Worst of the worst

If you watch enough of the MLB Network—and it will surely not shock you to learn I watch a lot of the MLB Network—you will eventually see footage of pretty much every notable baseball game or event for which footage is extant. Sometimes this is in ads for programming, sometimes the programming itself, but ultimately, you see it all.

I bring this up because I was watching something the other day—Quick Pitch, probably, which towers over every other baseball highlight show like Babe Ruth towering over the American League in the 1920s—and for some reason or another they played a clip from the 2004 ALCS.

As you might imagine, I’m not fan of seeing that. But it occurred to me that fans of nearly every team must experience this sometimes, which further got me thinking about what could be classified as the worst game in history for each team. So that’s what we’re doing this week.

Before we begin, a few notes. First, owing somewhat to space restrictions, but more towards the difficulty in picking them, I’m only listing the worst games for teams I feel sure about. Furthermore, I have been using the word “team” rather than “franchise” for a reason. Insofar as franchise history is concerned, the worst game for the Expos/Nationals is “Blue Monday” in the 1981 playoffs. For Nationals’ fans though, that game means little, and for Expos’ fans I can only assume that October 3, 2004—the last day the team was actually the Montreal Expos—is the worst. So we shall worry instead only about games taking place in the team’s current city.

One last thing before we begin: it is important I point here that, when discussing worst games, I am only discussing baseball worst. As bad as losing to Boston in 2004 was for Yankee fans, August 6, 1979, when the team hosted the Orioles after returning from Thurman Munson’s funeral, was far more terrible. That’s real-life—I’m only here for the game.

New York Yankees: 2004 ALCS Game 7

Ugh. The Yankees have had some tough losses, Game 7 of the 1960 World Series springs to mind, as does Game 7 of the 2001 World Series. Both of those games, however, either immediately preceded or followed a World Series victory. On the other hand, this game came a year after the Yankees had lost a World Series—ugh—and was the culmination of a disastrous four games that saw the team blow a 3-0 lead to the hated Red Sox and do so while getting blown out at home. Ugh. Let’s just move on.

image
The Cards celebrate giving the Rangers their worst loss ever (US Presswire)

Boston Red Sox: 1986 World Series, Game 6

Conceding there’s not a real way to make a study of this, I would guess the Red Sox have more “worst games” than any other franchise. Moving backwards in time (and excluding the worst game above), there was the final game of the 2011 season, Game 7 of the 2003 ALCS, Game 7 of the 1975 World Series, Game 7 of the 1946 and so on. Those are all pretty bad losses in their own right, but even more so in the context of the Red Sox inability to win a World Series for so many years. Of course, they’ve turned it around since then as the above story—ugh—establishes.

Despite those other struggles, I think this is the clear choice for the worst game in Red Sox history. Decades away from their last World Series title, the Red Sox were repeatedly just one strike away from winning it all. Instead, they not only ended up losing the game, but losing the game owing to a succession of misplays.

Texas Rangers: 2011 World Series, Game 6

Speaking of losing the World Series when a team is just one strike away, it’s the 2011 Texas Rangers. This was one of the greatest games in baseball history, but I doubt any Ranger fans will want to watch it again for pure aesthetic appreciation. In both the ninth and tenth inning, the Rangers had two-run leads, including a two-run lead with two outs and two strikes in the ninth. No team has ever come closer to a World Series title without ending up celebrating.

San Francisco Giants: Game 7, 1962 World Series

Of course, when I say no one has come closer to winning a World Series without actually doing so than the Rangers, I am speaking figuratively. Speaking literally, no one has ever come closer than the 1962 Giants. In Game 7, trailing by one run, the Giants puts runners on second and third with two outs and slugging Willie McCovey at the plate. It had not been a great World Series for Stretch, but a hit in that situation would make everyone forget. On the other side, Yankees pitcher Ralph Terry, who had surrendered Bill Mazeroski’s series winning home run in 1960, was looking for redemption.

Ultimately, McCovey got a pretty good pitch to hit and sent a line drive in the direction of Yankee second baseman Bobby Richardson. McCovey had made good contact—he would later say the ball was the hardest he ever hit—but Richardson was placed perfectly and made the catch to end the series. Had the ball been hit slightly to the left, or to the right, or up, the Giants would have unquestionably tied the game and—with Willie Mays on second—probably won it.

Many noticed this fact, but perhaps no one took it as hard as Charlie Brown, who lamented the play not once, but twice.

MLB’s Diversity Fellowship Is a Step in the Right Direction
It is not a perfect program, but it certainly counts as progress.

Florida Marlins: March 31, 1998

This is rather an unusual choice, but I think it is an easy one when it comes to the Marlins—who have had a lot more good than bad in their days. This day was the first of the 1998 season. On Opening Day 1997—a year which ended for the Fish, of course, with 92 wins and the World Series title—the Marlins starting line-up included Gary Sheffield, Kevin Brown, Devon White, Moises Alou and “Mr. Marlin” Jeff Conine. By Opening day of 1998, all of those names save Sheffield were gone, replaced with the likes of Ryan Jackson, Josh Booty and a pre-competence Mark Kotsay. The Marlins would end up losing 108 games that season, and checking out the line-up on Opening Day, Marlins’ fans no doubt recognized the glory of 1997 was not to be repeated.

So that’s five teams. At this point, I throw it open to you to fill in the remaining 25 teams. I have some ideas on it, but for some teams, I’m at a genuine loss even for candidates for worst game. Let me know what you think in the comments, and perhaps we’ll revisit this topic another day.


Print This Post
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Frank
Guest
Frank

As an A’s fan, the one that still stings is game 1 of the 1988 WS. Not only did it bring my 13 year old self to tears, but I have to re-watch Gibson pumping his fist around the bases before every single post-season game these days.

Frank
Guest
Frank

As a life-long Cubs fan, there weren’t as many choices as you’d think. Decades of futility will do that. After mulling over games 4 and 5 of the 1984 NLCS, for me, it came down to the Bartman game in ‘03. Five outs away, and then one of the most colossal collapses/implosions EVER. I don’t blame Bartman, but that play got the whole thing going.

Marc Schneider
Guest
Marc Schneider

The Bream game for the Pirates?

InnocentBystander
Guest
InnocentBystander
I’m a Yakees fan and I disagree with your pick. That 04 ALCS loss is only the 3rd worst for me. In 2nd I put the 2001 WS. I know that the Yanks had just won in 2000, but I felt like the 2001 WS would have been a nice distraction after 9/11. Obviously nothing in the world of sports could offset what had happened in real life, but the way the 2 comebacks happened earlier in the Series it felt like it was supposed to be. Major let down when it didn’t happen. The worst was 1995 Division Series… Read more »
Patrick
Guest
Patrick

I have to agree with Marc, as a young fan in the early 90’s, the Bream game was devastating and I would argue the beginning of the downward spiral that the Pirates are now still trying to correct.

scott
Guest
scott

As an Indians fan, Game 7 of the 1997 WS.  They had a mediocre (86-75) season but got hot (and lucky) in the postseason, and given that the team and city hasn’t won anything in decades, a win would have stopped that in its tracks.  But their luck ran out with 2 lousy outs to go.  Oh well…

Jim C.
Guest
Jim C.

Personally, I don’t think you can ever say that a WS Game 7 is a franchise worst.  No matter how ignominious the loss, your team still came within one game of a world championship.  That’s got to be considered a highly successful season by any standards.

Instead, I’d point to games like the Bucky F-ing Dent Game, or the Robert F-ing Andino Game, or one of the games of the 1964 Phillies Phold.

hopbitters
Guest
hopbitters

I agree with InnocentBystander on 94/95 kind of rolling together into a massive crushing disappointment culminating with the ‘95 DS.

And even as a Yankee fan, the Andino game was rough to watch. It’s one of those “you wouldn’t wish that on your worst enemy” type of things that actually came to fruition. I still laugh about Bucky Dent, though. Sorry.

Rob
Guest
Rob

Game 5 of the ALDS in ‘95 is the worst Yankee loss. Besides the crushing nature of the defeat, it was also Mattingly’s last game.  Game 7 in 2001 is second.

Chris N.
Guest
Chris N.

For the Phillies I have the 1977 NLCS Game 3 “Black Friday” game,or the 2011 Game 5 playoff game loss of 1-0 to the Cardinals. I would take the 2011 game because it appears that the loss ended the greatest era of baseball in Phils history.

JBL
Guest
JBL

Just agreeing with my fellow Yankee fans that the 1995 ALDS game 5 was the worst.  2001 was bad, but bloops off Rivera happen.  2004 was almost inevitable by game 7, and I wasn’t surprised when Brown and Vazquez were destroyed.

1995 I was really expecting a win and to have a lead converted to a loss in one play is very painful.

J6takish
Guest
J6takish

Detroit Tigers: The Gallaraga game or 163 in 2009

David P Stokes
Guest
David P Stokes

For the Tigers, how about their game at the A’s on May 18, 1912?

Brent
Guest
Brent

For the Dodgers, it was October 3, 1962, game 3 of the NL tie-breaker series.

Butch
Guest
Butch

Thurman died August 2nd 1979 not the 6th.

Dale
Guest
Dale

The one that hurts the most as a Braves fan is the Leyritz game.  Being up 6-3 with five outs to get, you could almost taste the championship knowing that between Smoltz, Maddux and Glavine you’d only need to win one more game.  It wasn’t to be, though.

Richard Barbieri
Guest
Richard Barbieri

Munson died on August 2nd, but the first game after the funeral—when Bobby Murcer walked-off the Orioles—was August 6th.

Jim C.
Guest
Jim C.
scott, I understand your point, and am sympathetic.  But I still think it’s worse to get your knees cut out from under you just short of the playoffs/WS than to lose a WS Game 7.  So if I were an Indians fan (which I’m not), I think I’d be more unhappy about Game 4 of the 1996 ALDS, when a superb Tribe team was sent home by Roberto Alomar’s 12-inning home run in the twilight off Joe Table. Also, I know it’s outside the scope of this article, but the worst game in my memory is Senators-Yankees on September 30,… Read more »
Bad Bill
Guest
Bad Bill

Yes, for the Cardinals, Denkinger.

Personally, however, I think there’s also a case to be made for the Cardinals game of September 16, 1963, a 3-1 loss to Los Angeles which brought a tremendous stretch drive between them (they’d just won 10 in a row and 19 out of 20) and the Dodgers to a screeching halt, sent Stan Musial (who homered to no avail in that game) off into retirement without a final World Series, and caused a certain small boy in Illinois to cry himself to sleep that night.  Bobby Shantz, may you get what you deserve.

gdc
Guest
gdc
As some of the others say, losing when ahead is worse than failing to win from behind…would it have been a black mark if Mazeroski’s fly was caught at the wall and they lost in 10?  So McCovey’s liner finding leather wasn’t as bad as game 6 in 2002, up 5-0 (97% WPA) at the 7th inning stretch with Ortiz cruising on a 2-hit shutout and just nine outs to San Francisco’s first WS win.  Like the Denkinger call game or Buckner’s ground ball, the fact that there was another game after doesn’t destroy its infamy. Or for the Angels,… Read more »
Ed DeCaria
Guest
Ed DeCaria
I wasn’t in Chicago in the 80’s, but 2003 NLCS Game 6 was crushing. How about a game from Baltimore in April 1988? You could of course pick their 21st straight loss to open the season, in which they were winning early, but in the moment of the streak I might go with Game 16 on April 22nd. After getting swept five series in a row, they arrived in Kansas City, grounded out three straight times in the top of the first, and then gave up seven straight singles in the bottom of the first en route to a 9-running… Read more »
Todd
Guest
Todd

For the Cardinals- Denkinger?

bucdaddy
Guest
bucdaddy

Marc Schneider said…

The Bream game for the Pirates?
—-
Of course. Nothing in my 55 years even comes close. I’d bought my World Series tickets that day.

Michael Caragliano
Guest
Michael Caragliano
For the Mets: putting aside the well-documented 2007 and 2008 last day crash-and-burns, the worst was September 11, 1987- the “Terry F-ing Pendleton” game. The defending champs finally had momentum and healthy players, and they were gaining on the Cardinals. It looked like they were going to inch within a half game of the Cards on September 11th, as they had a 4-1 lead in the top of the 9th of a three-game weekend series opener at Shea. That’s when Terry Pendleton whacked the three run shot off Roger McDowell that tied the game, which the Cards won in ten.… Read more »
scott
Guest
scott
I must disagree, Jim C.  For decades, Indians fans wanted just to be in a pennant race, and from that standpoint being in a Game 7 would seem like success.  But when you’re the Indians, who have won 2 lousy titles in 112 years (they won’t win this year either), being so close to something most of the team’s fans haven’t experienced in their lifetimes, it’s a bit of a bitter blow.  And I would say the Giants’ 1962 game 7 loss is similar – they were THAT CLOSE to their first championship in SF, and when they lost they… Read more »
Paul Blocklyn
Guest
Paul Blocklyn

Any compilation of the “worst of the worst” would surely have to include the Philadelphia Phillies’ spectacular collapse in the fall of 1964, which granted Chico Ruiz a permanent place in baseball history.

Larry S
Guest
Larry S
As an Astros fan, I enjoyed listening to Vin Scully via MLB at Bat in his farewell broadcasts of the last games of the Astros in LA as an NL team. He very poignantly described Houston “as the team that came so close but remained so far”. He recounted all of the heartbreakers. Personally, I consider the 1980 NLCS game 5 to be the most heartbreaking. But that really doesn’t mean it was the “worst”. It was the greatest experience a baseball fan could have had – I saw Games 4 and 5 in person. The “worst” for Astros fans… Read more »
Larry S
Guest
Larry S

@Bad Bill – I can see where a bubble popping game in mid-September of 1963 could have broken a little boy’s heart. I guess that was your first real pennant race – the Cards hadn’t been in a WS in what, about 15 years. But think of how much sweeter it made the drive one year later to overtake the Phillies and beat the Yankees to become 1964 World Champs. How many of those 19 out of 20 did Bobby Shantz win?

Dom DeCaria
Guest
Dom DeCaria

Without a doubt – for Pittsburgh that loss to Atlanta was one of pure devastation for the franchise.  The only good thing that came from it was that we learned Sid Bream’s middle name, and it starts with an F.

For the Tigers, has to be Game 163 in 2009.  Crushing not only because it kept them out of the playoffs after leading the division for much of the season, but worse because Nick Punto (whose middle name also begins with F, as it turns out) was the key gnat in the Twins foul-ball-spraying, pitch-count-burning lineup.

pat rocket
Guest
pat rocket
For Atlanta, it’s G7 in 91 v Minnesota.  Despite a great season, the legacy of so many years of sh** baseball comes to the fore in poor baserunning and lousy relief pitching.  After that, WS G4 v NYY in 96 (Mark Wohlars won’t throw a fastball game), NLDS G4 v HOU in 05 (Clemens game.  How WAS he able to pitch so well in relief on two days’ rest?) and the NLCS game v FLA in 98 where Livan Hernandez had his own personal strike zone. And for BAL may I suggest the Jeffrey Maier (sp?) game; v NYY in… Read more »
Philip
Guest
Philip
So far as Giants history if New York were included, their worst game could be one that they actually didn’t even lose. I am referring to the Merkle’s Boner game in 1908. Instead of beating the Cubs on September 23rd, his base-running miscue resulted in a tie-game. When the season ended with the Cubs and Giants tied after 153 games, a make-up game was played. Although not a playoff game or tie-breaker in the normal sense, it was every bit in meaning – the winner would win the NL pennant. The Cubs won the game 4-2 and went on to… Read more »
Ted
Guest
Ted

For me, a Die Hard Houston Astros fan, Game 5 of the 1980 NLCS.  We drove four hours to the Astrodome to see the game.  This 13-year-old cried the entire fours going back home. 

Sorry Larry S, for this Astros fan, 1979 through 1982 were the toughest years for me.

wpDiscuz