VOTE: Players Deserving Movies, Round 2


Current Leader: Ro! Ber! To! Ro! Ber! To!
image credz

Our quest to find a movie-worthy story continues today as we vote on the second round of contestants.

Here’s the top five from Round 1:

1. Roberto Clemente 14.5% (77 votes)

2. Satchel Paige 13.94% (74 votes)

3. Moe Berg 11.11% (59 votes)

4. Branch Rickey 9.79% (52 votes)

5. Bill Veeck 8.47% (45 votes)

Here are the Round 2 contestants, our final grouping:

Hilda Chester — A Dodgers fan in the true “fanatic” root of the word, Chester spent a healthy portion of the early 20th century cheering on Brooklyn’s home team — first with a frying pan, then team-supplied brass cowbells. She had heart attacks.

Otis Nixon — The speed-demon Nixon stole 620 bases in his lengthy career and had a slew of strong defensive plays on his tab. He also struggled with drug and alcohol addiction, but has since gone clean and committed himself to helping others rehabilitate.

Bob Gibson — A Hall of Fame pitcher for the St. Louis Cardinals, Gibson — despite two awful late-career seasons — finished his MLB time with an 82 FIP- and nearly 3900 IP. He debuted at age 23 and retired at 39 — oh, and had rickets and some sort of asthma as a child.

Reggie Jackson — “Mr October” got Dayn Perry to write a book about him. According to Perry’s bio: “Ne’er has there before strutted a scalawag of equal October aplomb, of greater fastball dimissory powers, of such lasting bespectacledness or mustachiosity.” Or maybe not; like I’m actually going to read that book.

Nolan Ryan — This guy pitched in the majors from age 19 to age 46. He then parlayed those earnings and that Hall of Fame career into owning his home-state team, the Texas Rangers, which are now a perennial powerhouse franchise.

Dock Ellis — Threw a no-hitter while bugging out on LSD. THE SEVENTIES!

Willie Mays — He could field, he could crush dongers, and he did it for 22 seasons — one fewer than he would have had he not served his nation in the Korean War. This guy has live a Life, I tell you.

Lenny Dykstra — The All-Star Dykstra had a solid career with the Mets and Phillies, and then parlayed his career success into a fashionable story of fraud, tax evasion, NHL great’s house flipping, and ultimately house arrest and rehab. This story is still very much writing itself. Though the short version can probably be seen in any episode of Arrested Development — coocoo-kacha!

Ryan Vogelsong — The North Carolina native Vogelsong translated his less-than-great MLB career into a mediocre career in Japan’s NPB league, and then — upon returning to the MLB at age 33 — Vogelsong suddenly become a FIP-breaking wizard. He now leads the National League with a 2.27 ERA, despite a 4.31 SIERA.

Ozzie Guillen — A great defensive middle infielder turned dynamic, boisterous, commie-loving manager. You know the story.

Rick Ankiel — Ankiel was a failed pitching prospect turned feel-good comeback story as he changed to the outfield, turned brush-under-the-rug story as he was caught for steroid use, turned solid, Jeff Francoeur-like career.

Marge Schott — I’ma let Wikipedia do the heavy lifting here:

She was the third woman to own a North American major-league team without inheriting it … and the second woman to buy an existing team rather than inheriting it. She is perhaps most well known for her controversial behavior during her tenure as owner of the Reds, which included slurs towards African-Americans, Jews, the Japanese and homosexuals. She was banned from managing the team by the MLB from 1996 through 1998 due to statements in support of German domestic policies of Nazi party leader Adolf Hitler; shortly afterwards, she sold the majority of her share in the team.

I wonder if she made a non-aggression pact with Mr. Red, and then betrayed him.

Jose Canseco — The steroids squealer wrote a tell-all story about PEDs after his dynamic 17-year career. He is currently seeking a second chance in the MLB, which renders his Twitter account perhaps the most depressing place on the Internet.

John Rocker — Rocker was best known as the sayer of racist, homophobic, and sexist comments and the “who wasn’t?” user of steroids.

Michael Jordan — The Chicago Bulls Hall of Famer and world-famous fop and jerk, Michael Jordan also had one spectacularly uninspiring season with a Chicago White Sox Double-A affiliate at age 31.





Print This Post

Bradley writes for FanGraphs and The Hardball Times. Follow him on Twitter @BradleyWoodrum.


Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Bryan
Guest
3 years 11 months ago

Are any of the wicked witch’s henchmen still alive and available to play Otis Nixon?

MustBunique
Member
Member
3 years 11 months ago

After reading Willie Mays’ writeup and thinking about how awesome and amazing it was that he served in Korea, I though about Teddy Ballgame who also served in the military. Last player to hit .400, the red seat, internet mogul, even in his death he was interesting due to his kids being idiots. He’s gotta be added, his frozen dome demands it.

Well-Beered Englishman
Guest
3 years 11 months ago

CoocookaCHA! CoocookaCHA! CoocookaCHA!

Has anyone on this website even SEEN a chicken?

Illinois glass M. Michael Sheets
Guest
Illinois glass M. Michael Sheets
3 years 11 months ago

Okay … that’s a pretty good chicken.

olethros
Guest
olethros
3 years 11 months ago

Gibson was also a Harlem Globetrotter.

Illinois glass M. Michael Sheets
Guest
Illinois glass M. Michael Sheets
3 years 11 months ago

David Stern would not approve of the Michael Jordan story, like he wants everyone to know that Jordan playing baseball was just a way to double secretly suspend Jordan a year for betting … or so the rumor goes.

dp
Guest
3 years 11 months ago

I would love to see an unvarnished Jordan movie about his time in the minors, because the fact that he was semi-decent at AA after not having played baseball since high school (~15 years) is an astonishing accomplishment.

Illinois glass M. Michael Sheets
Guest
Illinois glass M. Michael Sheets
3 years 11 months ago

In what world is a .266 slugging, .289 OBP semi-decent from an outfielder?

Yirmiyahu
Member
3 years 11 months ago

He hadn’t played baseball since high school, and then played in AA after 15 years. The fact that he hit better than .050/.050/.050 should’ve been considered a success. The fact that he mustered a .289 OBP was an extraordinary accomplishment.

Illinois glass M. Michael Sheets
Guest
Illinois glass M. Michael Sheets
3 years 11 months ago

Being an extraordinary accomplishment for him does not make it a respectable line. It is a bad line for an outfielder even if it is better than what 99.999 percent of the population would do after not playing for 15 years.

samuelraphael
Member
3 years 11 months ago

Wasn’t Space Jam about MJ’s baseball career.

Bluebird in Boulder
Guest
Bluebird in Boulder
3 years 11 months ago

Otis Nixon was the feature of a Canadian show in which two gentlemen wanted to relive their favourite childhood memory.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VSO9zqNoHzA

ALevy
Member
ALevy
3 years 11 months ago

I’d love to see the Nolan Ryan movie, but only if Nolan is played by Will Ferrell

Well-Beered Englishman
Guest
3 years 11 months ago

And only if his pitching coach is Old Hoss Radbourn (Clint Eastwood).

radicalhenri
Member
radicalhenri
3 years 11 months ago

it’s got to be ankiel. such a sad story. plus made even cooler (and sadder) by the fact that he can now throw a strike from centerfield. also reggie jackson is the most overrated player in the history of the game, and i’m a yankee fan.

AGS
Guest
AGS
3 years 11 months ago

The Dock Ellis movie will need to best this short animated film:
Dock Ellis & the LSD No-No
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_vUhSYLRw14

wpDiscuz