Holliday Time in St. Louis?

Rumors are flying throughout the twitterverse that St. Louis is doing some Holliday shopping, and it is expected to come at the expense of their top prospect, Brett Wallace.

Brett Wallace is not-so affectionately dubbed “the Walrus” by scouts for his 6-1, 245 pear-shaped body. Scouts do love his bat though; he was considered to be the best pure hitter of the 2008 draft. In just a season and a half of pro-ball, Wallace has put up a .308/.392/.469 line. This year he started slowly for Triple-A Memphis, but has worked his way up to a respectable .298/.351/.431. Not eye-catching, but certainly not at all shabby for someone who was swinging a metal bat in the Pac-10 just a little over a year ago.

Wallace is not projected to be a big-time power threat, but rather a 15-20 homer guy who hits for a high average and takes his fair share of walks; somewhat of a Kevin Youkilis before he found his power stroke. The biggest knock on Wallace his “fall down range”. He’s defensively challenged at third base to put it mildly, and there is this guy named Pujols in St. Louis who isn’t moving from first base.

Baseball America recently came out with their mid-season top 25, and Wallace ranked 21st. According to Victor Wang — who has published some tremendous research on the hidden value of prospects and the draft — top 11-25 ranked hitters have a trade value of $25 million. Suffice to say, Wallace is a valuable commodity.

Matt Holliday is projected to hit for a .370 wOBA the rest of the season. He’s a good fielder and base-runner, so we can safely figure he will add to the Cardinals a couple of wins, worth $9 million. He’s also a Type-A free agent at the end of the season, meaning an added bonus of some extra draft picks. Once again referring to Victor’s research, that compensation is worth $5 million to a club, not even close to equal value of a top 100 prospect. (Sky also has more light on the subject at BtB. Bookmark it, folks.) Holliday is also due about $6M in salary for the rest of the season.

So two wins plus draft pick compensation minus salary equals about $8 million in value for Holliday. Simple math, folks — $25M > $8M. The trade is actually pretty lopsided when you look at from that perspective. Mozeliak is also faced with the fact that after Brett Wallace, his farm system will be a lot thinner, no pun intended.

Flags fly forever, and Wallace may never quite pan out and is probably not the greatest fit for his parent club.The Cardinals should be buyers at this point, but I wonder if they can’t get a better return than a rental for their top prospect.



Print This Post



Erik Manning is the founder of Future Redbirds and covers the Cardinals for Heater Magazine. You can get more of his analysis and rantings in bite-sized bits by following him on twitter.


Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Joe R
Guest
Joe R

While this makes sense for both teams (Oakland adds yet another good, cost controlled young guy and St. Louis adds a much needed bat in exchange for a guy that probably wouldn’t be getting much playing time there anyway), I also have this question:

What does Oakland do with Daric Barton? Call me crazy for not being willing to write off a 23 year old with a .261/.386/.458 line in AAA in 2009 (albeit in the PCL). It’s still good for 15th in the PCL in OBP and 34th in SLG. Not exactly a future MLB beast line, but seems like he’ll be serviceable after a little more seasoning.

Richie Abernathy
Guest
Richie Abernathy

yeah, that’s serviceable if Barton is putting up that line as a second baseman or a catcher.

Joe R
Guest
Joe R

Ryan Howard went .304/.374/.514 in A+ ball as a 23 year old. I can’t be the only person who hasn’t written off Barton.

Richie Abernathy
Guest
Richie Abernathy

I’d say the scouting reports on Ryan Howard at 23 and Daric Barton are remarkably different when trying to project future power output. I doubt that Barton will top Howard’s new record of fastest to 200 MLB homeruns. Sorry for that. Especially since I know your point is that he’s young and sometimes it takes time to develop. I’m just not sure Barton’s swing profiles for enough power if he is a first baseman. If that’s the case, he’d have to hit for contact like Mark Grace and John Olerud (with their fielding abilities as well) to be an impact player at that position. I personally always believed that Barton’s prospect status was inflated because he was a catcher with great contact skills with a hope of future power. If he can’t catch and the power doesn’t develop and the BABIP falls at higher levels, what you may be left with is a poor man’s Billy Butler.

Joe R
Guest
Joe R

I was thinking more on the lines of Adam LaRoche. Good guy to give $2,000,000 to when you need a one year fix at 1B.

Richie Abernathy
Guest
Richie Abernathy

I was thinking more along the lines of Lyle Overbay, but I’ll give you LaRoche, and yes, you’re not paying him silver slugger first baseman money, either.

Joe R
Guest
Joe R

But yeah, I agree, I’m just arguing that Barton still serves value to the Oakland franchise.

So I assume if this trade happens, Barton’s probably getting shipped off, too. Not sure what kind of hitter a team can get for a 1B with a fairly regular career projection, though.

wpDiscuz