Breaking Down 2B in Dynasty Draft

Last Sunday night a few of the Fangraph writers participated in a Mock Dynasty Draft. Today, I am going to give my thoughts on the 2B taken in the draft.

R1 P7 – Robinson Cano
R1 P12 – Dustin Pedroia
R2 P11 – Ian Kinsler

These 3 are the top 2B in the league. Personally, I would take Pedroia and Kinsler over Cano based on the SB potential.

R4 P5 – Dustin Ackley

The pick of Ackley was too high IMO for a few reasons. First, I think there were better established players still on the board from other positions like Mark Teixeira and Adrian Beltre. If, a person wanted to go the prospect/youth route Hosmer, Strasburg and Posey were still available. Also, Ackley seems to have limited potential and some 2B picked below him are probably producing at or above his peak.

R5 P6 – Rickie Weeks
R6 P9 – Ben Zobrist
R7 P10 – Brandon Phillips

I probably would have picked these 3 in the opposite order. With Phillips and Zobrist, a person has an idea that the player will be on the field regularly. It is not the case with Weeks. He is just too injury prone.

R8 P8 – Dan Uggla
R8 P11 – Chase Utley

I would not be surprised to see one of these 2 in the top 5 of the final 2012 2B rankings. It is just a gamble on which one it might be.

R10 P2 – Jason Kipnis
R10 P4 – Jemile Weeks

Nice young pickups with potential. Kipnis has the chance to be stud.

R10 P12 – Howie Kendrick

I was a little surprised on how far Kendrick fell.

R11 P9 – Neil Walker
R11 P11 – Danny Espinosa
R12 P10 – Kelly Johnson

The three picks are about in line with what I expected. I see people being down on Johnson this year and he may be picked up in a lower round.

R15 P1 – Ryan Roberts

I am a little surprised to see R. Roberts get picked so early with a possible huge regression coming in 2012. The dual positions eligibility does add some value.

R16 P8 – Brian Roberts

Love the pick of B. Roberts. He has huge upside for a pick this late in the draft.

R16 P9 – Sean Rodriguez
R19 P5 – Daniel Murphy


R22 P3 – Gordon Beckham

Beckham is a decent player to take a chance on. He may not be much in 2012 -or- he may have a break out year like Alex Gordon did last season.

R23 P7 – Jose Altuve

Altuve could be a regular in the top 10 2B lists for years to come. Playing in Houston hurts his value quite a bit. Look to see if he ends up hitting 1st or 2nd in Houston’s lineup for a jump in value.

R25 P6 – Aaron Hill

I would have taken him over Rodriquez and Murphy. Great late value.

R27 P9 – Jamey Carroll

A last round pick up. He will be waiver wire fodder in a day or two.

Two players I was a little surprised no one took a chance on were Johnny Giavotella (youth and playing time) and Ryan Raburn (past potential).

Print This Post

Jeff writes for RotoGraphs, The Hardball Times, Rotowire, Baseball America, and BaseballHQ. He has been nominated for two SABR Analytics Research Award for Contemporary Analysis and won it in 2013 in tandem with Bill Petti. He has won three FSWA Awards including on for his MASH series. In his first season in Tout Wars, he won the H2H league. Follow him on Twitter @jeffwzimmerman.

Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Depressed White Sox fan
Depressed White Sox fan

Jamey Carroll is drafted and Gordan Beckham is not. /sigh