Clint Barmes dropped the ball!

I got a threshold, here. I got a threshold for the bad karma my team can experience. Now, right now, I’m a race car, right, and the Rockies got me in the red. And I’m just sayin’, I’m just sayin’ that it’s dangerous to have a race car in the red. That’s all. I could blow:

Photos taken by The Denver Post and a spectator in the right-field stands at Coors Field during Sunday’s dramatic 4-3 victory over the Cardinals reveal that second baseman Clint Barmes bobbled the final popup, with one picture showing the baseball on the outfield grass. Barmes rolled on the grass, jumped to his feet and fired to first to double off Albert Pujols to end the game.

But did he catch the ball?

“Only me and Barmes know the truth. It’s the same as (Matt) Holliday touching home plate,” outfielder Ryan Spilborghs said Monday of the controversial slide that clinched the Rockies’ 2007 playoff berth. “It’s better that it’s (mysterious).”

Click through for the pics. The third one down in the most damning.

Albert Pujols’ baserunning mistakes notwithstanding, unless things break just right this week, this whole play shall forever be known as the play that jobbed the Braves out of the damn wild card.

(Thanks to readers puck and salvo for the heads up)


Print This Post
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Bob Tufts
Guest
Bob Tufts

Whatever you do, don’t tell Jack Marshall or the HOF clause on sportsmanship and integrity will be evoked.

Kahuna Tuna
Guest
Kahuna Tuna

Of course, Colorado fans don’t need to be reminded of the controversial play that got the Rockies into the playoffs last time.

Neither do Padres fans.  . . . Not that we’re bitter or anything.

We can somehow blame all these blown calls on the altitude or the humidor, right?  </loaded question>

Jack Marshall
Guest
Jack Marshall
You know, I’m increasingly uncomfortable with the long-standing baseball tradition of approving players’ faking catches and tags. It’s embedded in baseball culture, and thu isn’t regarded as cheating, but it sure looks, smells, and quacks like cheating. Before television, these things could all be “mysteries,“which had its charm, but we know Holliday never touched the plate, and we know Barmes missed the catch. There’s not much good that comes out of fans knowing they were jobbed, and if it could be worked out practically (don’t ask me how now—I’m going nuts counting other angels on pin-heads), it may be time… Read more »
Chris in Dallas
Guest
Chris in Dallas

Not only that, but Matt Holliday STILL never touched home plate in the one-game playoff.  It’s an obvious case of Mountain Time Zone bias by the umpires.

Jason B
Guest
Jason B

“The play that jobbed the Braves out of the damn wild card” was giving Frenchy and Schafer so, so many wasted at-bats in the early months of the season, Lowe and Johnson underachieving, and perhaps a hat-tip to losing 5 of 6 to the Reds.  I think the Barmes play ranks #428 on the list of reasons, just ahead of Vladimir Nunez’s 36.00 ERA in 1 inning pitched.

Bob Tufts
Guest
Bob Tufts
And I thought that the Rockies team was a religious group – I guess Holliday and Barmes never attended that part of the baseball chapel services. We can’t quantify exactly how the use of steroids altered the results of games (frankly, both pitchers and batters were using, so it probably was close to balancing out). However, replays have shown us clear examples where players knew they dropped the ball or missed home plate and turly affected the outcome of the game right in front of our eyes. Jack, we will soon be heading to limited challenges and instant replay similar… Read more »
Wooden U. Lykteneau
Guest
Wooden U. Lykteneau

Assuming, of course, that (a) Lugo would have scored on the play, which took place with one (1) out and was therefore in a position to have to play it halfway (b) that the Cardinals would have scored an additional run in the inning, i.e. to have taken the lead (c) that the Rockies would not have scored in the bottom of the ninth, i.e. to have either tied or reclaimed the lead.

Jack Marshall
Guest
Jack Marshall

I know, and I hate the thought of replays. But it’s hard for me to distinguish the relative injustices of a foul called a game-changing homer and a hit called a game-changing catch. If its worth getting one right, it’s worth getting the other right too.

I’m STILL pissed about Larry Barnett’s non-interference call on Ed Armbrister….

Jason F
Guest
Jason F
Let’s all settle down just a minute. If the umpire had ruled that Barmes failed to catch that ball, it doesn’t mean that the Cardinals win that game. Lugo would have scored to tie the game, and Pujols would have advanced to third, and Ludwick would have been on first with a single, and there would have been one out. That’s an advantageous situation for the Cards, but the Rockies still had the opportunity to get two outs and win it in the bottom of the ninth or extra innings. This was not a situation in which an apparent missed… Read more »
Wooden U. Lykteneau
Guest
Wooden U. Lykteneau

Jason F – So Pujols goes from first to third on a shallow popup to RF with one out? Really?

Jason F
Guest
Jason F

He was standing on third base when the play was over. He stated after the game that he was positive Ludwick’s bloop would drop for a hit.

Wooden U. Lykteneau
Guest
Wooden U. Lykteneau

Of course he did – not very often a baserunner admits to making such a horrific mistake.

Allan
Guest
Allan

Well…if the ball had dropped, he would have had every right to be on third at the time.  Baserunning error or not, he DID go “from first to third on a shallow popup to RF with one out”

At the very least, the game did not end when or as it should have.  It was a blown call and one that Braves fans could (though not necessarily should) point to as being one that changed the complexion of the Wild Card race.  Though all this will be moot if they continue on this run and win the Wild Card.

GO BRAVES!

Allan
Guest
Allan

Correction: If the ball, which dropped, had been correctly called an out.

Allan
Guest
Allan

sorry, had not been incorrectly called an out…damnit I need some coffee

Rob in CT
Guest
Rob in CT

“You know, I’m increasingly uncomfortable with the long-standing baseball tradition of approving players’ faking catches and tags. “

I’ve always hated that.

Jason F
Guest
Jason F

I agree with most all of what’s been said, with the exception of Go Braves! and video replay.

This damning evidence of Barmes’ muff did not come from video of the play, it was a fan in the stands with a still camera that became our Zapruder. An expansion in scope of video replay would not have corrected this call.

Wooden U. Lykteneau
Guest
Wooden U. Lykteneau

To Jack’s point, Barmes first looked to third when he got to his feet, indicating perhaps that he *knew* he hadn’t caught the ball. However, I can’t agree with the assumption that Pujols would have been safe even if Barmes had come up firing. Sorry, Albert ain’t that fast.

Bob Timmermann
Guest
Bob Timmermann

Why didn’t Julio Lugo try to tag up and score? It was a timing play and he could have beaten the throw back.

At worst, he could have forced the Rockies in to going for a fourth out.

mike in brooklyn
Guest
mike in brooklyn

Jack Marshall—your comment reminded me of an essay I read n “Baseball and Philosophy” (it’s part of that Simpsons and philosophy; sienfeld and philosophy; etc series).  It dealt with cheating and why some forms are considered ok (gaylord perry; phantom tags) and others aren’t (steroids; corking the bat).

I’d tell you what the guy concluded—assuming he even drew any conclusion—but that would require brain cells I’ve long since destroyed.  Or getting off my lazy arse to get the book.

I recommend it, though.

Hizouse
Guest
Hizouse

Here’s the link to the video of the play:
http://stlouis.cardinals.mlb.com/media/video.jsp?content_id=6889331

Pujols makes third easy. 

Of course, if the Braves hadn’t blown a 4-run leading going into the 7th at Coors on the last day before the ASB, this would be less of a big deal.

puck
Guest
puck

Nice post, Jason F, on the context of those plays.  The other part about the game vs. San Diego is that the umps blew a call on Atkins’ 7th inning drive, ruling it a double rather than a HR.  If that call is made correctly, who knows if the game would even go to extra innings.

Jason F
Guest
Jason F
@puck:  True on the Atkins play from ‘07. If the current replay system for boundary calls was in in place then, that’s a dinger. Dan Iassogna also called Dexter Fowler out at first in the first game of this Rockies-Cards series on Friday night, and replay showed that Fowler was safe by quite a bit. On Saturday night, Iassogna was behind the plate and botched at least two calls—one a called third strike on Jason Giambi (replay showed it was low and inside), and one a checked-swing third strike on Mark DeRosa (replay showed he did not go around). Then… Read more »
Dennis Koziel
Guest
Dennis Koziel

I was at the Cards/Rocks game on Sunday, two rows from the field, behind home plate.  Despite the fact he probably thought his team was jobbed, I saw Tony Larusa do a very classy thing. He walked over to the Rockies dugout and shake Jim Tracy’s hand.  I’m sure it was to wish him contiued good luck in the playoffs.  Nice to see that any time.

Jason F
Guest
Jason F
Again, Todd, I fully agree with the scope of what you’re saying here. But the Barmes play was really crazy—he was sprinting backwards at full speed, dove, tumbled, and popped up holding the ball. His back was turned to all four umpires, and all four of them were shielded from a view of the ball. None of the video cameras broadcasting the game picked up the ball on the grass. None of the press photographers credentialed to cover the game captured it either. The only image that shows the loose ball was shot by a fan, in the stands far… Read more »
Todd
Guest
Todd
“My point is this: Teams don’t win or lose, or make the playoffs or miss them, based on a call by an umpire. And blaming blue is a loser’s lament.” If a team misses the playoffs by a small enough margin, there are all sorts of things you could point to that allowed their opposition to get that extra win or two over them. An example that’s more palatable to those who want to believe that calls “even out” is having a starter or two with really low BABIPs, causing their team to generate a little less offense then they… Read more »
wpDiscuz