My Weekend Game Diary: October 2

So absolutely incredible that not even Vin Scully could believe it, the Dodgers came back from a 3-0 ninth-inning deficit against the Giants to win the NL West last night. The Dodger announcer was almost nonplussed as Giant reliever Dustin Hermanson simply could not find the plate, walking in a run before being relieved. The inning was capped by a grand slam home run by Steve Finley, and the Dodgers won this crazy game 7-3.

Some perspective: Between 1979 and 1990 there were almost 3,000 games in which the home team trailed by exactly three runs in the bottom of the ninth, and they managed to come back and win only 99 of them. That’s less than a 4% Win Expectancy. Dodger fans seemed virtually assured of a loss and one more meaningful game on Sunday, but Finley and the Dodgers turned those probabilities into improbabilities.

Actually, Finley’s grand slam was not the key play of the inning. Here’s a chart of how the Dodgers’ play-by-play Win Expectancy rose from 4% to 100% in the fateful ninth:

                                  WE    Diff
Beginning of Inning             0.038
Green singled                   0.096   0.058
Ventura walked                  0.193   0.097
Cora struck out                 0.110  -0.083
Hernandez walked                0.214   0.104
Choi walked, run scores         0.343   0.129
Error by Ransom, run scores     0.544   0.201  Second most important play
Werth singled, run scores       0.835   0.291  THE key play
Finley home run                 1.000   0.165

It was Jayson Werth’s single to right that really made the difference. Cody Ransom had just been inserted at shortstop in the ninth as a defensive substitute, but his error was the second-most crippling play of the inning for the Giants. This was a case of the Giants beating themselves. Marguis Grissom had two big hits and Brett Tomko pitched an excellent game. But Dustin Hermanson’s wildness, coupled with the Ransom error, did them in.

Take nothing away from the Dodgers, however. Congratulations to LA.

Actually, two western division titles were decided last night. The other LA-area team, Anaheim, also came from behind to beat Oakland 5-4 and head into the postseason. This was another wild game, with lots of ups and downs. As evidence, I submit the following Win Expectancy graph of the game:


The Vlad-for-MVP campaign has already started, but Darin Erstad’s game-tying double in the eighth (WE=.335) made him the Most Valuable Player in this game. Here’s a list of each player’s total Win Expectancy score:

Erstad        0.304
Anderson      0.272
Vlad          0.240
Miller        0.187
Chavez        0.177
Percival      0.175
Dye           0.159
Rodriquez     0.154
Zito          0.084
Scutaro       0.072
Figgins       0.042
Molina        0.039
Paul          0.017
Byrnes        0.004
Halter       -0.026
Donnelly     -0.037
Amezaga      -0.044
Eckstein     -0.051
DaVanon      -0.054
Pride        -0.062
McLemore     -0.073
Kotsay       -0.085
McMillion    -0.085
Durazo       -0.088
Mecir        -0.090
Dotel        -0.090
Riggs        -0.131
Glaus        -0.153
Hatteberg    -0.174
Crosby       -0.185
Escobar      -0.240
Rincon       -0.335

This race will probably be better remembered for Oakland’s downward September spiral than anything else. But, like the Dodgers, take nothing away from the Angels. This win was a microcosm of the team’s strengths: good all-around hitting from a stable of fine batters, good starting pitching and excellent relief. Congratulations to the Angels.

Back in the National League, the Astros took a big step toward winning the NL Wildcard by beating the Rockies 9-3 behind an onslaught of six home runs, including two each by Craig Biggio and Jeff Kent. Notably, Kent moved into first place for most all-time home runs by a second baseman. There really wasn’t much drama to this game as Roy Oswalt dispatched the Rockies with relative ease. The Astros have a chance to cap their remarkable comeback with a victory against the Rockies today.

The Braves put the Cubs out of their misery with an 8-6 win in a cold Wrigley day game. It was an intense, closely managed game, as both Dusty Baker and Bobby Cox pulled their pitchers frequently in search of the best matchup. J.D. Drew spoiled Baker’s managerial conniving with a two-run triple off lefty Mike Remlinger in the 8th, the key hit of the game (WE of .463).

The Cubs found their home run strokes again with Sosa, Alou and Ramirez all lofting balls into the bleachers. But several key plays turned the game around: first, Carlos Zambrano hit Chipper Jones on the hand with a pitch in the fifth inning. This may not have materially affected the game, but, unfortunately for the Braves, it could be a factor in the playoffs. Let’s hope it was just a bruise and Chipper recovers quickly.

In the next inning Jose Macias totally lost a flyball in centerfield, contributing to a three-run outburst by the Braves. As expected, Zambrano handled his fielder’s miscue with equanimity… not. Later in the inning, the emotional righthander was taken out of the game and the Cubs’ bullpen proceeded to give the game away. And so went the Cubs’ disappointing season.

We’re down to one race and a maximum of two meaningful games today. The Astros can simply take the NL wildcard by beating the Rockies. If they lose and the Giants beat the Dodgers, playoff on Monday.

Print This Post
Dave Studeman was called a "national treasure" by Rob Neyer. Seriously. Follow his sporadic tweets @dastudes.

Comments are closed.