The best teams that only had one All-Star

Yes, yes, this time it counts, but Major League Baseball still wants to make sure that all 30 fanbases have a reason to watch the All-Star Game. That reason may be as simple as giving fans in Houston the opportunity to see Jose Altuve take a single plate appearance in front of a media circus, but even still, it’s reason enough. In the middle of a dreary year, seeing a player from a struggling hometown team warmup and play with the greats is, at the very least, a nice distraction from a 100-loss season. Being a fan of a terrible team can feel like all of the joy in baseball is passing right by without a second look, and sending even just one player from every team makes the All-Star Game the league-wide exhibition is should be. Sure, occasionally baseball trips on its feet and selects a Mark Redman (a 5.27 ERA in the first half), but for the most part, the lone token selections are worthy of a spot on the roster, even if you have to squint a tiny bit.

Now, of course, good teams don’t have to worry about any of this. Division leaders, pennant contenders, and even most teams above .500 usually have more than one player worthy of an All-Star selection. This year, 12 teams had one representative at the 2012 All-Star Game, and they averaged 73 wins by the year’s end.

But what if teams outside the basement are only sending their one token representative? Good teams have good players, and good players get selected to All-Star games, right? Surprisingly, there are some enormous slip-ups.

The Pyramid Rating System’s All-Time Pittsburgh Pirates
Though there's one key player missing, this squad rosters six Hall of Famers.

W-L Record Year Team All-Star
102-60 1977
KCR George Brett
102-60 2001 OAK Jason Giambi
99-63 1983 CHW Ron Kittle
99-63 2002 ANA Garret Anderson
98-64 1979 PIT Dave Parker
97-65 2002 STL Matt Morris
92-62 1946 DET Hal Newhouser
97-66 1999 NYM Mike Piazza
96-66 2004 ATL Johnny Estrada
95-66 1979 MIL Cecil Cooper
94-67 1988 LAD Orel Hershiser
94-68 1991 ATL Tom Glavine
94-68 1993 MON Marquis Grissom
94-68 1982 BAL Eddie Murray
94-68 2012 OAK Ryan Cook
94-68 1977 TEX Bert Campaneris
59-43 1981 STL Bruce Sutter
93-69 2005 CLE Bob Wickman
93-69 2006 OAK Barry Zito

That’s right. Baseball has twice given a 100-win team the All-Star short shrift.

The 1977 Royals sent George Brett and no one else, even though they finished the season with the best record in baseball. Al Cowens contributed a full third of his 13-year career’s WAR total in 1977, with a 5.2 WAR mark in right field, but he ran into an incredibly talented group of American League outfielders in Carl Yastrzemski, Reggie Jackson and Jim Rice. Dennis Leonard finished the year with 20 wins, a fourth-place Cy Young finish, and an eye-opening 8.7 WAR, but he wasn’t selected. That WAR figure has been bested by a starting pitcher only 23 times in the 35 years since then, and yet, Leonard couldn’t beat Dave LaRoche for a spot on the roster.

The 2001 Athletics were also only allowed to send one guy to the Midsummer Classic, Jason Giambi. The three-headed pitching monster of Barry Zito, Mark Mulder, and Tim Hudson would combine for eight All-Star selections and a Cy Young win over their careers, but none were selected in 2001.

The 2001 A’s seem to typify the sort of team that succeeds in spite of a single All-Star selection. One superstar, Giambi, and a large collection of valuable players who seemingly just miss the level of production that garners national attention and praise. The A’s had four players who finished the year in the 5-6 WAR range, but only one star above that level.

And even though a team with one superstar and a flock of solid regulars can slip under the All-Star radar, it’s still eye-opening to see that three All-Star games have been played with a single lone representative from the eventual World Series winner.

References & Resources
All All-Star data from Baseball-Reference. All WAR data from Fangraphs.


Print This Post
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
David Bristol
Guest
David Bristol

Nice article, I was thinking it would include post-season success . . . of course I *could* look it up myself, but then I wouldn’t be working.  Then again, I’m not working now either! 

Anyway it’s nice to see Dennis Leonard recognition, growing up in the 80’s I was always blown away by his and Mark Gubicza’s inning totals – at least until their arms fell off.

Nickolai
Guest
Nickolai

Don’t forget that while the 2001 A’s finished w/ 102 wins, they looked pretty mediocre at the half.  Their season splits that year are insane:

1st Half: 44-43 (.506 win %), 404 runs scored vs. 385 runs allowed  
2nd Half: 58-17 (.773 win%!), 480 runs scored vs. 260 runs allowed

1 All-star from a .500-ish team seems about right.

MikeS
Guest
MikeS

What @Nickolai said.  The same holds for the 1983 White Sox.  They were mediocre at the break and unbeatable after.

Chris Waters
Guest
Chris Waters

Neat article, but I would like to point out that Steve Rogers was with Montreal in 1982.

piazza
Guest
piazza

The 2004 Braves bit is bizarre. They have Chipper, Andruw Jones, JD Drew and Rafael Furcal, among others, and they sent Johnny Estrada?

asym
Guest
asym

How about that, a list of greats without a single mention of the Yankees.  How many of the years had ballot stuffing, er I mean ‘fan’ voting?

John A
Guest
John A

The 93 Expos had only one All-Star?

wpDiscuz