Roster Doctor 4/6/09

Welcome to THT Fantasy’s Roster Doctor. If you’d like your team to be analyzed by one of our fantasy baseball experts, please send your full roster to
. Also be sure to include your league’s player pool (mixed, AL-only, NL-only), number of teams, scoring format (roto, head-to-head, points, etc.), categories, whether or not it’s a keeper league, and any other pertinent information. If your roster is selected it will be analyzed in a future Roster Doctor column.

Today’s edition of Roster Doctor features a lineup put together by Nathan:

Player pool: Mixed
No. of teams: 16
Categories: Traditional 5×5
Scoring Type: Head-to-Head
C: Yadier Molina
1B: Carlos Guillen
2B: Kaz Matsui
SS: Jose Reyes
3B: Felipe Lopez
OF: Carl Crawford
OF: Lastings Milledge
OF: Willy Taveras
Util: Fred Lewis
BN: Randy Winn
BN: Ronnie Belliard

SP: Brandon Webb
SP: Roy Oswalt
RP: Francisco Rodriguez
RP: Jonathan Broxton
P: Joba Chamberlain
P: Brandon Lyon
P: Manny Corpas
BN: Zach Greinke
BN: Todd Wellemeyer
BN: Jordan Zimmermann
BN: Trevor Cahill

Nathan is employing a strategy that Derek discussed here. While most managers employ a drafting strategy that focuses on power and balance throughout the roster, this strategy focuses on punting categories to “guarantee” wins in other categories.

While this lineup will almost never win the home runs and RBI categories, the trio of Jose Reyes, Carl Crawford and Willy Taveras essentially guarantees a win in stolen bases. The majority of the hitters in this lineup are projected to hit in the leadoff spot, which will help with runs. And due to the depth of this league, I think there will be plenty of weeks when this team will compete in batting average despite not having a single batter projected to hit over .300. A weekly average of .280-.285 may be good enough to win a fair share of weeks.

A couple quick suggestions would be to start Randy Winn over Fred Lewis, if only to give a slight boost to the team batting average. A decrease in stolen bases shouldn’t be a concern since Reyes, Crawford and Taveras will steal a boat load and Winn should steal about 15 himself. While Lewis may get more at-bats at the top of the order, there will be plenty of times when Winn will bat first as well, as he had 224 plate appearances batting leadoff last year. This means that any decrease in runs will most likely be very small. But the benefit in starting Winn over Lewis is that Winn projects to hit about .285 while Lewis will most likely hit closer to .270.

The other suggestion is to simply bench your catcher. Molina won’t contribute much in many categories, and his projected batting average of .270 might hurt your team more than it might help.

As I mentioned before, most managers will tend to stress hitting over pitching and we are going against the grain by punting home runs and RBIs. In doing so, this strategy dictates that we focus on pitching and make hitting somewhat secondary. So let’s check out the pitching staff.

Brandon Webb is a solid anchor in any league format, and Roy Oswalt has thrown at least 200 innings in each of the last five years, which will definitely help in accumulating strikeouts. Everyone knows about Joba Chamberlain’s potential, and he is a high strikeout pitcher. He also plays for one of the best teams in all of baseball, which ought to help with wins. While Francisco Rodriguez won’t come close to saving as many games as he did last year and, despite all of the talk regarding his declining skills, he should still provide you with good numbers for this season. Jonathan Broxton is also another good closer to have on your team.

I think its pretty clear though that you could use another closer. I would hang onto both Corpas and Lyon in case Huston Street or Fernando Rodney falters. But I wouldn’t bother starting either of them until they take over their respective closer positions. I definitely like that you were able to grab Zach Greinke, as he is a (popular) breakout candidate with legitimate potential. Hopefully, for this team’s sake, he breaks out in 2009.

The remaining few pitchers are dispensable. While Trevor Cahill and Jordan-Zimmermann both have potential, it is highly unlikely that they will reach that potential this year. This strategy places too much stress on pitching, and while they may have their moments this year, a large majority of pitchers simply need more than a year to adjust to major league hitting. So if a closer becomes available on the waiver wire, I wouldn’t hesitate to drop either Cahill or Zimmermann to get the extra saves.

Overall, I think Nathan did a pretty good job executing Derek’s strategy. Adding an extra closer or two is essential for this strategy to really work but considering the depth of this league, I think this team will end up winning more categories than it will lose.

Print This Post
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
I tried this strategy over the weekend, with an even more extreme focus on pitching. How do you think it went? 10-Team H2H Mixed League Traditional 5×5 C: V.Martinez (11) 1B: Conor Jackson (12) 2B: H.Kendrick (13) 3B: C.Figgins (10) SS: J.Reyes (1) MI: J.Peralta (15) CI: C.Kotchman (16) OF: L.Milledge (14) OF: W.Tavares (18) OF: S.S.Choo (20) OF: D.DeJesus (22) OF: F.Lewis (24) Util: C.Guillen (21) Bn: Matt Wieters (19) SP: CC.Sabathia (2) SP: R.Halladay (3) SP: D.Haren (4) SP: R.Oswalt (5) RP: J.Papelbon (6) RP: J.Nathan (7) RP: J.Soria (8) SP: C.Billingsley (9) Bn: C.Marmol (23) Bn: J.Arredondo… Read more »

Apparently I left out the fact that I also have Javier Vazquez on this team.  Do you have any other ideas for relatively high average hitters that may be available?  Given your analysis, that seems to be the spot to improve.

At the time of draft, both Corpas and Lyon were expected to be closing.  Given the league is so deep, two closers is not bad, but I have definitely been looking around for possible trade partners.

Marco Fujimoto
Marco Fujimoto
JTIn, Unless you want other readers to analyze your team, please direct all team-analysis requests to the roster doctor email address linked above in the first paragraph. Nathan, You (and others) may have noticed, but we at THT are pretty high on Vazquez this year. So this pitching staff looks much better now, and I feel more confident in its ability to win more categories, more weeks than not. I completely understand the reasoning behind having drafted Corpas and Lyon. You aren’t the only one who drafted those two guys. But, drafting them wasn’t necessarily a mistake, as the jobs… Read more »
This is the strategy I use.  I like getting all those leadoff hitters, and the power guys I do have are 20/20 potentail, ie Nate McClouth, Jayson Werth, & especially Randy Winn.  What I do differently is I get Brian Roberts in the 2nd or 3rd round & for SS I get Jason Bartlett toward the end of the draft, SS of the Rays who can get you 30+ SBs and hit around .280.  Jose Reyes doesn’t seem worth it to me that early, I would get someone like Santana, Lincecum, or possibly a power guy there instead (or especially… Read more »