Joe Crede Still Available

In December, I wrote a post about how Joe Crede was falling under the radar in the free agent market in 2010, much like he did in 2009, when he took a $2.5 million incentive-laden contract with the Twins. As I write today’s post, we are a mere two weeks from opening day, and Crede is still looking for a job. Reportedly, Crede isn’t retiring, and is remaining active and hoping for a job offer.

All the projection systems we have on site here project Crede as a -5 to -9 hitter over 600 plate appearances. Despite his injury issues, he still seems to be an excellent defender – his UZR/150 is 10.8 and his best fielding numbers have come in the most recent years. Putting that all together, Crede projects as a slightly above-average player, and even with an assumed injury limited season of 300 plate appearances, that’s 1.0-1.5 WAR.

So what did teams take this winter over Crede? Let’s take a look at some players who were part of the same 3B market as Crede (although some won’t be playing that position next year).

San Francisco re-signed Juan Uribe at $3.25MM, 1.2 proj. WAR
Baltimore acquired Garrett Atkins at $4.5MM, 0.5 proj. WAR
Baltimore signed Miguel Tejada at $6.0MM, 2.3 proj. WAR
Houston signed Pedro Feliz at $4.5MM, 2.0* proj. WAR
San Francisco signed Mark DeRosa at $6MM, 1.9 proj. WAR
Chicago (AL) acquired Mark Teahen at $3.75MM, 1.5 proj. WAR

And three other players have signed minor league contracts:
Texas signed Matt Brown, -0.5 proj. WAR
Los Angeles (AL) signed Robb Quinlan, -0.5 proj. WAR
Arizona signed Chad Tracy, -0.1 proj. WAR

San Francisco passed on Crede in two different situations, passing on the better 3B value in order to take the more versatile players in Uribe and DeRosa. In the case of Baltimore, Tejada is certainly a better hitter than Crede and less of an injury risk. Crede, however, is certainly the better fielder, and that makes their talent levels roughly even. It’s hard to imagine Crede not providing both a better value and more wins than Atkins.

For the Astros, Crede is just simply a better fit than Feliz. Feliz’s CHONE projection includes a very optimistic fielding projection of +9, which doesn’t fit with his progressively dropping UZR ratings and his advanced age of 34. It’s likely that Crede would provide more value both in the sense of the contract and wins than Feliz. Similarly, I think Crede would’ve been a better fit for the White Sox as opposed to the defensively challenged Teahen, and he wouldn’t have cost them as much money nor the control of Chris Getz and Josh Fields.

There are still some potential fits out there for Crede. I think he would make good Brandon Wood insurance for the Angels. A similar situation would be in St. Louis, where he could serve as David Freese insurance, but that role seems to have fallen on Felipe Lopez. It seems like a lack of versatility is what has hurt Crede’ options this winter, but Crede is still a talented player, and I would be surprised if he doesn’t latch on somewhere at some point in the season.

Print This Post

Jack Moore's work can be seen at VICE Sports and anywhere else you're willing to pay him to write. Buy his e-book.

10 Responses to “Joe Crede Still Available”

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
  1. cpebbles says:

    Nice as it would be to land a hometown boy at a discount, there just isn’t any place for Crede on the Cardinals barring injury. Freese projects to be a league-average player, as does Felipe Lopez. Between Lugo, Craig, and Mather, they should fill out the rest of the bench quite nicely for the league minimum. If Crede was a lefty, this could be going somewhere.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  2. Kid Charlemagne says:

    The key component here that you’re missing is injury history – Crede hasn’t played 100 games since 2006. In the past two years Feliz has played more than a hundred more games than Crede.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

    • MikeS says:

      I think unreliability hasn’t been factored into this analysis. No matter how little you pay him, it’s out the door if he can’t play.

      It’s really a shame. As a White Sox fan, I truly appreciate that defense now that it’s gone.

      Vote -1 Vote +1

  3. Sam A says:

    Crede missed a lot of games last year while with the Twins. He did not hit the DL until September, so the team played dozens of games short one player while Crede was day-to-day with various injuries.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  4. CJ says:

    As I recall, Crede’s agent is Scott Boras. Given Crede’s history, he would have to take a significant discount in order to sign during this past off-season. It’s one thing to say that he projects at 1 or 1.5 WAR, but there is significant possibility that he could fall off a cliff too, either due to injury or loss of ability. Most teams would be reluctant to pay him more than $1 – 1.5 million, IMO. Perhaps Boras was holding out for a salary which is too high.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  5. Steve says:

    Does this analysis factor in the player who will have to play the other half of the season for Crede, a player likely to be replacement level or worse?

    In that case, does he grade out ahead of guys like Teahan, Atkins, Feliz, etc?

    Crede can only add value if he’s on the field. And he’s shown zero ability to stay healthy for 3 years running.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  6. JoeyO says:

    “Arizona signed Chad Tracy, -0.1 proj. WAR”

    Tracy signed with the Cubs, not the DBacks.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  7. Michael says:

    Lots of concerns here about the injury risk of Crede, but I think Jack mentioned it. CHONE projects Crede at 1.6 WAR in 400 or so PA. If you think there’s an injury concern, knock his PA down to whatever your think it should be. If you think he’ll get 200 PA, bring him down to 0.8 WAR. That already includes the threat of him being replaced, because presumably a replacement level 3B would be worth 0 WAR.

    Look at Feliz. CHONE projects 2 WAR over 550 PA, but as Jack mentioned, much of that is based on a very optimistic defensive projection. Knock him down to +5 defensively (what the Fans are projecting for him) and you get more like a 1.5 WAR player in 550 PA.

    Where’s the breakeven point? You would need 384 PA of Crede to match up to 550 PA of Feliz. From there, it’s your bet whether can make it to 384 PA and an equivalent number of games on the field. In the last three seasons, he made it around there twice, and made it to half of that the third year. So it’s your call, but you have to think some teams would take a flier on him over someone like Uribe or Feliz.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  8. ineedanap says:

    Angels have Macier Izturis in case Brandon Wood fails.

    I’d take him a a minor league deal, but between Boras and finding someone to play in the other 72 games, it seems like too much of a hassle to bother.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  9. Joey B says:

    Joe Crede is a BUMB

    Vote -1 Vote +1

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>