are missing from the list.

    Comment by Boomer — July 20, 2009 @ 3:46 pm

  27. Where is Franklin in your list?

    Comment by brian_sun — July 20, 2009 @ 3:58 pm

  28. NO Votto means total waste of time!

    Comment by dan l — July 20, 2009 @ 4:01 pm

  29. Justin Upton should be #1. He has more potential than any hitter in baseball, including Hanley and Longoria.

    Comment by Jason — July 20, 2009 @ 4:45 pm

  30. Meh, Justin Upton is certainly an outstanding player but what he’s doing this year as a 21-year old is not that different from what Longoria did last year as a 22-year old. Trying to project a far superior career as a hitter based on that alone is a little iffy. Throw in the fact that Longoria is a better defender at a more premium defensive position and Longoria gets the edge. What really seals the deal though, as others have mentioned, is that Upton has actually accrued more service time to date and word is that both Uptons are intent on testing free agency at the earliest opportunity, while Longoria is signed for 8 more years at reasonable-to-downright-cheap rates.

    Comment by Bob — July 20, 2009 @ 6:19 pm

  31. Hurts flexibility? Baseball doesn’t have a salary cap. If an owner is willing to spend a fortune, they can. Its plainly obvious by now that the luxury tax is not a deterrent for some. Anyone team could match that salary, its whether the owner wants to or not.

    Comment by Slick — July 20, 2009 @ 6:47 pm

  32. By your logic, Weiters should be #1, he only has potential going for him right now.

    Comment by Slick — July 20, 2009 @ 6:49 pm

  33. Hey, Simmons had Duncan in the top 5 (No. 2, No. 3, No. 1, No. 2, No. 1, No. 3, No. 3, No. 4) for an entire decade. No reason you cant do that for Longoria.- he’s THAT valuable. Completely untouchable.

    Comment by Sean — July 20, 2009 @ 6:52 pm

  34. Nick– Uh, wrong. What are you, a Red Sox fan? Jesus.

    There’s no guarantee of anything in this game. Somebody offers you a big contract, you take it. Your career is by no means a sure thing. Longoria wants to make money, and he will, he’ll wait until free agency. Thanks for playing.

    Comment by Mark — July 20, 2009 @ 7:55 pm

  35. Trying not to overextend the point, but would you take Cano over Gallardo in this hypothetical draft?

    Comment by Jordan Mader — July 20, 2009 @ 11:53 pm

  36. Look boy genius you just said what they said… They said “NOBODY EXCEPT VERY FEW CLUBS WOULD WANT TO TAKE ON THAT KIND OF SALARY” and it’s clearly obvious that IF the Tigers were to trade Cabrera, it would be to…

    a) Yankees

    b) Mets

    c) Red Sox

    d) Angels

    e) Nats

    f) Orioles

    g) Giants

    That’s 7 teams that would pony up for him because his defense is crap!

    I know Oakland, Texas, Minnesota, Kansas City, Cleveland, Toronto, and Tampa Bay in the AL, along with Florida, Atlanta, Philadelphia, Pittsburgh, Houston, Cincinnati, Chicago (too many big contracts and a change of ownership), St. Louis, Colorado, Arizona, and San Diego in the NL, simply don’t have the payroll flexibility to pay him his contract.

    That leaves Seattle, Chicago (AL), Milwaukee, Los Angeles (NL), who for many reasons could not make sense of Miguel Cabrera on their roster.

    Loney blocks Miguel for years to come and arbitration will eat up the Manny dollars that are available in two years.

    Milwaukee has Prince Fielder now and Gamel in the future, so again no place to play.

    Chicago is done with old vets and big contracts, right now they are trying to unbury themselves from the debt of the last couple years from bad contracts.

    Seattle has learned about big contracts to 1 dimensional players. Ichiro gives you GG defense and All-Star production more consistently than anybody not named Pujols, so yes he’s an exception, but even then his contract isn’t great and leaves a lot of people in Seattle wishing they could move him for the financial flexibility.

    Seattle would see Cabrera as more of a negative than a positive because of their team first mentality that his conditioning program clearly outlines as secondary to all things Miguel. Of course some of these other trade candidates might feel similarly from my list of 7 teams. I think the Giants are desperate for offense and would consider him, but again, like everyone else said, just because there are 7 teams that would consider him, doesn’t mean any of them would feel the pressure to get him. Alex Rodriguez had defense on his side when he was traded to the Yankees, and all the Rangers got was Alfonso Soriano and having to pay $75MM for him to perform on another team. If Alex didn’t have such a rediculous contract, probably they could have got Soriano, and a handful of promising young players. You might be able to get Sanchez from the Giants straight up for Cabrera if the Tigers ate $4-5MM per season. So yeah, Cabrera is NOT a Top 50 acquisition. Even in Seattle where our offense is desperate for a bat… We aren’t THAT desperate… Not even if they ate $5MM a year and took Silva, Batista, and Johjima in return for him.

    Comment by Kurt — July 21, 2009 @ 12:56 am

  37. 1 dimensional players being:

    $6-8MM a year for Vidro (whose 1 dimension became getting more gatorade by the end of the deal.

    $14MM x 2 to can’t hit for power and can’t field for sh*t Sexson.

    $12MM x 4 + 1 to “I can throw strikes, but I can’t keep them from getting hits” Silva.


    $8MM x 3 to a guy who can throw out runners and hit some, but who has a horrible OBP and can’t call a game or work with pitchers worth a d4mn in Johjima. His hitting is .5 dimension, same with his throwing, still two halves just make him 1 dimensional in the end.

    We could probably do this for a ton of teams after the stupid contracts that were signed over the last few years…

    Comment by Kurt — July 21, 2009 @ 1:03 am

  38. You just listed 8 ratings, that would be 2 years less than a decade. I mean if we’re counting…

    Comment by Kurt — July 21, 2009 @ 1:05 am

  39. “There‚Äôs no guarantee of anything in this game. Somebody offers you a big contract, you take it.”

    Well, that’s a very simplistic way of looking at things. Rather, you make a decision based on how much money you’d be losing by signing a contract like Longoria’s vs. how much the added security of a guaranteed amount is worth. It’s a different amount for everybody, obviously Longoria liked the guaranteed money.

    The way he’s been playing, though, he was set to get a lot of money the second he was eligible for arbitration, so the risks were probably pretty minimal. I think Longoria got absolutely hosed, he would have made so much more money than he’s going to now. Those club options are the end are also killer – that’s just poor negotiating by his agent, after the steal the Rays got on the initial part of his contract the least his agent could have done is get him mutual options or something…

    Comment by B — July 21, 2009 @ 8:56 am

  40. No Joey Votto or Yovani Gallardo? Neither have a contract in place, but they are both young and under team control for 3-4 more years.

    Comment by John — July 21, 2009 @ 9:26 am

  41. It all comes down to the contract. Longo is great, but a .359 OBP isn’t *that* special. Perhaps Longo’s agent should have made the list.

    Comment by Marco — July 22, 2009 @ 9:27 am

  42. Longoria is signed to an absurdly below market contract that extends through his prime. Even if you think that Longoria will be just the 25th best player in baseball for the next seven years, you’d be getting him at next to nothing if you traded for him. Upton, on the other hand, is due for arbitration, which means that he’s going to get paid soon and will not likely sell off his FA years as cheaply as Longo did.

    Comment by Fresh Hops — July 23, 2009 @ 1:16 pm

  43. Where the heck is Jason Kendall on this list? I thought he’d at least be top 3… power bat, good speed, high average, canon for an arm…
    or what about Suppan and that lethal fastball
    or Counsell
    or Looper
    or Bush
    or Hall
    or McGehee
    sometimes I hate being a Brewer fan… but then Braun or Fielder belts a HR and reminds me that there is hope if we can get some pitching to fill in around Yo.

    Comment by Eyin — August 1, 2009 @ 3:35 pm

  44. I am a Cards fan, and no way would I trade Albert for those guys in the top three. Pujols is just too freaking awesome.

    Comment by Dylan — August 7, 2009 @ 2:39 pm

  45. I agree with Sky, locking up your arb years is fine if it provides you with the financial security you’re looking for.

    …but man are those option years dumb. Tampa has no leverage over you at that point, why let them have that kind of financial flexibility?

    Comment by Gary — November 9, 2009 @ 12:51 am

  46. Cabrera was an above average defensive player at 1st last year…

    He moved down the defensive spectrum from 3rd to 1st, so just because he was below average at 3rd doesnt mean he will be at 1st..

    His defense got better and better as the season went along… I would have no problem calling for a +5 URZ for 2010!

    Comment by Jeff — January 10, 2010 @ 6:30 pm

  47. I’d trade him for Longoria or HanRam, definitely.

    I agree that I probably wouldn’t pull the trigger on Upton, because he’ll only just be hitting his peak when he reaches free agency, meaning whoever wants him through his peak years is going to have to seriously pony up some cash. He was pretty good last year, at an absurdly young age, but his BABIP was nearly .370 which is unsustainable even for a guy with his speed, and I’m not convinced he’ll put up an 18% HR/FB again, even though Chase Field is pretty friendly to flyball hitters, so perhaps his raw power numbers, OPS and non-park-adjusted wOBA over-rate him somewhat in 2009.

    I also think his defence is yet to kind of “level out”; he’s had some wildly variable UZR ratings and, despite the speed and strong arm, I think it’s hard to say with assurance that he’s a great defender going forward.

    He’s a hell of a player and putting up the numbers he has at 21 is pretty special, but I think his ceiling is questionable enough that I’d rather be paying the greatest player in the game $30m for two years than have Upton under team control for another four years at probably $20m or so.

    Comment by Felonius_Monk — January 18, 2010 @ 11:53 am

  48. The new Nature Miracle: Argan (Just google it and you will see!)To find 100% Certified organic Argan oils, ask the seller to issue the original certificate, mostly ecocert.I have done this with my supplier: 100% Bio Argan:- Certified products- Cosmetic Oils & Cream- Culinary Oils- Bulk OilsI advice any reseller or investor who want to start or continu selling virgin and organic oils to contact ( They have best prices and products quality. They are located in Morocco.

    Comment by Mehdi — February 12, 2010 @ 9:03 pm

  49. Hello, I am pretty impressed by your blogging expertise. I am a blogger myself.

    Comment by vacances au maroc — March 18, 2010 @ 2:49 pm

  50. How often do you use your squash grip for things which would get under most peoples skin.

    Comment by squash ball — March 24, 2011 @ 10:03 am

  51. Just wish to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your post is just spectacular and i can assume you’re an expert on this subject. Well with your permission allow me to grab your feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please carry on the gratifying work.

    Comment by jerseys — October 31, 2011 @ 5:27 am

Leave a comment

Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Close this window.

0.121 Powered by WordPress