THT Awards

Welcome to the awards.

All stats are for Monday, April 15 through Sunday, April 21. Please see the week one column for category explanations.

This week’s proof that assigning wins and losses to a pitcher is an archaic practice that must stop

Good luck division

One thing about games in which your teammates throw up 14 runs in the first two innings and 19 in the game is that you can get shellacked for six runs and fail to make it out of the fourth and you still don’t get a loss. Take a bow, Scott Kazmir.

Lance Lynn got the win despite allowing four runs in five innings of work on seven hits and three walks. Pittsburgh starter James McDonald was much worse, failing to make it out of the second inning.

Because Barry Zito was hammered for nine runs in two and two thirds, Wily Peralta was able to yield six runs in four frames and not take the loss.

Jeff Francis was rocked to the tune of eight runs in four and a third. But the Mets bullpen ended up blowing the lead and losing the game. Francis received a no-decision.

David Price and Miguel Gonzalez were touched up for five runs each, Price in six frames, Gonzalez in five and two thirds. Darren O’Day and Jake McGee each blew a save and neither starter took the loss.

Julio Teheran and Jeff Locke posted game scores of 38 and 35 respectively and each managed to avoid the loss.

Hyun-Jin Ryu was punished with five runs in six frames but was let off the hook by a Pedro Strop blown save.

Gio Gonzalez was shelled for five runs in four frames. His opposing starter, Jeremy Hefner also lasted only four innings, allowing three runs. The bullpens took turns giving up runs and neither starter was given the loss.

Bad luck division

Homer Bailey and Kyle Kendrick threw 15 scoreless innings between them, allowing only four hits, walking two, and striking out 14. Neither was credited with the win.

Max Scherzer and Felix Hernandez combined to allow just two runs in 16 innings on 10 hits and one walk, striking out 12 each. Neither received the win in a game that went 14 innings.

The day after Scherzer pitched his gem and failed to win, Justin Verlander gave the Tigers a nice start, going seven frames, allowing two runs, walking one, striking out 12. Detroit was shut out and Verlander took the loss.

Mental Health and the CBA
A particular bit of language in the latest CBA could have negative consequences for some players.

Cliff Lee pitched seven innings, holding the Reds to two runs on five hits and a walk, striking out four. He was denied the win as Bronson Arroyo and Aroldis Chapman held the Phillies to two runs.

Jeremy Guthrie and Kris Medlen combined to allow just four runs in 14 innings on 11 hits and one walk, striking out 11. Neither was credited with the win, which went to reliever Eric O’Flaherty because of Kelvin Herrera’s implosion.

Pat Corbin held the Yankees to one run in seven innings, striking out seven, walking three. He posted a game score of 73 and was denied the win by a J.J. Putz blown save.

Hiroki Kuroda posted a 74 game score for the Yankees, going seven and a third, allowing one run with seven strikeouts to one walk and was denied the win by a David Robertson blown save.

Mat Latos gave the Reds seven innings allowing one run on six hits, striking out 10, walking one. Cincinnati scored only one run and Latos was left with a no-decision.

Vulture Award

Andrew Bailey blew the save for Ryan Dempster, wasting his 77 game score
only to watch Mike Napoli send Dustin Pedroia home to win the game for him.

Hector Santiago pitched an inning and two thirds. He was lifted after having retired the first two batters of the inning in succession for Matt Lindstrom. After Lindstrom threw three pitches to retire J.P. Arencibia, Dayan Viciedo plated a White Sox base runner to break the tie. Santiago had retired five batters. Lindstrom retired one and was given the win.

Sean Doolittle blew the save for the A’s by allowing a solo home run to former Oakland first baseman Carlos Pena only to watch his teammates score another run and hand him a victory.

Wes Littleton Award

Andrew Bailey’s first save of the season was of the three-run variety. He retired Cord Phelps, Lonnie Chisenhall and Drew Stubbs.

Please hold the applause

Tom Gorzelanny allowed as many home runs as he recorded outs. He got the hold.

Any sufficiently advanced defense is indistinguishable from pitching

Tommy Hanson struck out two of the 26 Tigers he faced and still wound up with six scoreless innings and the win. He walked twice as many as he retired via strikes.

Hiram Burgos struck out one of the 19 Cubs he faced and recorded five scoreless innings and the win.

Things John likes

I know I’ve been using this exclusively as a platform to recognize the relatively rare times when a manager has given a reliever long outings and I promise I will come up with something different soon. Either that or I will rename this category. But let me just point out that I like what Ron Gardenhire did on Tuesday with Anthony Swarzak.

After Mike Pelfrey scuffled through five innings, allowing four runs but still making it out of the game with a lead thanks to Jason Vargas and his own shelling, Gardy put Swarzak in to protect a three-run lead and didn’t lift him until the ninth inning, when he had put a couple of men on base with the heart of the Halos’ lineup coming up. Glen Perkins was the new pitcher, and while he allowed Mike Trout to drive in a couple of runs charged to Swarzak, I can’t fault anybody too much and I can’t minimize the leverage of coming into the game with two on and Trout and Albert Pujols coming to bat.

This is how middle relievers and swing men are supposed to be used. Instead of using five different bullpen pitchers who may or may not have their good stuff on that day, use the one guy who seems to be doing well and will keep you ahead with little fuss until he runs into a problem and then you bring in your bullpen ace to shut the other guy’s big, scary monsters down. And that is what happened here.

To that same end, I will also say it was cool to see the Orioles give the three-inning save to Tommy Hunter, closing out the Dodgers with three scoreless after entering with a five-run lead. I’m not sure I think that should be counted as a save, but I like what Buck Showalter is doing there. And the same goes to the Rangers and Michael Kirkman, who went three innings against Seattle after entering with an eight-run lead.

Joe Carter Award

This week, Pablo Sandoval drove in seven Giants, tied for fourth in the majors and one more than Joe Mauer, who smacked the ball around for a .588/.667/.824 week. Sandoval batted .273/.292/.455.

J.J. Hardy inexplicably plated five runs for the Orioles while hitting .143/.208/.333 in 23 PA.

Allen Craig collected six RBI in 21 PA but batted an uninspiring .263/.333/.368.

Sanchez Award

Jeff Francoeur singled six times in 20 PA this week and did very little else. No extra base hits and no walks lead to an empty batting average. He ended the week with a .300/.300/.300 line.

Similarly, but not exactly, Brandon Belt went .294/.300/.294 and Michael Young went .292/.320/.292.

Ryan Howard struggled along to the tune of .278/.263/.278.

Harmon Killebrew Award

Ryan Braun singled only once all week. On the other hand, he homered three times and drew five walks in his 25 PA for a .200/.360/.650 line.

Steve Balboni Award

At this point, we all know to expect Adam Dunn to show up here from time to time just because of his strikeout rate. The Big Donkey fanned in exactly half of his 22 plate appearances and ended the week batting .048/.130/.190.

Dunn’s teammate Alejandro de Aza had a bad week as well with 10 strikeouts in 23 PA and a .227/.261/.409 line.

Stephen Drew fanned nine times in 18 PA and went .118/.167/.176.

Chris Carter continued to strike out at staggering rates and continued to post horrendous triple slash lines with nine Ks and a putrid .053/.208/.053 line.

Josh Hamilton whiffed eight times and went .048/.130/.048 in 22 PA.

Justin Smoak posted a .182/.280/.182 with 10 strikeouts in 25 PA.

Will Middlebrooks fanned 11 times in 26 PA and ended the week at .080/.115/.080.

Three true outcomes

Kelly Johnson smacked two home runs, walked five times, and struck out nine times in 24 PA.

Braun posted a three-five-nine TTO line in his 25 PA.

Justin Upton went two-four-eight in 25 PA.

Arencibia is missing a category, but four-zero-10 in 28 PA is worthy of mention.

Joey Votto went two-five-seven in 31 PA.

The anti-TTO

Eric Young Jr. did not hit a home run or walk. He struck out once in 25 PA.

Ben Revere posted a zero-zero-three three true outcomes line in 25 PA.

This week’s MVP

AL: Napoli went .345/.406/.690 and boosted his season’s line for the Red Sox from .217/.234/.413 to .267/.304/.520.

NL: David Wright reached base 14 times, seven via hit and seven more via walk. He did not strike out all week. He also added two triples, two home runs, and two steals while putting up a .350/.519/.850 line for the Mets.

Print This Post
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Jim G.
Jim G.

I agree with you about middle reliever usage. How many times have we heard pitchers say if they’re “on” it doesn’t matter if the batter is lefty or righty. They’re going to get them out.
And what makes starting pitchers so special that they are allowed to face their opposing handedness, even to the point the other team will load the lineup with them?


Man, I look forward to THT Awards every Tuesday. Thanks again John.

No ma'am we're musicians
No ma'am we're musicians

‘Ben Revere posted a zero-zero-three three true outcomes line’

he’s in the anti-TTO section, so I suppose the order is HR/W/SO.  I’ve never been clear on what order is being used when just numbers are mentioned, I just like to read the prose about how Dunn is remarkable.

Anyone ever do a ‘Stratomatic’ evaluation of a team of TTOs vs the anti-team?  Pitching handled by the provider of the most outcomes in the offenses category….hmm.

John Barten
John Barten

Jim: I’m just here, nodding my head in agreement.

Neil: Thanks. That means a lot.

Musicians: Yep, my order is always HR/BB/K. I always make sure I use the words for the first TTO candidate before using the “line” shorthand.

No idea about the strat question. The internet is a big place though.