Is Wilin Rosario the New No. 1 Fantasy Catcher?

Last week when I published the September Catcher Rankings, there were a few people who questioned the ranking of Colorado Rockies backstop Wilin Rosario, who was sitting fourth in the second tier. The first to question Rosario’s ranking was Cuck City who threw a little sarcasm my way and said, “Lets just ignore that Rosario outperforms tier1 in everything but AVG,” which was quickly followed up with another splash of the tongue-in-cheek from manjun who noted the catcher’s .290 batting average. And so when Check YoSelf asked, “…what’s the deal…?” I decided to actually check myself and look into Rosario a little deeper and see if these readers were right. Is Rosario the top catcher in fantasy baseball?

I suppose a quick glance at the numbers for Rosario are in order. After a rookie season in which Rosario batted .270 with 28 home runs, 71 RBI, 67 runs scored and four stolen bases, he has, thus far, followed it up with a .290 average, 21 home runs, 74 RBI, 60 runs scored and another four stolen bases. The average is up 20 points, thanks in large to a .339 BABIP which is a good 50 points higher than it was last year. His strikeout rate remains in the 23-24 percent range while his walk rate dropped from a meh 5.9-percent to a lousy 3.3-percent. And with three weeks still to go in the season, his ISO has dropped 62 points to a .198 mark.

In looking at his plate discipline numbers, it appears that Rosario has been more aggressive at the plate this season than last, probably due to a nearly seven-percent increase in his F-Strike percentage. His swing rate has jumped four-percent and he’s making a little more contact overall. Still swinging through 14.7-percent of his pitches though. This would, obviously account for his lack of walks, but the aggressiveness and increased contact has helped the BABIP and thus maintaining that .312 OBP. So in truth, the fluctuation in some of his numbers isn’t all that great and he’s roughly the same exact hitter he was last year. While you’d like to see some improvement from year to year at his age and level of experience, the relative consistency isn’t too bad.

So now that we’ve seen his numbers and for all intents and purposes, like what we see, how does he measure up to the rest of the players in his tier and above? That’s the question, right? Why is he not ranked higher? So let’s see…

One caveat to keep in mind is that this is strictly for fantasy purposes. There will be no talk of WAR or wRC+ or even wOBA. For general fantasy purposes, these numbers are not used. We’re talking strictly standard five categories with the possibility of OBP replacing average along with age and opportunity. We’ve all seen players who are better in fantasy than in real life and vice versa, so we’re just talking fantasy here. Hence the article sitting in RotoGraphs and not that green section we see to the left.

vs Carlos Santana — Rosario’s counting stats and batting average are better with the obvious edge in OBP going to Santana. Both have shown equal consistency from year to year, so for fantasy purposes, yes, Rosario is slightly better, but are comparable enough to reside in the same tier.

vs Jonathan Lucroy — More raw power from Rosario but a comparable average. Lucroy has a much better on-base percentage and has shown some slight year to year improvement in the plate discipline which could mean even higher rate stats. The power though is likely to stay in the same range. Rosario’s overall counting stats are better and he could probably be considered a notch about Lucroy. A whole tier, though? I’m not so sure yet.

vs Brian McCann — McCann is obviously on the decline and Rosario’s numbers, save for OBP are better. With youth on his side, he gets the edge over the Braves’ veteran backstop. But in looking further, perhaps a drop for McCann is more likely than a bump up for Rosario.

vs Joe Mauer — So the concussion problems have put a damper on this year and so if the tiers were based solely on ROS performance, yes, Rosario has the edge for sure. But these tiers also take into account performance throughout the year and even a splash of protectability (not even a word, I know) for next. Rosario definitely has the edge in power; and a significant one at that. But a healthy year from Mauer produces more runs scored and he beats the snot out of Rosario in average and on-base percentage. Considering Rosario’s age, health, and home ballpark, I’ll actually give him a slight edge over Mauer, but not to the point where he is in a higher tier. In truth, I’d say they’re pretty close to a wash in overall value. Next year Rosario and Mauer will likely have similar ADP numbers.

vs Yadier Molina — So age and mileage are a big factor in the comparison here and considering Molina’s health and drop from last season’s career-best totals, I’d say he’s hit his peak. Advantage Rosario. Molina has the better rate stats, but unless he matches his 2012 totals, Rosario has the clear edge in overall value.

vs Buster Posey — In truth, the drop that Posey has taken this year in overall numbers had to be expected. His second half in 2012 bordered on the ridiculous and to expect him to repeat that feat was a bit ludicrous. Still, strong plate discipline numbers and lovable rate stats help his overall value and also allow me to believe that he will find a happy medium in overall power putting him right about even with Rosario. Our contender for the title may hit more home runs, but I see an edge in RBI totals and runs scored for the future.

So overall, I will credit our three readers for their criticism of my Rosario ranking. Even in just this cursory glance at numbers, it is clear that Rosario does indeed belong in that upper tier. Or at the least, the top two tiers should be combined with McCann dropping down. Is Rosario the best fantasy catcher out there? I still give the title to Posey, but obviously, Rosario is running an extremely close race; closer than I gave him credit for in my September tiers. Take a bow, Cuck City, manjun and Check YoSelf. I have checked myself and concede to your outcry. I will certainly keep this in mind when doing the preseason rankings for 2014.





Print This Post

Howard Bender has been covering fantasy sports for over 10 years on a variety of websites. In addition to his work here, you can also find him at his site,, Fantasy Alarm, RotoWire and Mock Draft Central. Follow him on Twitter at @rotobuzzguy or for more direct questions or comments, email him at

newest oldest most voted

Love it that you put your ego aside and took another look at it.


please don’t put it in your preseason rankings. I was able to draft him in the 17th round this year. Keep it a secret.