Panda month-by-month:  What the fudge?

I had the pleasure of taking in one of the Giants vs. Braves games in Atlanta last week sitting next to THT’s own Studes. When Pablo Sandoval came to bat, Studes asked me the obvious question, to which I, as a close observer of the Giants, should have some manner of reasonable answer, namely: just what the heck is going on with The Panda?

After all, he hit 330/387/556 last year as a 22-year-old, and while one might expect that particular torrid pace a bit difficult to sustain, a thudding drop all the way to 268/325/382, which is where Sandoval is through yesterday’s games, was hardly what anyone expected.

The answer I gave Studes, the stock answer I give to everyone who asks (and I get asked this question with increasing and depressing regularity), is that The Panda doesn’t appear to have the tremendous bat speed he wielded last year. He’s been especially vulnerable to the high fastball, fouling off pitches he used to be driving with power. And one look at this ballplayer will suggest the likely reason for the loss bat speed: his weight, which is egregious. It would seem awfully hard to get around on the high heat when you’ve got that kind of belly in your way.

But here’s the thing: the weight explanation would be a lot more persuasive if Sandoval were noticeably heavier this year than he was last year. But he isn’t.

Moreover, one would think that whatever it is about Sandoval that’s different this year than last would have manifested itself at the very beginning of this year—or perhaps even toward the end of last year. But it didn’t.

Let me show you some numbers to explain what I mean.

Here’s Pablo Sandoval’s batting performance month-by-month, ever since he arrived in the majors in mid-August of 2008, though July of this year:

Month          PA    H   2B   3B   HR   BB   SO    BA   OBP   SLG   OPS BAbip   ISO
Aug 08         58   22    4    1    1    1    6  .393  .397  .554  .950  .420  .161
Sep/Oct 08     96   28    6    0    2    3    8  .315  .333  .449  .783  .317  .134
Mar/Apr 09     80   23    5    1    1    3   12  .307  .350  .440  .790  .355  .133
May 09        100   29    9    1    2    5   12  .309  .350  .489  .839  .338  .180
Jun 09        109   37    9    0    8   13   16  .394  .459  .745 1.203  .403  .351
Jul 09        110   31    7    1    5    5   17  .298  .327  .529  .856  .313  .231
Aug 09        105   33    7    0    5   10   12  .355  .419  .591 1.010  .364  .236
Sep/Oct 09    129   36    7    2    4   16   14  .321  .403  .527  .930  .337  .206
Mar/Apr 10     97   32    7    1    3   10    8  .368  .433  .575 1.008  .382  .207
May 10        120   26    7    1    1    6   19  .234  .275  .342  .617  .269  .108
Jun 10        105   22    4    0    2   10   11  .234  .305  .340  .645  .244  .106
Jul 10        106   22    6    0    0   10   19  .232  .302  .295  .597  .286  .063

Here’s what strikes me about this: The Panda’s performance in the first month of 2010 was tremendous, right in line with his hottest hitting of 2009. It wasn’t until May of this year when the bottom just suddenly dropped out, and he weirdly has sustained his lousy May 2010 performance with dreary consistency through June and July—a level of performance vastly lower than any he’d presented in any month of his prior career.

We see that when Sandoval arrived in the big leagues, he was immediately a very high-average hitter, but with limited power and virtually no strike zone discipline. But over 2009, he sustained the lofty batting average, while adding substantial power, and an increasingly healthy walk rate as well.

Through March/April of 2010, he was keeping up that across-the-board excellence. Only in May did he suddenly encounter a disastrous evaporation in both batting average and Isolated Power. The drop in BAbip has been particularly stunning. He’s still drawing a few walks, but not nearly enough to make up for the complete loss in production when he swings the bat.

So, I don’t know. His weight might very well be a significant problem, but the fact is that Sandoval didn’t suddenly gain a ton of weight on May 1, 2010. But whatever his problem is, it seems to have arrived with extraordinary suddenness in May, and it doesn’t seem to be in any mood to go away.


Print This Post
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Braves Fan
Guest
Braves Fan

Could it have anything to do with his divorce? Yogi Berra once said “90% of the game is half mental.”

Steve Treder
Guest
Steve Treder

It certainly could.  Outwardly, Sandoval has continued to present his jovial, upbeat personality, but who knows what he might be going through privately.  He’s still a very young man, and managing life’s stresses is often an extremely difficult challenge, even for star athletes.

Of course the whole thing might simply be a wicked case of randomness, but the longer it goes on, the less plausible that explanation becomes.

Dave Studeman
Guest
Dave Studeman

Well, why didn’t you say so???

Steve Treder
Guest
Steve Treder

Because I hadn’t THOUGHT of it yet!

Brad Johnson
Guest
Brad Johnson

So here’s an incomplete list of plausible explanations.

-Weight finally caught up to him (perhaps in the form of fatigue leading to slower reactions and/or slower swings)
-off-field distraction
-pressing at the plate/shaken confidence (the low BABIP and ISO tell the tale of a power hitter who’s swinging at bad pitches and not doing anything with them)
-lingering minor injury (any number of seemingly minor ailments could really handicap the swing of a player his size)
-What else?

Matt Lentzner
Guest
Matt Lentzner
The plate discipline stats don’t seem to support your hypothesis. He is making contact about the same rate as last year: 2009: 82.6% 2010: 83.3% Slight improvement, but probably not significant. What has changed is his O-Swing and Z-Swing numbers. 2009: O-Swing: 41.7% Z-Swing: 83.0% 2010: O-Swing: 44.1% Z-Swing: 76.6% So he’s swinging at more pitches out of the zone and taking more in the zone. This would suggest a decrease in his ability to identify pitches, or put another way, he’s getting fooled more often. It’s possible that he’s cut down on his swing to compensate since his contact… Read more »
Steve Treder
Guest
Steve Treder

“The plate discipline stats don’t seem to support your hypothesis.”

I wasn’t aware that I had a hypothesis.

Anyway, here’s the important thing:  since I wrote this little thing yesterday afternoon, Sandoval is now 4-for-6 with a double, a triple, and a home run.

Why the hell didn’t I write it back in May?!?

obsessivegiantscompulsive
Guest
obsessivegiantscompulsive
I think divorce and the consequences is the best explanation specifically for Sandoval, though off-field distraction is also part of this because the rumor is that the divorce was precipitated by a young man yielding to the temptations readily available to young rising baseball stars. Last three games: 3 for 5 2 for 5 with double 2 for 3 so far with triple and HR And it has been reported (tweeted really by Hank Schulman) that both the double and triple (415 feet) would have been homers in most parks:  http://twitter.com/hankschulman/statuses/21005605846 He appears to be recovered and ready to make… Read more »
Brad Johnson
Guest
Brad Johnson
Again, this is all supposition, anything that’s remotely plausible. I wouldn’t dismiss the injury explanation just because he wasn’t DL’d. Plenty of players play through injuries of various severity without there being a word to the public. Chase Utley is my go to example here, he played through a large chunk of a season with a bad hip labrum that only he and the club really knew about. The only reason there was any suspicion that he was hurt was because he had that un-Utley like 0-27 streak at one point. That’s an extreme example of course… As for the… Read more »
obsessivegiantscompulsive
Guest
obsessivegiantscompulsive
It’s all Studes fault, Steve, he waited too long to ask!  :^) Eh, just fate, no one could really say when he would snap out of it, he just happen to do it almost virtually after this was posted.  Notch it up to about as bad timing as one could ever hope to get. BTW, Steve, always have enjoyed your articles on the Giants, current and historical, thanks and keep up the great work! Lastly, per Matt’s comment, that jogged my memory on another possible reason, that being Sandoval being diagnosed with astigmatism during the off-season.  Turns out that last… Read more »
Steve Treder
Guest
Steve Treder

“when a player slumps for 3 months, 3 good games are not enough to declare him out of the woods”

Entirely true.

obsessivegiantscompulsive
Guest
obsessivegiantscompulsive

I understand the reticence over 3 games, but 1) he’s been hitting much better for about a week now, not just 3 games, 2) he hasn’t hit like this since April, and 3) the divorce explains all the various ups and downs pretty accurately. 

But yeah, can’t declare him out of the woods yet (I did note one step at a time), but if he’s doing something he hasn’t done since April, it’s perfectly valid to speculate that perhaps he has turned things around.

Steve Treder
Guest
Steve Treder

Meanwhile, the bullpen has just coughed up a 4-run lead in the 7th and 8th innings.  The Cubs have now tatooed the Giants’ staff for 50 hits in just shy of four games.

obsessivegiantscompulsive
Guest
obsessivegiantscompulsive

Brad, I would agree with you regarding Utley and the DL (we Giants fan encountered something similar with Foppert until he went under TJS), but looking at his career record, I don’t see a season where his OPS was under .900 and if you are talking this season, he was still at .849 OPS. 

If Sandoval was hitting over .900 or even .849 OPS, there would not have been a post like this now or over the past few months.

obsessivegiantscompulsive
Guest
obsessivegiantscompulsive
Almost anybody closely following the Giants know that Pablo is going through a divorce, which was finalized when he flew down to Venezuela for “personal” reasons the weekend after the ASG.  He’s clearly been on an emotional rollercoaster.  If you break it up even finer than a month, you can sort of see him ebbing up and down, lower and lower, then perking up: May 01-May 13:  .104/.120/.167/.287 May 14-May 31:  .333/.386/.476/.862 Jun 01-Jun 16:  .246/.333/.404/.737 Jun 17-Jul 11:  .200/.253/.213/.465 ASB Jul 15-Jul 24:  .270/.357/.405/.763 Venezuela for personal business Jul 28-Aug 10:  .300/.327/.360/.687, and he was one game away from… Read more »
felinxster
Guest
felinxster

Two words – Tiger Woods

wpDiscuz