Felix for Cy Young 2010

As the AL Cy Young announcement approaches, here’s a quick look at everyone’s favorite candidate from the northwest….

Felix Hernandez was excellent this year, Cy Young excellent. He led the league in innings pitched, ERA, games started and hits per nine, and struck out 232 batters. He pitched against the Yankees three times and the Red Sox once, winning all four of those games. Looking at his season game log, Hernandez only had four, maybe five, bad outings.

How did he do it? He showed up this season with an improved changeup, a pitch that has become one of the best single pitches in the game. I believe this had a positive effect on his fastball as well, and batters had a tough time squaring up either pitch. Both offerings get excellent sinking action and appear to duck under bats. He still spins two different breaking balls, although they seem to blend together at times. Improved deviation between the slider and curve could make Hernandez even better.

But with all these superlatives, will he win the award? Doubtful.

He struggled in what is traditionally the most important Cy Young Award statistic, wins. I guess it makes sense, since Cy Young will forever be the all-time wins leader. So, traditionally, Hernandez’ 13 wins might as well be zero when considering someone for the Cy Young award.

But it wasn’t his fault. In his 34 starts, Felix had nine no-decisions, all of which were classified as quality starts. In his 12 losses, the Mariners offense was shut out four times and scored just one run five times. Those simple numbers, numbers that every baseball fan can understand, are the reason why pitchers can’t be overly lauded or condemned for their win/loss records.


Print This Post

Leave a Reply

31 Comments on "Felix for Cy Young 2010"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Matt
Guest
Matt

Sorry but we already know all this stuff. Nothing new is presented in this post, and most writers say that he is probably going to win the award.

Tom B
Guest
Tom B
If you start looking at “coulda shoulda” on starts for Felix, do you knot also do that for the other pitchers?  Did CC or Price or whoever not also have no decisions, shutout losses, and overall bad luck in some of their starts that would have boosted their win totals even higher? In the end, I don’t think you can justify voting for one guy by giving him special considerations that you are not giving those other pitchers.  They all work with what they are given.  Felix had an outstanding season. He won 13 games. Less than half, almost 1/3… Read more »
Tom B
Guest
Tom B
I must be stupid if you just made a convincing argument, because I don’t see it. You can’t just argue for one player without discussing all of them. Felix had a great season, it was not “by far” better than everyone else.  He did not in fact lead the league in strikeouts, Weaver did.  He did not lead in WHIP either (lee and weaver). He did not lead in wins, obviously. He did not lead the league in WAR, or anything like it (surprisingly its lee even with his lack of innings and then verlander). He did not lead in… Read more »
Dave Studeman
Guest
Dave Studeman

Sven, don’t listen to grouches like Matt. I appreciated your post.

Tom B
Guest
Tom B

In fact, the more I am looking into this right now, Cliff Lee is going to lose a Cy Young award that is his by rights because he has 6 less starts than Felix/Price/CC/whoever… even though he still pitched over 200 innings, actually led the league in all sorts of measurables that he controls (a 10.2K/BB? really?!), and averaged more innings per start than anyone over 200 innings.

I agree with Dave, I liked the article… just didn’t seem fair to “assume wins” for Felix and not the others.

Bob E
Guest
Bob E

Tom – I personally think it’s great you get to put your degree to work at home on the computer. smile  Too bad you work at Burger King…  Bahaha, don’t posture over the internet it makes you appear foolish.

Tom B
Guest
Tom B

Sorry Bob, I’ll type slower next time.

Jeffrey Gross
Guest
Jeffrey Gross
Sven, You are 100% right. The man may not be the best in any specific aspect, but he’s the best rounded player. He possesses the holy trinity: He’s great at whiffs, great at limiting walks and Great at inducing groundballs. Weaver’s high K’s come with extreme flyballs. Verlander too. Felix may not be #1 in any specific category, but he’s essentially top 3-5 to EVERY category that matters. I’ve consistently ranked Felix as a top 3 pitcher in baseball, next to only maybe Wainwright and Lincecum. He’s on par with Halladay but more valuable due to his age. He deserves… Read more »
Jeffrey Gross
Guest
Jeffrey Gross

My rank of the the AL’s top pitchers:
Felix Hernandez
Cliff Lee
Jered Weaver
Francisco Liriano
Jon Lester
Justin Verlander
CC Sabathia
David Price
Zack Greinke
Colby Lewis
Gavin Floyd

adam
Guest
adam
Seems like a no brainer…his team had the lowest run production in the history of the DH….it is so blatantly obvious that his Wins were a result of poor offense and in some cases defense when Milton Bradley refused to run down a fly ball that resulted in a loss and the infield seemed to tank a lot of plays….Felix is the best talent in the AL right now and was last year…in fact he has won many pitcher of the month awards and now the Sporting News Pitcher of the Year award…the only thing that is keeping him from… Read more »
Leonardo
Guest
Leonardo

If Felix had pitched for a team like the Yanks, he’d of won about 25 or 28 games last year.

Jon N
Guest
Jon N
I don’t think Tom B’s point is unreasonable, even though I do disagree with his conclusion(s). We hear a lot about how well Felix pitched in losses, but why don’t we compare the other Cy Young candidates similarly, and see how they won/lost games? Doing so, I think, only strengthens Felix’s case. For the record, I am not including Lee in this analysis (great season, but 25/35 IP fewer than either CC or Felix, w/ 6 fewer games. Price is included because, though I believe his season compares unfavorably to Lee [fewer innings in more games than Lee], he’s in… Read more »
Jon N
Guest
Jon N
{Part II; I got a little carried away:} -Price: Of his 19 wins, 8 were Super-Quality Starts, 8 were Quality Starts, 2 were Crappy Starts, 1 was a Dud Start. -Felix: This blew me away. Of his 13 Wins, 12 were Super-Quality Starts, 1 was a Quality Start. None were Crappy Starts. None were Dud Starts. And, by the way, that one quality starts was 1/3 of an inning from being a Super-Quality Start (6.2 IP, 2 ER). This just reinforces the argument that in order to win, Felix had to be close to perfect. -OK, onto No-Decisions, using same… Read more »
El Paso
Guest
El Paso

Get ready baseball world…..Felix is only going to get better he is the real deal and he ain’t goin away.

Tom B
Guest
Tom B
Jon N – I like it, that’s certainly an interesting way of looking at Cy Young hopefuls.  The only downfall to it I see is that just looking at quality starts gives his defense credit for his cy young candidacy, something i thought we were trying to avoid. I don’t seem to be able to find the overwhelming SABR support of Felix that everyone else has.  Only baseball-reference’s win values favor him to the point where another player would not even be looked at. i mean, i can only assume the guys that were discrediting my opinion were looking at… Read more »
debevemos
Guest
debevemos
Jon that was a great post and really shines some light on how well Felix consistently pitched for the Mariners this year. Felix Hernandez’s 2010 season illustrated how much impact a bad offense can have on a dominant pitchers win/loss record. A pitcher can only impact one side of the baseball and Hernandez had no one swinging the bats for him. He was dominant in almost all of his starts, as shown by his 30 quality starts which is a feat in of its self, but suffered heavily because of the historically bad offense he had behind him. You can… Read more »
Steve
Guest
Steve
He pitched a lot of innings very well, but a lot of other pitchers had great seasons too.  You can’t just say that because he had the most innings and the lowest ERA on a crappy team that he had the best year. My God, this is straight out of the Joe Morgan School of Reasoning. You can’t say that because he had the most innning and lowest ERA, not to mention all of the other categories he either leads or is near hte top in, that he is the best pitcher in baseball? What? Why not? Why on earth… Read more »
kds
Guest
kds

The only reasons that I can see to vote against King Felix have to do with defense and park factors.  If you think that much more than normal of the run prevention when he pitched was due to these things rather than the quality of his pitching, then you should support someone else.

Joe M
Guest
Joe M

Felix has no pride in the way he wears his uniform.  He wears his ball cap cockeyed and always has his shirt untucked.  If you don’t think the voter’s take that kind of attitude into consideration, you are sadly mistaken.  Even though it’s mostly about stats, they look at other stuff whether you believe it or not.  Sorry, but it’s Lee this year.  Time for Felix to square himself away.

Steve
Guest
Steve

Felix has no pride in the way he wears his uniform.  He wears his ball cap cockeyed and always has his shirt untucked.

C.C. Sabathia would never do something like that.

Seriously, did you even think about that before you posted it?

Kyle
Guest
Kyle

Everyone knows that the Cy Young is in fact voted on by how you wear your cap. Duh!

Paul
Guest
Paul
The only problem Felix has is the one Tom B mentioned. The idea is that it is Felix SABR champion vs CC (or Price or Bucholtz) TRAD champion. The issue is that actually (or embarrasingly) C.Lee had ‘arguably’ a better season by some metrics (specifically fangraphs WAR – fWAR where Lee laps the field).  So Felix’s problem is if the SABR voters split their vote between them, then it leaves it open for the TRAD candidate. Luckily, he TRAD candidates will also split votes between them. I can honeslty see 2 different ballots, depending on the voters preference for TRAD… Read more »
Nato Coles
Guest
Nato Coles
Hi, I thought I’d add to what Jon N wrote in his comparisons of David Price, CC Sabathia, and Felix Hernandez.  I think Cliff Lee is definitely in the discussion for Cy Young winner.  If you use the metric of super-quality starts, quality starts, crappy starts, and dud starts, here’s what you get for Cliff Lee: Wins:  10 super quality, 1 quality, 1 crappy, 0 dud No-decisions:  5 super quality, 0 quality, 1 crappy, 1 dud Losses:  2 super quality, 1 quality, 4 crappy, 3 dud Total out of 28 starts: 17 super quality, 2 quality, 5 crappy, 3 dud… Read more »
Ryan
Guest
Ryan
Tom you are an idiot. Felix by far had the best season out of any pitcher in the American League.  Everyone knows the mariners had the worst offense in baseball.  I live in Seattle and had to watch the team play every other day and saw all the times that Felix one games where we only scored one run. If Felix was on a team like the Yankees or Rangers he would easily have the most wins out of any pitcher in the AL.  If you have the most strikeouts, innings pitched, and the Best ERA then you are the… Read more »
Tom B
Guest
Tom B
That’s a lot of good stuff, thanks Jeffrey. I like to think that I wouldn’t be considering “where the team ended up” if I got to vote on the MVP award.  There is clearly still great value in losing efforts (felix only starts that conversation).  The results of the actions of 24 other players determining the perceived value of the 25th doesn’t seem right.  Especially since it’s not the type of difference that you would say Hamilton could have put Detroit in the playoffs. “Plus Hamilton didn’t get to drink any Champagne. Hence, he deserve the award” This is the… Read more »
Jeffrey Gross
Guest
Jeffrey Gross

Thanks Tom. It’s slightly more awesome logic than Felix doesnt tuck in his shirt, go CC.

Jeffrey Gross
Guest
Jeffrey Gross

Nato,

The innings are always the tie breaker. More of the same quality is always the more valuable. Durability is an aspect of production which I feel is oft underrated.

Tom B
Guest
Tom B

Will the “more of the same quality” argument carry over to Hamilton… who played 20 less games than anyone else up for MVP?

Shouldn’t Hamilton be passed over like Lee?

Jeffrey Gross
Guest
Jeffrey Gross

I do not think so, no. In the AL, Hamilton was the handsdown best player, even without missing a month of the season.

On the NL Side, I still say that Tulo deserves the award, though I will not be angry if either Votto/Pujols walks away with it. Zpacks gonna get screwed over though.

Tom B
Guest
Tom B
I know this is way off topic but I’m bored. Was he hands-down the best player?  Only Fangraphs WAR/wOBA says so.  They really kill Cabrera’s defense or he’d probably be leading in WAR there, and 1B’s don’t get proper credit for alot of what their position entails.  Hamilton leads the standard rate categories… but that’s about it. Longoria and Cabrera basically lead all the measuables on BR, and Cabrera actually leads in WPA on multiple sites (which is literally most valuable player, no?). Unlike the Cy Young and the Silver Slugger awards, the MVP is all about value, right? (and… Read more »
Jeffrey Gross
Guest
Jeffrey Gross
Tom, Consider the following: 1. Josh Hamilton’s AVG/SLG stats (.359/.411/.633) are slightly better than Miguel Cabrera’s (.328/.420/.622), but Miggy has a slight edge in OBP (which is more valuable than slugging). 2. Even with park factors considered, Miguel Cabrera’s wOBA is .427. Hamilton’s is .447 3. In terms of total batting production, Hamilton’s BRAR is +55.5, having missed almost a month of play. Cabrera’s is +55.3 over the 17 additional games he played. 4. Miguel Cabrera’s 1B fielding is was indexed at -6.1 UZR/150 (take 1 year UZR with a serious grain of salt), while Hamilton’s OF fielding per 150… Read more »
wpDiscuz