Five Best Metro Areas for the Prospect Nerd

A little over a week ago, talking with a friend who now lives in Washington, DC, that same friend dedicated no small portion of our conversation to celebrating his proximity (by virtue of living in the aforementioned American city) to minor-league baseball — in this case, to the Bowie Baysox of the Double-A Eastern League, the Frederick Keys and Potomac Nationals of the High-A Carolina League, the Hagerstown Suns of the Low-A Sally League, and even the Aberdeen IronBirds of the short-season New York-Penn League.

Mentioning that same conversation to FanGraphs managing editor Dave Cameron a couple days afterward, he (i.e. Cameron) replied by suggesting that his present hometown of Winston-Salem — which features no fewer than eight minor-league teams within a 90-minute drive (depending on traffic, of course) — is perhaps the best place to live in the country were one’s sole ambition in life to attend minor-league baseball games.

Because it’s among my ambitions in life to fact check Cameron’s most dubious-sounding claims — and also because I was curious — I spent too much of the weekend attempting to assess which towns and cities offered access to the greatest number of minor leagues.

As a sort of informal way of measuring this, I assigned to those same towns and cities three points for every ballpark within a 30-minute drive (according to Google Maps), two points for every ballpark within 60 minutes, and a single point for a ballpark within 90 minutes — while awarding points for only one team (the closest) per minor league.*

*Note: the scores aren’t recorded here, but the reader can reproduce them easily enough using MiLB.com and Google Maps.

So, for example, to Winston-Salem I assigned three points for the Winston-Salem Dash of the High-A Carolina League, two points for the Greensboro Grasshoppers of the Low-A Sally League (37 minutes away), one point for the Burlington Royals of the rookie-level Appalachian League (64 minutes), and another point for the Triple-A Durham Bulls (89 minutes!) — but not points for the Kannapolis Intimidators, for example, as, like Greensboro, they belong to the Sally League. Is it possible that the presence of an extra Sally League team in the general vicinity improves the experience of a baseball nerd living in Winston-Salem? Perhaps. But the marginal gains are small, I’d submit — and, more to the point, the prospect of measuring such a thing tested the will of the author.

In terms of criteria that were not considered in the creation of this list, “basically everything else” is the answer to that. So, for example, real estate prices: that’s not a criterion. Or unemployment rate: that’s not a criterion. Or weather. Or restaurants. Or schools.

With that said, here are the top-five metro areas for prospect nerds, as best I can tell. Note that all maps (which one can click for the purposes of embiggening) are from MiLB.com and presented on same scale, to avoid confusion. Drive times are courtesy Google Maps.

5. Southeast Suburbs, Cleveland

What an exercise like this one reveals is both that (a) it’s uncommon to find teams from two different minor leagues within an hour of each other and also that (b) it’s decidedly rare to find clubs from three different minor leagues all within the same general metro area. That’s why, even with just three teams, residents of the southeast Cleveland suburbs have considerably above-average access to minor-league baseball, with the Lake County Captains of the Class A Midwest League and Akron Aeros of the Double-A Eastern League both about a half hour’s away and the Mahoning Valley Scrappers of the short-season New York-Penn League about an hour’s drive.

*****

4. Philadelphia, Generally

Philadelphia isn’t very close to any particular minor-league ballpark, but it’s sort of close to a number of them, including: the Trenton Thunder of the Double-A Eastern League, Wilmington Blue Rocks of the High-A Carolina League, the Lakewood BlueClaws of the Low-A Sally League, the Triple-A Lehigh Valley IronPigs, and the Aberdeen IronBirds of the New York-Penn League.

*****

3. South Suburbs, Boston

Living in the south suburbs of Boston gives one the advantage not only of being able to access both the New Hampshire Fisher Cats (Double-A Eastern League) and Lowell Spinners (short-season New York-Penn League) north of the city and the Triple-A Pawtucket Red Sox south of the city, but also the Cape Cod League’s western-most team, the Wareham Gatemen, thereby giving the nerd the opportunity to see many of the country’s best college prospects, as well.

*****

2. East Valley, Phoenix

The map here isn’t particularly well suited to telling the entire story so far as the baseball-related benefits of living in Greater Phoenix are concerned. Residents of the East Valley (Mesa, Scottsdale, Tempe) have the opportunity to watch live baseball almost all year long, beginning in February with both spring training and Pac-12 baseball, proceeding to the Arizona Rookie League (to which many high-school first-round picks are assigned), and then culminating in the Arizona Fall League, which more or less features three Futures Games per day for a month and a half.

*****

1. Along I-40, North Carolina

It appears as though Dave Cameron is more or less accurate with his suggestion that Winston-Salem is among the country’s better towns for the prospect nerd. I say “more or less” because actually somewhere east of Winston-Salem — between Burlington (home of the rookie-level Appy League Burlington Royals) and Durham (home of the Triple-A Durham Bulls) — would be most strategic. But anywhere along I-40 between Winston-Salem and Raleigh offers access not only to the two aforementioned team, but also the Greensboro Grasshoppers of the Low-A Sally League and one from the Carolina Mudcats and Winston-Salem Dash — both of the High-A Carolina League.




Print This Post

Carson Cistulli has just published a book of aphorisms called Spirited Ejaculations of a New Enthusiast.


Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
DD
Guest
DD
3 years 10 months ago

So the follow up would be – where do the scouting pros all live? Keith Law is in Arizona (a fine job of positioning there), but where are Callis/Sickels/Goldstien/et al?

dp
Guest
3 years 10 months ago

Callis and Goldstein live in the greater Chicago area, Goldstein in DeKalb and Callis somewhere near Evanston. Given that they travel extensively, and that there are plenty of Low-A teams between Madison and Chicago, they’re covering plenty of live prospects. (Covering in the figurative sense, but also as one horse would cover another.)

gnomez
Guest
gnomez
3 years 10 months ago

Depending on the particular Cleveland suburb and the traffic, you’re also about an hour and a half from Toledo.

JayAre
Guest
JayAre
3 years 10 months ago

Or an hour and a half from Columbus

reillocity
Guest
reillocity
3 years 10 months ago

Seems like Asheville NC would be a great place along I-40 for a scout to call home. From there besides Asheville and the other eastern NC teams you’d have the entirety of the Appalachian League plus Greenville (SC) and West Virginia (Charleston) of the South Atlantic League within a reasonable drive.

Mike
Guest
Mike
3 years 9 months ago

and out of USA?

wpDiscuz