Print This Post
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Paul Singman
Guest
Paul Singman

Haha, nice one Tuck. I’ve come to the conclusion that human refs will simply blow too high a percentage of close calls that replay becomes worthwhile in all sports.

TUCK!
Guest
TUCK!

@Paul: Thanks! I don’t know that instant replay’s the solution (see also: the timid NFL “refs”), but what bugged me was, ala West, Coulibaly wouldn’t/didn’t/couldn’t offer any explanation, which smacked of such arrogance it was simply irresistable to this cartoonist…thanks for the post!

Mark Sanders
Guest
Mark Sanders

Tuck: The MLB can’t have him; the NFL has already reserved him for the next time the Vikings play in the NFC Championship.

Jim C
Guest
Jim C
FIFA shields the refs from the press. They said all they needed to about him by not assigning him to any more matches. Clearly there should be replay for any penalty called in the box, whether it results in a penalty kick or in the disallowing of a goal. BTW, Joe West, and several other MLB umpires, are flaming assholes. MLB umpires should all be wired for sound, so that their supervisor can hear if they initiate or exacerbate any argument that takes place, and there should be a replay official in a booth to review all close calls, except… Read more »
TUCK!
Guest
TUCK!

@Mark: HAR! Bitter much there, Vikings fan? Thanks for the post!

TUCK!
Guest
TUCK!

@Jim: I don’t think I need Coulibaly accountable to the media (tho some kind of acknowlegement of All. Those. Fans. would be nice); but I sincerely think some explanation to the players and/or coaches involved was in order, and that (obviously) didn’t happen, for whatever reason. Kinda like West/Buehrle/Guillen (And totally UNlike Joyce/Galarraga/Leyland). Thanks for the post!

Lisa Gray
Guest
Lisa Gray

jim c

there are more bad ball/strike calls than any other missed calls

so why are you (and so many others) so eager to have cameras determine every other call, but not ball/strikes?

Jim C
Guest
Jim C

Because, if every pitch gets reviewed, the games will all take 4 hours. I think there could be some way to put some sensors on each batter’s uniform, and sensors in the plate, so that if the ball crossed the plate in the “strike zone”, whatever that really is, the plate umpire would hear a beep in his ear and call the pitch a strike. But I can’t imagine that being accepted at any point in my lifetime.

wpDiscuz