Kendrys Morales and Partial Uselessness

As facts about Kendrys Morales go, here are a few of them. On Wednesday, Morales was traded from the Angels to the Mariners in exchange for Jason Vargas. Morales is and has always been a switch-hitter as a professional. Morales began switch-hitting when he was 12 years old, and the right side is his natural side. That is, Morales naturally bats right-handed, and he had to learn how to swing as a lefty. Every switch-hitter starts off with a natural side, but what’s interesting about the Morales case is this:

Career as a lefty: 127 wRC+
Career as a righty: 84 wRC+

Morales has thrived from his unnatural side, and struggled from his natural side. You can pull off an 84 wRC+ if you’re a shortstop or a center fielder or a pitcher, but not so much if you’re a 1B/DH. For his career, as a right-handed hitter, Morales has been unhelpful.

I don’t know what the consensus is on switch-hitters, but most people probably think of them as mirror images. They probably think Player X is more or less Player X no matter which side he’s standing on. Of course we shouldn’t expect that to be true — different sides are stronger than others — and it isn’t true in the case of Morales. The sample size as a righty is limited, perhaps too limited for absolute comfort, but my understanding is that platoon splits for switch-hitters stabilize pretty fast, and Morales’ separation is enormous.

If we dig deeper, we can find more of interest:

as LHB wOBA ISO
Pull 0.480 0.381
Center 0.450 0.289
Opposite 0.321 0.122
as RHB wOBA ISO
Pull 0.313 0.168
Center 0.347 0.182
Opposite 0.372 0.276

Batting left-handed, Morales has been a pretty conventional pull hitter with power up the middle, too. He’s yanked a lot of home runs to right-center field, and a lot of those home runs have been impressive. Batting right-handed, Morales has had the majority of his success up the middle and especially the other way. As a righty, Morales has had his power to right field. There’s no particular Angel Stadium park factor we should be taking into consideration right here. Morales has just done his damage to center and right, regardless of where he’s stood.

If we know that Morales has been worse as a righty, and if we know that he’s hit as a righty to the opposite field, what that suggests is that Morales has been later to get around. We can’t refer to him as a punch hitter or a slap hitter, because those isolated sluggings are substantial. Morales has had power from his natural side. Just not so much pull power. Morales’ strikeout rate has been a little lower from the right side than from the left side. Historically, there’s been no difference in swing rate, and there’s been no significant difference in contact rate. It’s the batted-ball profile that’s different.

Before we move on, I suppose I should show you some dinger .gifs. This is a post topic that cries out for images. We should get an idea of what Morales’ swings actually look like. These are all from 2012.

Morales certainly looks powerful from the right side, just as from the left side. Although, granted, I selected clips of home runs, so, yeah. His stances are open, but Morales holds his hands a little higher as a lefty, and he seems to have a more pronounced step. When you have a guy who generates different results, you expect that there will be differences in swing mechanics. Some are easily observed, and I’m not even good at analyzing this sort of thing. If you are, you might see far, far more.

So we’ve established that Morales has been relatively unsuccessful batting right-handed, despite that being his natural side. Now we wonder: are there any signs of improvement, or is this just what Morales is? I did a lot of Googling, and below I’m going to present a few article excerpts:

October 2009:

“His right-handed swing came alive in the second half of the season. That’s important.”

Finding his stroke from his natural right side — he began switch-hitting at age 12 — enabled Morales to play every day after sitting against most lefties early in the season.

April 2010:

Morales made strides in the second half and worked all winter in Miami — taking batting practice six days a week — to refine his right-handed stroke. He also sought out his former hitting coach in Cuba, Miguel Valdez, who had also defected. Valdez filmed him and then tinkered with his right-handed stance.
[…]
“This guy’s got a great swing from both sides. … There’s not going to be much difference when it’s all said and done, I don’t believe,” manager Mike Scioscia said.

August 2009:

“I’ve been able to see the ball better from that side, reading patterns,” Morales said, having raised his average against lefties to .275 and his slugging percentage to .475. “I made a couple of adjustments with my hands.”

Morales didn’t bat a whole lot against left-handed pitchers in 2012, which makes it look like he was being strictly platooned. He basically was, but there were reasons for that: Morales needed some occasional days off, and the Angels needed to play the right-handed Mark Trumbo. In 2010, before getting hurt, Morales wasn’t platooned, nor was he platooned down the stretch in 2009. It’s unclear at this point just what the Angels wound up thinking about Morales as a switch-hitter.

But, in one of the excerpts above, Scioscia says that Morales really found his right-handed swing in 2009’s second half. I’m dreadfully uncomfortable splitting an already small sample like this, but watch what happens if you split Morales’ career at the 2009 All-Star break:

Through ’09 ASB, as a righty: .224/.242/.336
Since ’09 ASB, as a righty: .269/.315/.472

Now the picture looks a little different. We already said that platoon splits for switch-hitters tend to stabilize quickly. Does that mean they can re-stabilize quickly? Is Morales not as useless as his overall career split?

It’s interesting that, for his career, Morales has pulled the ball 40% of the time batting lefty, but 43% of the time batting righty. We wouldn’t have thought that, based on the power profile included above. But of more interest to me are groundballs. Groundballs should not be a big part of Kendrys Morales’ game, on account of he’s Kendrys Morales, just look at him, I mean come on. He’s an aggressive power hitter. So:

Split GB%
LHB, 06-08 45%
LHB, 09-12 45%
RHB, 06-08 60%
RHB, 09-12 50%

Nothing doing in the left-handed swing. In the right-handed swing, we see a significant drop in groundball rate, as Morales has done a better job of putting the ball in the air, where it belongs (for him). Last season, Morales actually hit more grounders from the left side than from the right side. Last season, from the right side, Morales slugged .471. The sample is small, but performance is performance, and Morales wasn’t even 100% coming back from injury.

Overall, Kendrys Morales has not been much of a switch-hitter, as he’s been fairly unproductive batting right-handed, which is a big part of any switch-hitter’s job. Given Morales’ career splits, one assumes the Mariners should think about platooning him going forward. Yet there are signs that Morales might have made substantial progress over the years. It’s hard to say anything for sure, given the nature of the sample sizes we’re dealing with, but Morales might not actually be partially useless, as he used to be. His natural side might be catching up, and for a guy a year away from free agency, there are worse career possibilities.



Print This Post



Jeff made Lookout Landing a thing, but he does not still write there about the Mariners. He does write here, sometimes about the Mariners, but usually not.


Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
I'm hilarious.
Guest
I'm hilarious.
3 years 8 months ago

#6org

taste the tears
Guest
taste the tears
3 years 8 months ago

Hit a nerve with that one!

Dead Horse
Guest
Dead Horse
3 years 8 months ago

Ow. Stop it.

Ruki Motomiya
Member
Ruki Motomiya
3 years 8 months ago

Who would the Mariners platoon him with? The Angels could have platooned him with Trumbo, but it might be wiser for the Mariners to see how he does from the right side before platooning.

Erik
Guest
3 years 8 months ago

Morales is fine from the right side. He had some issues when he was younger that he has gotten over in my opinion. His platooning last season had everything to do with his inability to play every day and the fact that there were other players who were better against lefties. No reason to play the right handed Trumbo and give Morales the day off against a righty.

joser
Guest
joser
3 years 8 months ago

Morales has just done his damage to center and right, regardless of where he’s stood.

This is not a bad thing for a guy playing half his games at Safeco, whatever the effect of the new fences.

river-z
Guest
river-z
3 years 8 months ago

And let’s not forget that this past season Morales hit 2 home runs in the same inning, one from each side of the plate. That was really something.

Travis
Guest
3 years 8 months ago

Small sample size. ;D

Tim
Guest
Tim
3 years 8 months ago

I wonder if Morales is strongly right-eye dominant. That’s the explanation that springs to mind for me.

Joel
Guest
Joel
3 years 8 months ago

Need to get him a Pirate patch.

payroll
Guest
payroll
3 years 8 months ago

I thought the same thing, but, he would be unique. If you assume throwing handed-ness is the same as eye dominance, and then look at Lance Berkman or mark texeira you’ll find the opposite is actually true. Instead, I would be curious to see how Morales’s splits break down by pitch type. Maybe he is better as an aggressive fastball hitter early in counts from the left side, and does better from the right side by getting ahead in counts and sitting on breaking balls and changeups, for example.

payroll
Guest
payroll
3 years 8 months ago

The other thing, Morales has had less than 400 PAs against LHP. My understanding for non-switch hitters anyway, was that a hitter needs to see at least 1000 pitchers of both hands before his platoon splits stabilize.

payroll
Guest
payroll
3 years 8 months ago

*1000 PAs

James
Guest
3 years 8 months ago

I’m righthanded. Played all sports right handed. But, shoot pool and guns lefty. And did so naturally without practice or thought. Never figured out why, except it was a comfort thing.

Hurtlockertwo
Guest
Hurtlockertwo
3 years 8 months ago

There is a long list of HOF players, Ted Williams for one, that batted exclusively left handed but were natural right handers.

Paul AB
Guest
Paul AB
3 years 8 months ago

Ichiro.

Terry Benish
Guest
Terry Benish
3 years 8 months ago

If you look at his stats the year before he was hurt he had an OPS of .866 against lh starters.

So last year he gets 63 plate appearances as a rh batter and you base your piece on that. The last two and one half months suggests he might revert to 2009 rather than what you suggest.

Baltar
Guest
Baltar
3 years 8 months ago

Yes, he may have improved some as a rightie, but since the handedness advantage is only about 10%, why doesn’t he just always hit leftie?

jim
Guest
jim
3 years 8 months ago

it may be that he can’t pick up left-handed pitching at all as a LHB

Dobbs
Guest
Dobbs
3 years 8 months ago

Morales hitting right-handed only up until 12 may or may not mean that he was meant to hit right-handed.

I’m left-handed, but as a child I didn’t want to bat or throw left-handed because my brothers did it right-handed. At 27 years old I picked up a bat after 10 years away from baseball and after a couple months of hitting right-handed, tried out hitting lefty and it was definitely my stronger side.

Move forward 8 years, I have a right-handed throwing 2 year old who hits left-handed simply because it was the way I showed him. In the end, perhaps he’d be a more natural right-handed hitter if he decides to switch-hit.

Apone007
Guest
Apone007
3 years 8 months ago

This is pretty simple. KM has better mechanics from the left side. He has less movement and jerks his wrists better. The right side has a lot of bad habits built in, most likely because it was the swing he used growing up. Hence he hits towards right center and does not pull as much right handed. Also, the inside heater eats him up batting right handed.

wpDiscuz