Pirates Push For Postseason, Acquire Wandy

Prior to the trade deadline, many expected the Pittsburgh Pirates to leverage their talented farm system to acquire an impact bat. After all, their offense has a combined .302 wOBA, and they penciled in a batting order on Tuesday evening that featured five players (not including the pitcher) with an on-base percentage below .300.

That big bat may still be in the cards this week, but the Pirates temporarily shifted their focus to the starting rotation and acquired southpaw Wandy Rodriguez from the Houston Astros in return for three minor league players — outfielder Robbie Grossman and lefties Colton Cain and Rudy Owens.

The starting rotation for the Pirates was not necessarily a pain-point for the organization, as the group had compiled a 3.95 ERA and 3.92 FIP on the season thus far. Room for improvement existed, however, as right-hander Kevin Correia still took the mound every fifth day with a 4.31 ERA and 4.95 FIP. His ZiPS projection throughout the remainder of the season only forecasts pain, too, as it predicts him to post a 5.40 ERA and 4.83 FIP from here on out.

Trading for Wandy Rodriguez allows the Pirates to remove Correia from the starting rotation and replace him with a more consistent, more effective pitcher.

Rodriguez has seen his swinging-strike rate drop in each of the past three seasons and his strikeout rate is the lowest since his rookie year in 2005, but the 33-year-old continues to find success on the mound by throwing strikes and keeping the baseball on the ground. His 2.20 BB/9 walk rate and 50.7% ground ball rate are both the best marks of his career. Those two factors have helped Rodriguez post a better-than-average 3.79 ERA (97 ERA-) and 3.77 FIP (98 FIP-) this year.

Look for him to continue his success in Pittsburgh. He now moves to PNC Park, which has suppressed home runs in 2012 at the fourth-highest rate across the league. This will benefit Wandy Rodriguez because he can continue to flip up his nasty curveball, yet not get beaten by his pedestrian fastball as often as he did in Minute Maid Park in Houston.

Of the home runs surrendered this season, ten of the eleven he has surrendered came off his fastball. Opposing hitters have a .226 ISO against his fastball and only swing-and-miss against it 4.1% of the time. All of that speaks to his fastball being a fringe-average pitch, especially when considering it only averages 89 MPH at this point in his career. PNC Park will help mitigate the damage against his fastball.

Rodriguez will be owed $13M next season and now has a player option worth $13M in 2014. The Pirates will only pay $8.5M of his contract next season, and if the left-hander exercises his option for 2014, the Pirates only pay $7.5M of the contract. That leaves Pittsburgh with a maximum $16M commitment in 2013 and 2014 for an unspectacular, but effective mid-rotation pitcher, who has not compiled an ERA over 4.00 since the 2007 season. He is a two-to-three win pitcher annually and will certainly improve the Pirates’ starting rotation down the stretch in the battle for the NL Central pennant.

To acquire Wandy Rodriguez, the Pirates surrendered a trio of prospects that will provide even more depth to the Astros’ burgeoning farm system. Our own Marc Hulet has in-depth scouting reports available on the Grossman, Cain, and Owens. The consensus seems to be, though, that Houston acquired more depth than high-end talent in terms of prospects in this deal.

New Astros’ GM Jeff Luhnow understood the mess he inherited in Houston and has engaged in a full-scale rebuilding project. Take a look at the prospects acquired this month, including their Baseball America team ranking prior to the season:

Player ’12 BA Ranking
3B Matt Dominguez 4-Miami
LHP Rob Rasmussen 7-Miami
RHP Joe Musgrove 20-Toronto
RHP Asher Wojciechowski 10-Toronto
LHP David Rollins UR-Toronto
C Carlos Perez 14-Toronto
RHP Matthew Heidenreich UR-Chicago (AL)
LHP Blair Walters 26-Chicago (AL)
OF Robbie Grossman 8-Pittsburgh
LHP Colton Cain 13-Pittsburgh
LHP Rudy Owens 16-Pittsburgh

One could argue that Houston has failed to acquire a true top-tier prospect this season, which is valid, but the Astros have not traded away any elite talent, either. Luhnow has moved his assets to accumulate talent and depth in a system that ranked amongst the worst in all of baseball just a couple of seasons ago. The rebuilding project in Houston will not become successful with an elite prospect or two. Instead, it will take a completely new wave of talent. The organization has begun working toward that gameplan this summer with a flurry of trades, which effectively transform their minor league system for the upcoming seasons.

For the Pirates, they acquired a mid-rotation pitcher in Wandy Rodriguez, which will allow them to jettison Kevin Correia from the starting staff. It will be interesting to see if this deal is just a precursor to a move for an impact bat, or if the organization believes themselves to be in a good position for a postseason berth, given the inclusion of the second Wild Card.

The Pirates are not going “all-in” for the 2012 season with a rental. Instead, they acquired an upgrade in the starting rotation for through at least 2013 without sacrificing their future core in the farm system. This is not a one-time grab at baseball relevancy. The Pittsburgh Pirates want to build a perennial contender. Unlike many mid-season trades, Wandy Rodriguez helps them accomplish that goal.

Print This Post

J.P. Breen is a graduate student at the University of Chicago. For analysis on the Brewers and fantasy baseball, you can follow him on Twitter (@JP_Breen).

13 Responses to “Pirates Push For Postseason, Acquire Wandy”

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
  1. CabreraDeath says:

    Good article. I think they need and will get a bat, particularly a corner OF/IF profile.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  2. marcello says:

    The Astros approach under Luhnow reminds of the Pirates approach when Huntington took over. Which is to say, I think they are clearly starting off in the right direction.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

    • Cidron says:

      sell anything and everything of value, burn down the remain, and start from scratch, huh?

      Vote -1 Vote +1

      • Ryan S says:

        Value is all perspective. A 33 year old starting pitcher like Wandy Rodriguez has more value to a team chasing a division title than it does to a team that is just starting a rebuild process. There are certainly players on the Astros that have value that would not make sense to trade.

        Vote -1 Vote +1

    • Bob says:

      Agreed, slow and steady wins the race for a team that is in ruins.

      Vote -1 Vote +1

  3. jesse says:

    I think this is another huge step for Pittsburgh, not because wandy is great, but they traded off decent prospect who are around to provide mainly depth. Meaning the biggest thing they parted with in the deal was money. While it is just 16m over two years, still these are not the penny pinching pirates of the past.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

    • Melkman says:

      Great trade, i believe they also received cash along with Wandy, though not sure how much. Also, no they are not the cheap, penny pinching pirates of the past anymore, now ownership is seeing results with Huntington as GM so they are more willing to invest in players he believes in. Exciting time to be a Pirate fan. It’s so obvious that they need another bat in the COF, (or 1B if u believe G.Jones can handle RF). Of course Upton would be perfect but its looking less and less likely that it will happen.

      Vote -1 Vote +1

  4. Ryan S says:

    this should help Wandy’s value as the Pirates, while not exactly the Rangers or Yankees in offensive output, are still putting up far more runs than the Astros. Also the park in Houston is pretty tough on southpaws with the short porch in left. When you look at his periph home/road splits this year he’s a much better pitcher away from Houston than he is in it. While the ERA doesn’t reflect that, his FIP is nearly a full run better on the road. So moving to a park that surpresses right handed power should greatly benefit him. When you also take into consideration that he’s a supreme groundball pitcher and the Pirates defense is lightyears ahead of Houston it should also help limit the number of baserunners

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  5. jose says:

    How about Soriano from the Cubs? I know his defensive liabilities wont endear him with many, but he can still bat. And given better protection in the Pirate’s lineup than with the Cubs, might produce some good numbers. The Cubs would probably eat a significant part of the money, too.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  6. jacob glick says:

    I wonder if the Pirates are considering trading James McDonald. He’s young, cheap, and his value will probably never be higher; he should fetch some good hitting talent, which the Pirates desperately need. The addition of Rodriguez will help keep the rotation solid until Cole and Taillon arrive.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  7. Tom Au says:

    The acquisition of Wandy Rodriguez “frees up” weaker Pirates’ pitchers for trade: Kevin Correia, Erik Bedard, and most of all, Brad Lincoln.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  8. Butters says:

    “One could argue that Houston has failed to acquire a true top-tier prospect this season….”

    Um, yeah. In fact, it cannot rationally be argued otherwise. This so-called “depth” they’ve gathered would better be described as, you know, “garbage.”

    Grossman has a chance to be a 2-3 WAR player, mebbe even a bit better over his prime years. But ALL the others, Pirate farmhands or otherwise, are dreck — and the author insults us by suggesting any different.

    “New wave of talent”? “Transform”? Give me a break, Breen. You yourself showed us these guys — again, all but Grossman — were basically about as highly-rated & useful as a one-legged man at an ass-kicking contest…and THEN you try to tell us they have some semblence of REAL value because…um…oh, right, because the Houston farm system has recently been SO dreadful that adding any discarded fecal matter from another organization MUST therefore qualify as a meaningful upgrade.

    Go back to school for a logic course. Grade school.

    Vote -1 Vote +1