The Older Guys

Back in January, Dave Cameron was discussing the lack of interest in then free agent Johnny Damon, saying:

Abreu was a bargain on a one year, $5 million deal with the Angels, even as he proved that he didn’t really belong in the outfield anymore. Damon, though, is basically the same hitter, just with better defensive skills, and he might have to settle for less than what Abreu got? This is a market correction gone way too far.

Even with the reduced costs of wins, Damon is easily worth $8 to $10 million for 2010. Just like with Abreu last year, teams will be kicking themselves in a few months if they let him sign for peanuts. There are enough clubs out there that could use a +2 to +3 win left fielder that this level of disinterest is simply a market failure.

So let’s see if teams have indeed taken advantage of these older players by looking at a few. I’m going to focus on position players who received one-year deals and had question marks surrounding them due at least partly to their age.

LF Johnny Damon
Free agent age: 36
Signed by Detroit Tigers to 1 year, $8 million deal
2009 WAR: 3.6
2010 WAR: 1.1

Damon, the centerpiece of Cameron’s commentary, finally got a nice-sized deal from Detroit. Although the lefty has gotten on base at near the same rate as last season (.365), the power has been zapped, as he’s only slugging .391, his lowest rate since 2001. However, a 113 wRC+ isn’t that bad given that Damon has a UZR/150 of 19.2 in left field. That adds up to 1.1 WAR already on the season. If Damon continues his current pace, he’ll be worth his contract.

2B Orlando Hudson
Free agent age: 32
Signed by Minnesota Twins to 1 year, $5 million deal
2009 WAR: 2.9
2010 WAR: 1.8

It’s hard to imagine why Hudson only got that $5 million after a very good year with the Dodgers in 2009. He has continued his solid offense with a .337 wOBA, but it’s been his defense that has guided him this season, as Orlando’s on pace for a 16.1 UZR/150. At 1.8 WAR, Hudson’s already been worth his contract and then some.

OF/DH Vladimir Guerrero
Free agent age: 35
Signed by Texas Rangers to 1 year, $5 million deal
2009 WAR: 0.8
2010 WAR: 2.1

Vlad in that hot, homer-happy ballpark in Arlington? It just made too much sense not to have happened. After a down season in 2009 in which he was hampered by injury, Vlad has put up a beautiful line of .327/.374/.538, solid numbers for a DH. Like Hudson, Guerrero has already been worth his contract at 2.0 WAR, and doesn’t seem to be slowing down soon.

1B Aubrey Huff
Free agent age: 33
Signed by San Francisco Giants to 1 year, $3 million deal
2009 WAR: -1.3
2010 WAR: 2.3

What a swing from last season. R.J. Anderson wrote about Huff recently, so I’ll let him explain:

The Giants signed Huff for $3 million on a one-year basis- meaning that just getting a combination of those projected figures probably would have made Huff worth it. Instead they have received one of the best hitters in baseball to date. It’s like a karmic refund for the Edgar Renteria deal turning into a mess.

3B Miguel Tejada
Free agent age: 36
Signed by Baltimore Orioles to one year deal worth $6 million
2009 WAR: 2.7 WAR
2010 WAR: 0.8 WAR

Tejada has not found much success back with the O’s this year, as the third baseman is slugging a career low .379. Add to that a .318 OBP and you have a corner infielder with an OPS under .700. Luckily for Miggy his defense has been above average this year, and if he can muster some pop in the second half of the season, he will most likely be worth his contract in terms of our Dollars metric.

1B Russell Branyan
Free agent age: 34
Signed by Cleveland Indians to 1 year deal worth $2 million
2009 WAR: 2.8
2010 WAR: 1.2

Despite losing some time due to an injury, Branyan has put up a .355 wOBA with very good defense (11.2 UZR/150) at first base. He’s already been worth more ~2.5 times his contract thus far. His initial demands this past winter may have been unreasonable, but there’s no question Branyan truly settled at just $2 million.

These are only a handful of names, and I’ll go through some more later on, but at least on a bunch of these players, Mr. Cameron seems to be on the money.

Print This Post

Pat Andriola is an Analyst at Bloomberg Sports who formerly worked in Major League Baseball's Labor Relations Department. You can contact him at or follow him on Twitter @tuftspat

9 Responses to “The Older Guys”

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
  1. Lucas says:

    Jim Thome. Even with limit ABs, a big contributor.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

  2. Neil says:

    “If Damon continues his current pace, he’ll be worth his contract.”

    That’s probably small comfort to Damon, though – if a 3.6 WAR Damon last year could only get $8 million, you have to think that a 2.5 WAR Damon coming out of this season will be in for another big pay-cut in the off-season.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

    • Kevin S. says:

      Also, don’t we have to take that UZR with a massive SSS grain of salt, given his recent history?

      Vote -1 Vote +1

      • schlomsd says:

        Add Hudson to that as well.

        Vote -1 Vote +1

      • Steve C says:

        Posting the UZR/150 was probably not the best choice for this article. Typically when we think of SSS it is in terms of predictive value. When looking at UZR for a past season to say what a player had contributed over the course of the season it does not really apply. Its not like we look at a player who posted 25 HRs on a season and when evaluating that season in hindsight we discount those home runs down to 18 because that is closer to where his true talent is.

        Hudson – 5.3 UZR
        Damon – 1.6 UZR

        Vote -1 Vote +1

      • B N says:

        If Damon ends the season with an UZR/150 half that good, I’ll eat my hat. With salt. While it’s a great feel-good story to imagine Damon suddenly being a lot better at defense, I just don’t see him being a plus defender this year. If he can keep to being an average defender over the rest of the season Detroit should count itself lucky.

        Vote -1 Vote +1

  3. CircleChange11 says:

    Guerrero going to Texas made many of us think his offensive production would up. Shouldn’t we have had the opposite e pectation of Damon leaving New Yankk Stadium?

    Still, I don’t think many thought his power would tansfer in DET, but that he would still be worth a contract.

    Vote -1 Vote +1

    • Dwight S. says:

      Yeah if anybody expected Damon’s power to translate to Comerica Park they were obviously fooling themselves. With that said you can’t blame his power loss totally on him leaving the Yankees because last year he still hit 7HRs away from Yankee stadium and this year he is barely on pace to hit that many total and has yet to hit a single dinger on the road.

      Vote -1 Vote +1

  4. DJF says:

    “It’s hard to imagine why Hudson only got that $5 million after a very good year with the Dodgers in 2009.”

    I don’t think it’s hard for Orlando to imagine why….

    Vote -1 Vote +1