Staff rankings: Relief pitchers

The staff rankings by position end with our top 35 relief pitchers for the 2012 season. Don’t fret, though! A top 200 will come soon (hint, starting tomorrow). The following writers have ranked their top 35 relievers: Josh Shepardson, Ben Pritchett, Brad Johnson, and yours truly.

We used FantasyPros.com to create our composite rankings, and if you follow the link provided in our rankings, you can see how ours compared with a slew of other experts’. Assume a 12-team, mixed league with standard 5×5 settings.

Click on the links with our names to get to our Twitter accounts, where we’ll happily answer your baseball and fantasy questions year-round.

2012 Relief Pitchers Rankings
Player Name Nick
Fleder
Ben
Prichett
Josh
Shepardson
Brad
Johnson
THT
Composite
FantasyPros
Expert Consensus
Craig Kimbrel 2 3 1 2 1 view
John Axford 3 5 3 5 2 view
Jonathan Papelbon 5 8 2 3 3 view
Mariano Rivera 4 6 4 4 4 view
Brian Wilson 8 7 9 6 5 view
Matt Moore 1 1 1 6 view
Drew Storen 10 9 5 11 7 view
Heath Bell 13 4 13 10 8 view
Joel Hanrahan 9 18 7 7 9 view
Ryan Madson 11 12 11 8 10 view
J.J. Putz 6 16 8 15 11 view
Cory Luebke 7 2 23 20 12 view
Jose Valverde 12 11 15 18 13 view
Andrew Bailey 17 13 14 14 14 view
Kenley Jansen 16 19 6 19 15 view
Rafael Betancourt 15 17 20 9 16 view
Sergio Santos 14 26 10 12 17 view
Joakim Soria 19 21 12 23 18 view
Jason Motte 18 22 18 17 19 view
Huston Street 21 24 16 16 20 view
Carlos Marmol 20 14 21 24 21 view
Chris Sale 24 15 24 22 22 view
Jordan Walden 26 25 22 13 23 view
Joe Nathan 22 20 19 35 24 view
Neftali Feliz 28 10 26 36 25 view
Brandon League 27 23 25 21 26 view
Kyle Farnsworth 23 27 17 37 27 view
Frank Francisco 25 32 28 28 view
Matt Thornton 33 38 27 26 29 view
Addison Reed 35 43 29 25 30 view
Jim Johnson 37 28 32 27 31 view
Jonny Venters 30 41 28 32 view
Matt Capps 29 31 30 33 view
David Robertson 36 29 34 view
Daniel Bard 29 34 35 view

Fantasy Baseball Rankings powered by FantasyPros, the leading aggregator of expert fantasy advice.

Tomorrow… Top 200


Print This Post
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Ben Pritchett
Guest
Ben Pritchett
@Donald Trump- Ditto what Brad said. We only ranked starters that had reliever eligibility and relievers that had starter eligibility. Miggy does not have 3B eligibility which is why we and every other service have not yet ranked him as a third baseman. I do wish Josh would have ranked Moore I think he would’ve agreed that he should be considered the number one reliever eligible player. In regards to Luebke, I actually think he is going to be good for near 200 strikeouts which is why he is number 2 on my list. Others might not be so convinced… Read more »
Brad Johnson
Guest
Brad Johnson

Luebke’s one of those guys where I look at the stat sheet and see something different than what my eyes told me (only saw two starts though). I tend to penalize players whose stats don’t coincide with my personal scouting report. He’s one that may require a re-evaluation.

I’ve talked a lot about guys I ranked fairly highly but would almost never draft. Luebke might be the inverse case.

Mark Himmelstein
Guest
Mark Himmelstein
Interesting list. There are a bunch of guys with two wildly divergent consensuses or three agreements and one dissenter.  The tiers of closers I’m generally trying to select from are as follows: Hanrahan* Madson* Santos* Walden* Betancourt** Motte** Farnsworth*** Francisco*** Thornton*** Reed*** These are the guys I’m finding myself winding up with, and I try to get one guy I indicated here with one *, one with **, and one or two with***. Here’s the notes: -Hanrahan’s the earliest closer I’ve found myself willing to draft, and the best of this group. -Madson and Santos are close, though I’m slightly… Read more »
Brad Johnson
Guest
Brad Johnson

Street was initially further down my list, but I bumped him up since he’ll be pitching in Petco Caverns.

Dave Shoveoin
Guest
Dave Shoveoin

I agree with Brad that Betancourt should be ranked higher on the list. I also think that Jason Motte is far too low.

Jthom17
Guest
Jthom17
You think Moore being #1 RP is ameaningful list. Moore, Luebke, Feliz, Sale & Bard should not be on a list as TOP 35 RP for 2012. Since most fantasy RP value comes from saves, how do you omit Chris Perez, Javy Guerra or even Grant Balfour from the list? History has shown that if they open the year at closer, they will get close to 20 saves. Capps better than Chris perez is a laugh. I do not see Pestano as the future closer in CLE. As great as he was v. RHP, he equally bad v. LHP (4.50… Read more »
Mark Himmelstein
Guest
Mark Himmelstein

@Jthom17

The problem was, Perez was that bad against EVERYONE.  I’ll even buy that Perez is a guy who perhaps can keep his ERA ~1 run lower than his xFIP (career 3.13 / 4.33, though thats only 221 IP and if an SP did that over one full season, we’d be screaming fluke), but his xFIP was 5.01! If he’s anything close to that again this year, he’s just a balloon waiting to burst, and Pestano was pretty clearly the best reliever in that pen last year.

Brad Johnson
Guest
Brad Johnson
I don’t understand. If a player has a position designation, then he can be used there and should be ranked. There are leagues where those RP eligibilities will be valuable. I’m with you on Capps, he’s right next to Kevin Gregg on my poop list. I’d go as far as to draft Glen Perkins before Capps. Derek Carty convinced me that Pestano is not as good an option as he appears at first glance. I was one of the first on that Pestano for closer bandwagon, but now I’m off. I do think that Manny Acta could potentially platoon Pestano… Read more »
Brad Johnson
Guest
Brad Johnson

Thoughts:

Josh clearly didn’t get the memo about Moore’s eligibility for this list.

Sticking with Josh, he’s really confident that Jansen will win the closing job out of spring training. If Guerra leaches 15+ saves, which seems like a reasonable expectation, then Jansen loses a lot of value.

Similarly, I’m confident saying my colleagues are too bullish on Betancourt. He’s got similar numbers to Madson, an equally long track record of success, and a semi-secure job.

Overall, reliever’s the position where this kind of variance in ranking is expected.

Donald Trump
Guest
Donald Trump

it seems silly to have starters (even if they have rp eligibility) in here.  Four people ranked Moore #1 and one guy didnt even rank him. Leubke ranges from 2-23.  It messes up the purpose of this article. It is better to keep SP with the SP, regardless of designation. 
Likewise, Miggy should be ranked with both 1B and 3b.

Brad Johnson
Guest
Brad Johnson

The software we used only includes eligible positions. Aside from Moore and Luebke, the other relievers who are being converted (Sale, Feliz, Bard, Chapman (unranked)) could very well end the season in the pen.

Further, while Moore and Luebke are eligible at SP, Sale, Feliz, Bard, and Chapman are not. That leaves RP as the only position we can use to give a sense of value.

Ben Pritchett
Guest
Ben Pritchett

Brad, I think you meant we are “bearish” on Betancourt. I actually like his skills and potential if he were 29 or 33 or even 35 but he’s 37. I think that he should be fine, but his age makes me look to the guys like Ryan Madson.

Also Brad, great point about the relievers’ positional variance in our rankings.

People that deviation from the mean is exactly the reason why you shouldn’t draft closers early!

Donald Trump
Guest
Donald Trump
“Anyone in a standard H2H league will be very interested in Moore and Luebke’s RP eligibility.”… agreed, but he should be compared to SP, not RP.  Nobody is debating taking Moore or Papelbon, they are considering him vs another SP. I can, and people certainly will, draft Cabrera as a starting 3b, even if he cant play there the first week.  To argue otherwise is ridiculous. He IS a 3B, regardless of what some software program says. So what if fantasy pros does the software, you posted it here… me and my friends could all rank the top 3B in… Read more »
Brad Johnson
Guest
Brad Johnson
I’m not following your rationale. Howie Kendrick is on my 1B board but I’m going to draft him as a 2B if I pick him. Is there a problem with knowing where he stands as a 1b? The same concept applies except we’re simply more certain we will use Moore as a SP. It still doesn’t hurt to know where he would go purely as a reliever. We can’t do anything about Miggy yet, period. We discussed him in the comments and we’ll discuss him again tomorrow. For instance, I’ll have to explain why Pujols is my top ranked 1B… Read more »
Donald Trump
Guest
Donald Trump

” Is there a problem with knowing where he stands as a 1b?”… agreed, everyone should be ranked at all the positions they are eligible in.  I now agree that Moore should be ranked at RP, I got sidetracked and am not sure why I was arguing against.  My only point should have been that a guy like Miggy should also be ranked at 3B in addition to 1B even though he doesn’t have the eligibility yet, because that is the position most people will draft him for.

Donald Trump
Guest
Donald Trump

I get that adding Miggy at 3B is impossible because of fantasy pros, but i think you get that it is a bit ridiculous to publish a blog and not rank miggy at 3B when every single person has miggy ranked at 3B in their personal rankings.  I get that it is not your fault or choosing.

Donald Trump
Guest
Donald Trump

Just to beat this to death… you ranked Moore as the #1RP because he is actually an SP (who happens to be really good), but you then ranked the next best SP/RP, Cory Leubke, as the #20rp.  So Moore is better than all the closers in baseball, and Leubke is better than basically none of them?  Maybe this is the problem with ranking SP with the RP, the valuation system is clearly messed up.

Ben Pritchett
Guest
Ben Pritchett

If you look Trump, I had Luebke as number 2, Feliz at 10, and Sale I have at 15 (I love, love, love Sale. I’d rank him higher if I had the guts to live with being wrong). I think I did a better job than my cohorts at ranking starters as relievers. In all fairness, I play in a league where using a starter as a reliever is not only important, it’s essential. The rest of my leaguemates haven’t figured this strategy out, and they don’t know I write here either. But what they don’t know, won’t hurt me.

Donald Trump
Guest
Donald Trump

My bad.  I looked at Ben Johnsons rankings before, not yours.  You are correct to have ranked Moore and Leubke together. You actually did a great job in ranking the SPs here (I had not taken the time to analyze the individual picks in detail).  Your cohorts did not do as well.
I agree with you 100% on strategy, I just discovered the value of SP/RP last year as well. On that note… Champman is a must grab.  Long shot, but could be a huge game changer if he is a starter.

Brad Johnson
Guest
Brad Johnson
I think we all let the formats we play bias our rankings significantly. I tend to play and favor formats that don’t distinguish between SP and RP. I’m also pretty bearish about Luebke, or I was when I made these rankings. I actually don’t know why, so it’s probably something I need to correct. And because I do auctions, I think in terms of dollars. Anyway, to get back on track, the three factors combined caused the low ranking on Luebke. Reconceptualizing it a little, I should have ranked him 14th between Jordan Walden and Andrew Bailey. The low ranking… Read more »
Donald Trump
Guest
Donald Trump

Gotcha and agreed.

John K
Guest
John K

ranking starting pitchers on this list isn’t helpful

Donald Trump
Guest
Donald Trump
“I don’t understand. If a player has a position designation, then he can be used there and should be ranked. “… most people will use Moore as a SP, so that is where he should be ranked.  I guess it comes down to: Why would anyone do a 3B ranking and not include Miggy?  It would be ridiculous, as we ALL know he will be 3B eligible in one week and we all are going to draft his as a 3b.  Comparing Moore and Luebke to RP is like comparing Kinsler to Carlos Santana, it is apples and oranges. These… Read more »
Brad Johnson
Guest
Brad Johnson

DT,

Anyone in a standard H2H league will be very interested in Moore and Luebke’s RP eligibility. That’s a pretty large audience.

We can’t rank Cabrera as a 3b, just as you can’t draft him as a 3b. We’re beholden to the settings that Fantasy Pros established which I believe are based off Yahoo! settings.

wpDiscuz