Scherzer, Ortiz, and a Bullpen Implosion: The Red Sox Rally to Take Game Two

Ten strikeouts swinging. Three strikeouts looking. Six strikeouts on sliders. Four strikeouts on fastballs. Three strikeouts on changeups.

Max Scherzer was brilliant. He allowed just two hits over seven innings and walked off he mound with a 5-1 lead. His team’s win expectancy stood at 96 percent.

It wasn’t enough. The resilient Red Sox rallied to beat the Tigers 6-5 and even the ALCS at one game apiece. As Boston manager John Farrell put it, “Tonight was almost a tale of two different games inside one.”

The last two innings were a tale of woe for the Tigers bullpen. Detroit manager Jim Leyland used four relievers in the eighth, and each was charged with a run. A two-out grand slam by David Ortiz, off Joaquin Benoit, tied the game. A fifth reliever, Rick Porcello, came on for the ninth and failed to record an out. He took the loss after Jarrod Saltalamacchia lined a walk-off single.

The Ortiz home run overshadowed Scherzer’s outing, which was every bit as good as Anibal Sanchez’s Game One gem. The presumptive American League Cy Young award winner took a no-hitter into the sixth inning and mesmerized Boston bats throughout.

He set the tone early. The first batter of the game, Jacoby Ellsbury, was retired on a full-count changeup. From that point on, Red Sox batters had no idea what Scherzer would throw on any given count. His first nine outs were recorded on four fastballs, three changeups and two sliders.

As Leyland said after the game, “When they’re looking for a fastball, you try to throw something else. It’s a cat-and-mouse game. He was terrific. It’s a shame to let that one get away, but that’s baseball.”

Was it ever. It may have been a hard game for Tigers fans to stomach, but for baseball purists, it was pure theater. That made it an ideal stage for Ortiz, whose proclivity for big hits in the postseason has become legendary.

“It was a changeup, just a little up, and he put a good swing on it,” explained Tigers catcher Alex Avila. “He just got it out. To be honest, when he initially hit it, I didn’t think it had enough. It just kept going. Torii [Hunter] got pretty close to it. I wasn’t sure, but then the crowd started cheering, so I knew it was gone,”

Lefthander Phil Coke — against whom Ortiz is 2 for 18 — was warming up in the bullpen and had a great vantage point.

“Torii looked like he had a bead on it,” said Coke. “I looked to see where the wall was, where he was, and where the ball was. When Torii jumped up, I thought he had it. He missed it by just that much.

“When he flipped over that wall, I was kind of freaked out. I was hoping he was OK. Everybody started waving the trainer out, so I was hoping he didn’t smack his head on the back side of that wall, because there are metal beams and concrete. It was quite an interesting moment, and it obviously didn’t end up going our way.”

Fortunately, Hunter was OK. He was also, in his own words, “pissed off” with the result of the game

The mood in the Red Sox clubhouse was markedly different. They had just scripted a storybook ending, and Ortiz was the man of the hour.

“I’m pretty sure I have a new favorite player,” said first baseman Mike Carp. “He’s been winning my heart over time after time this year. He’s been doing this for a long time, so it’s no new thing to him, but to see him step up and do it again tonight was unbelievable.”

“We’re living out what you make up in you back yard,” added pitcher Andrew Miller. “It’s everyone’s childhood dream where you hit the game-winning home run. Or maybe you’re getting the big base hit to bring up David Ortiz to hit that home run. You dream about doing those things, and these guys are actually doing them.”

A pair of coaches may have said it best:

“We were down and out — we were in a classic UFC hold and ready to tap out — and we figured out a way with one swing of the bat,” said Red Sox bench coach Torey Lovullo.

“Until you actually close it out, the ballgame is never really over” said Tigers third base coach Tom Brookens. “I know from playing here for a lot of years that runs can come really quick at Fenway Park, and Ortiz has had a lot of big hits for them. He had another one tonight, maybe one of his biggest. We‘ll just have to come back and win one on [Tuesday] night.”

For that to happen, they’ll need Justin Verlander to put together a Scherzer-like performance, and they’ll need their beleaguered bullpen to not implode. They may also want to pitch around Ortiz with the game on the line. They didn’t last night, and paid the price.




Print This Post



David Laurila grew up in Michigan's Upper Peninsula and now writes about baseball from his home in Cambridge, Mass. He authored the Prospectus Q&A series at Baseball Prospectus from February 2006-March 2011 and is a regular contributor to several publications. His first book, Interviews from Red Sox Nation, was published by Maple Street Press in 2006. He can be followed on Twitter @DavidLaurilaQA.


11 Responses to “Scherzer, Ortiz, and a Bullpen Implosion: The Red Sox Rally to Take Game Two”

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
  1. Cardboard says:

    Oh cool. Another ho-hum beat write-up that can be found everywhere else on the internet.

    -22 Vote -1 Vote +1

  2. Jess says:

    Wow. Was waiting for the analysis, but it never came.

    -11 Vote -1 Vote +1

    • Alexander Nevermind says:

      To the jerks above: notice the author. David Laurila pieces on FG are interview-based. And I greatly appreciate the quotes he is able to procure for FG.

      +16 Vote -1 Vote +1

  3. I only scrolled past the comments to write, “Great write-up, thanks. Please do more.”

    MLB Insiders spew oceans of clichés and nonsense, but Laurila consistently draws out (or picks out) the best, colorful and different quotes. And has for years, I clicked through because of his byline.

    Laurila is “reporting”, the complaints here are like going to a game and complaining about no replays. If you want analysis this site offers the tools to do your own, if you want drivel read Bill Plaschke, Morosi has the fiction beat covered and Heyman delivers all the caterwauling you need. Fortunately, Laurila offers this and this is great.

    +9 Vote -1 Vote +1

    • tz says:

      Ditto.

      Would any of the aforementioned non-Laurila writers have gotten this great Andrew Miller quote:

      “It’s everyone’s childhood dream where you hit the game-winning home run. Or maybe you’re getting the big base hit to bring up David Ortiz to hit that home run. You dream about doing those things, and these guys are actually doing them.”

      [my emphasis added. as an analytical kid, I’d find a scenario with Big Papi getting the big hit more believable, and so more fun to re-create]

      Vote -1 Vote +1

    • joser says:

      Agree 100%.

      Vote -1 Vote +1

  4. phoenix2042 says:

    “Lefthander Phil Coke — against whom Ortiz is 2 for 18 — was warming up in the bullpen and had a great vantage point.”

    Why was he warming up? Was he going to face Napoli, instead of the lefty Ortiz? Leyland drives me crazy…

    Vote -1 Vote +1

    • sdiaz1 says:

      Phil Coke’s 2013 Line: 38.1 IP 21BB, 43 H, 3 HR, 30Ks.
      I can’ really see how anyone would really advocate for him in that spot.

      Vote -1 Vote +1