Could all this Strasburg noise be for nothing?

Today, Dave Cameron weighed in on the whole “Should Stephen Strasburg go to the All Star Game” debate. That got me thinking, if Strasburg is elected, will he even play? Here’s what I had to say in the comments over at Fangraphs.

Are we sure Strasburg would even pitch if elected? The Nats are holding a considerable cash cow in Strasburg and he happens to be on a pretty strict innings/pitches cap. I would think the Nats will try very hard to persuade him not to alter his routine so he can pitch the 5th inning of a game he’ll be going to for the foreseeable future.

Most importantly, Strasburg is already lined up to start somewhere between July 9th and 11th depending on how the Nationals juggle the rotation. The All Star Game is the 13th. It’s hard to imagine Strasburg climbing the mound in Anaheim on short rest after how carefully the Nationals have nurtured him. Perhaps the Nats would embrace the opportunity to get their money maker in front of the national audience and skip/shorten his last start.

So what do you guys think? Will Strasburg be available to pitch? Will the Nationals attempt to convince him not to pitch? Will he play regardless of his team’s wishes?

To me, this is a much more interesting question to pursue. I think that people get caught up in these notions of what the All Star Game is and isn’t. I’d have to guess that if it’s about anything, it’s the league showing appreciation to the fans by putting the most interesting and exciting players from each league on display. Right now, Stephen Strasburg is probably the most interesting and exciting player in baseball. He makes my cut.


Print This Post
The critics love The Daily Grind! "Reading these every day is like watching one man's slow descent into insanity." - Thomas ..... Follow Brad on Twitter @BaseballATeam or email him here.
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Craig Glaser
Guest
Craig Glaser

I was thinking the same exact thing.  I’m sure the Nationals don’t want him pitching in the game. 

He’ll be there soon enough though.  Leave him out this year.

Jim
Guest
Jim
NOOOOOOO. Stop the debate.  He should not pitch in the All-Star game because he doesn’t deserve it.  If we picked the All Star game after 4 starts wouldn’t you pick the guy who had 31 IP, 19 H against and 1 ER! Wow that guy must be the greatest ever!  That’s Livan Hernandez my friends, come on think before you speak/type.  How about we put Chris Shelton on April 2006 on the team too. Put Strasburg in the Futures game and let him throw an inning there – maybe there would be some more interest in that game if they… Read more »
obsessivegiantscompulsive
Guest
obsessivegiantscompulsive

I don’t think he deserves it, Zimmerman if anyone should get that spot. 

However, I don’t see what the problem would be if he starts 2-3 days before the All-Star game.  Most pitchers have an in-between throwing session in between each start, and the ASG would be right around when he’ll be throwing anyway.  And there could be an agreement, in light of the Nats concerns, to limit Strasburg to a set number of pitches or one inning, whichever comes first.

Garison
Guest
Garison
I’ll weigh in a little bit on the “does he deserve to go?” question, but I do find the “will he pitch?” question interesting as well. The most obvious argument against Strasburg is that his season is a short sample size. “Wait until he has sustained success before we crown him king of the world!!” That’s a good point, but as evidenced by Jim, it can sometimes degenerate into discussing guys like Livan Hernandez. We have an extensive history and a nasty set of stats under the hood that shows Livan is not an All-Star-caliber pitcher. On the other hand,… Read more »
Erik F
Guest
Erik F

The coaching staff does not want him to pitch. But isn’t the question whether the owners might want him to pitch? If he pitched in the all star game, would there be an effect on attendance?

Just cynical old me.

MikeS
Guest
MikeS
There’s a rule this year that starters that pitch on Sunday are not available to pitch in the game and another pitcher will be added to the roster.  These playeres are still considered all stars so they get their bonuses.  So if the Nats truly don’t want him pitching in the game all they have to do is juggle the rotation and have him pitch Sunday. There, everybody happy?  He gets to technically be an all star, he doesn’t take anybodies spot and he can’t get hurt in the game.  I still don’t really understand why anybody over the age… Read more »
Ollie G
Guest
Ollie G

I don’t think Strasburg should be selected…but for what it is worth—I saw Nats GM Mike Rizzo interviewed before a Washington game the other night and Rizzo said that it would be a great honor if Strasburg were selected and the team would be delighted to see him play.

wpDiscuz