Newman’s Own: Best Second Basemen Of 2012

Seeing prospects in person is my passion. In 2012, I was fortunate enough to visit parks in five different leagues — collecting information and video on 200 legitimate prospects or more. The lists released over the next few weeks will highlight the best prospects I’ve seen in person at each position during the 2012 season. The rankings will be adjusted based on projected position at the major league level, not present position (in italics if ranking includes position shift). Additionally, I’ll do my best to rank based on notes/video from the park and avoid adjusting for statistics after the fact. Keep this in mind when working through the lists and understand this is not meant to be a complete list of the best prospects at each position across all of Minor League Baseball, but the best of what I’ve seen.

Previous Rankings:
The Catchers
The First Basemen

1. Nick Franklin, Seattle Mariners (SS)

At 21, Franklin combines the defensive skills and offensive performance to profile as the highest floor prospect on this list by a wide margin. Young for Double-A and Triple-A competition, Franklin’s PCL numbers translate to .314/.395/.547 against age-appropriate competition. He’s not an impact talent, but one scout compared him to Adam Kennedy whose career stands at 14 years and counting.

2. Angelo Gumbs, New York Yankees

The most explosive athlete on this list, Gumbs oozes tools and has bat speed to spare. Gumbs has a lower floor than a number of second baseman ranked below him on the list, but nobody else has the potential of being an impact talent either. Amazing to think he was the fourth best position prospect on his own team in Charleston.

3. Jorge Polanco, Minnesota Twins

At 18, Polanco posted a .312/.383/.509 triple slash line in the Appalachian League and fit in nicely amongst fellow prospects on an Elizabethton team featuring up to eight of the Twins top-12. A switch hitter, Polanco appeared equally strong from both sides of the plate during batting practice and took infield reps at shortstop before sliding across the diamond during the game. I always want to see full season baseball on a prospect’s resume before becoming too excited about a player, but Polanco is off to an explosive start.

4. Henry Rodriguez, Cincinnati Reds

Color me enamored with Rodriguez’ hit tool — the best on this list. He’s undersized and may not provide much in terms of power production, but I saw few better pure hitters in 2012. My only real concern about his offensive game is a walk rate which may leave the 22-year old too batting average dependent. If I were an opposing general manager, I’d be inquiring with Brandon Phillips entrenched in Cincinnati.

5. Drew Robinson, Texas Rangers

I went to Greenville with little knowledge of who Drew Robinson was, but left thinking he was one of the better baseball players scouted all season. His tools aren’t loud, but the 20-year old presents with no real weakness in person. “Statifiles” point to Matt Skole‘s .438 OBP as a 22/23 year old in the South Atlantic League, but Robinson’s was .409 at 33 months Skole’s junior. Add a bit of power and the ability to play both second and third base admirably, and Robinson has a higher floor than anybody on this list not named Franklin.

6. Mookie Betts, Boston Red Sox

Mookie or Scooter? Scooter or Mookie? If name value were the name of this game, then the 6th and 7th ranked players on this list would be slam dunks for the top two slots. In all seriousness, Betts has the combination of tools and athleticism I covet in a prospect. For Lowell, Betts presented with the range of a shortstop, but multiple throwing errors made including him on this list an easy decision. I know a .307 slugging percentage is uninspiring, but Betts flashed gap power in game action in addition to above average plate discipline. Combine this with the defensive tools of at least an above average second baseman, and the 19-year old is primed to shoot up the Red Sox prospect ranks with a strong 2013 in Greenville.

7. Scooter Gennett, Milwaukee Brewers

If I had a dollar for every time a scout referred to a diminutive prospect as “a nice little player”, I’d be writing baseball for a living. On the field, Gennett is the poster boy for this sentiment as he does everything relatively well, but has no standout skill or tool to speak of. One concern about the 22-year old is that his OPS his dropped steadily each season as he’s moved up the organizational ladder. Gennett’s inability to play shortstop in a pinch hurts a potential utility profile leaving his big league prospects a bit murky should he not emerge as at least a second division starter.

8. Branden Kaupe, New York Mets

How does one spin a .173 average and .195 slugging percentage into a positive? I have no idea, but I’m willing to give it a try. After being a surprise fourth round pick out of a Hawaii high school, Kaupe posted a .358 OBP in his lower 48 debut at a time when he should have been overwhelmed in all areas offensively. The 18-year old has the bat speed, foot speed and build of a Jose Altuve clone if everything breaks right. Having scouted Altuve at the South Atlantic League level, I’m more willing to give a guy like Kaupe a longer leash than I once was.

9. Tony Renda, Washington Nationals

Another “nice little player”, Renda has foot and bat speed to spare, but showed little pop in his short season debut. A second round pick who probably would have gone lower had the Nationals not shot for the moon by drafting Lucas Giolito, Renda has a big league projection, but little upside to speak of. Like Gennett, Renda not being able to play any shortstop hurts his versatility and negatively impacts his prospect value.

10. Jake Lemmerman, Los Angeles Dodgers (SS)

Is Jake Lemmerman a future big leaguer? I think so, but there’s just not much upside in a utility profile these days. He presents with no glaring weakness, but identifiable strengths are not there either. At 23, I’m a bit concerned his baseball skills will fall short of offsetting Lemmerman’s lack of tools leaving a player with more of an up and down profile in the end.

11. Matt Reynolds, New York Mets (SS)

Speaking of utility profiles, Mets second round pick Matt Reynolds also projects as a jack of all trades type with no stand out tool. I commend New York for trying him at shortstop, but he’s probably not long for the position. Maybe he can function as a third shortstop option on a big league roster, but that’s about it. In Savannah, his contact skills were relatively strong, but Reynolds approach is conducive to less power than his muscular frame would indicate.

12. Kenny Diekroger, Kansas City Royals

Once considered one of the top preps in the country, Diekroger struck out a startling 27% of the time in his Appalachian League debut. I can see him developing into a utility player, but he’s a greater risk to meet that projection than the two players ranked ahead of him in Lemmerman and Reynolds. Based on Diekroger’s Stanford pedigree, he should have dominated short season baseball, not struggled in it.

13. Tyler Greene, Philadelphia Phillies

only 19, Green suffered through a disastrous 2012 batting only .195 with a 122/23 strikeout-to-walk ratio across two levels. In Auburn, New York, I witnessed a Williamsport coach dress down Greene after a lethargic infield/outfield practice only to appear disinterested in the actual game. In general, it’s considered a positive for a young prospect to experience failure at the minor league level. However, it’s only a productive exercise if the player matures and improves from that adversity.



Print This Post



Mike Newman is the Owner/Managing Editor ofROTOscouting, a subscription site focused on baseball scouting, baseball prospects and fantasy baseball. Follow me onTwitter. Likeus on Facebook.Subscribeto my YouTube Channel.


Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
A
Guest
A
3 years 10 months ago

Comparing Franklin to Kennedy seems odd to me. Did that comp mean production-wise or actual tools-wise? Franklin should have much more power than Kennedy at least.

lonestarball
Guest
3 years 10 months ago

Are you including Odor with the shortstops, or did he just not make the cut?

Daniel
Guest
Daniel
3 years 10 months ago

No Jon Schoop? Or were you not able to see him this year? I know his numbers are kinda pedestrian but for his age at AA he seemed solid.

reillocity
Guest
reillocity
3 years 10 months ago

You posted before that you saw Roman Quinn. If he had to be moved off short and to second, where would you slot him on this list as of today?

Preston
Guest
Preston
3 years 10 months ago

Does Gumbs have the arm to play SS? They moved him so that he and Culver could both play everday, Culver’s not really blocking Gumbs moving back to the left side anymore.

MikeS
Guest
MikeS
3 years 10 months ago

The link for the catchers goes o the first basemen.

wanderin
Guest
wanderin
3 years 10 months ago

I believe that the Reds are going forward with moving Henry Rodriguez to 3B in the future. He will still get some PT backing up Phillips, but I think we’ll see him at 3B more often going forward once Rolen retires.

I think a competition between Frazier and Rodriguez for a starting role will eventually transpire. The victor gets 3B, while the other gets the utility role. I see there being room enough for both going forward.

Cliff
Guest
Cliff
3 years 10 months ago

I’m assuming that Stefan Romero was omitted from this list because you see him more as a 1B rather than 2B….who woud you rank higher?…Romero or Franklin? Mainly in terms of hitting. Also, with Franklin, Romero, Smoak, Ackley, Carp, Miller, and Seager all vying for essentially 4 spots, what do you see as the starting 4 in 2013? 2014?

I was thinking next year to start, it will prolly sill be Smoak, Ackey, Ryan, and Seager…but by June, Smak will have been demoted after hitting .207, Ryay will be relegated to bench after the Ms realize he literally cannot hit AT ALL. Any chance Romero and/or Franklin are regulars by June 2013?

danny
Guest
danny
3 years 10 months ago

I was hoping Franklin might see some time at SS in Seattle in 2013. Would seem like a fit to bring him up with Ryan to caddy. Is he for sure a 2B now?

MSom13
Guest
MSom13
3 years 10 months ago

I’m assuming you didn’t see Kolten Wong? Can you make a reasonable guess as to where he’d project?

Clifford
Guest
Clifford
3 years 10 months ago

From what ive read with Wong, hes gonna end up being a much better real-life player for the Cards than a fantasy player. i think ive read .280-.290+, 10 HR, 20 SB with high run totals. also pretty sure hes an elite defender.

Kolten Wong
Guest
Kolten Wong
3 years 10 months ago

I’ll hit .310 on the reg, not .280. I’ll hit 10 HR before the all-star break. 20 SB? Try 50. I’m better than you. GOLD GLOVES. Back off, Clifford.

Will
Guest
Will
3 years 10 months ago

I really like these lists, knowing you’ve actually seen the prospects. Jorge Polanco played the season at second base, but I assumed that was mainly because the team wanted to give Niko Goodrum as much time as possible to develop at SS. However, John Sickels says he sees Polanco as more suited to 2B. What did you think? Could he work out at SS? How is his defense overall?

Drew
Guest
3 years 10 months ago

Did you see Eddie Rosario? I’m guessing that he would be on the list, but maybe not. One thought for the future installments – maybe include a list of guys that might make the list but are ineligible because you did not see them in person. That will give the readers more information while also preempting a number of “what about X” comments.

Thanks, and I’m looking forward to the rest of the series.

Drew

Richard Leo
Guest
Richard Leo
3 years 9 months ago

Hi mike, have you seen Anderson Feliz this year? and what’s your opinion on him?

chucknchino
Guest
chucknchino
3 years 9 months ago

Hi Mike, great stuff! Did you get a chance to see cory spangenberg? Thoughts…

wpDiscuz