The Dominance of Clayton Kershaw

Yesterday, I saw a nifty little tidbit in my Twitter timeline. It basically sums up the dominance of Clayton Kershaw about as well as any statistic I can think of.

It’s true. Opponents are hitting .189/.220/.288 against Kershaw this year. Kershaw is hitting .194/.237/.194 when he steps up to the plate to do the thing he’s not paid to do. Yes, he gives up a few more extra base hits than he hits himself, but just in terms of getting hits or out avoidance, opposing hitters against Kershaw have been worse than Kershaw against opposing pitchers.

And this is actually a bad year for Kershaw at the plate. Over the last four years, spanning 295 plate appearances, he has hit .202/.245/.231. Over those same four years, opponents have hit .202/.252/.298 against Kershaw.

For four years, Kershaw has posted the same batting average and on base percentage as he’s allowed actual professional hitters to put up against him. Yeah. This guy is ridiculous.




Print This Post



Dave is the Managing Editor of FanGraphs.


Leave a Reply

18 Comments on "The Dominance of Clayton Kershaw"


Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Lookin for a Junk Drawer
Guest
Lookin for a Junk Drawer
2 years 29 days ago

All of these articles have pretty much doomed Kershaw to injury and subsequent irrelevance.YOU BASTARDS DID THE SAME DAMN THING TO VOTTO!!!

Alec
Guest
2 years 28 days ago

Dave and Jeff are both huge Mariner fans. Felix is alive, and arguably the most valuable pitcher in the game (when factoring in contract and durability, he is arguably just a bit more valuable than Kershaw – note that I say arguably, just a bit, and factoring in). Dave nicknamed him King when he was 19. I don’t think he’s the problem

Robin
Guest
Robin
2 years 29 days ago

I wonder how many other pitchers we could say this about. Without looking, certainly Kershaw’s teammate Greinke.

Anon
Guest
Anon
2 years 28 days ago

Wainwright

Robin
Guest
Robin
2 years 29 days ago

Oops. Maybe not. Well, last year’s Greinke.

triple_r
Member
2 years 29 days ago

An awesome tidbit, to be sure, but you might want to fix that “apeparances”.

Stan
Guest
Stan
2 years 29 days ago

He also has more RBIs than A-Rod. It’s true… look it up.

Bruce Chen
Guest
Bruce Chen
2 years 29 days ago

He also strikes out batters more often (33.3%) than he strikes out (31%).

Anon
Guest
Anon
2 years 29 days ago

to do the thing he’s not paid to do

No. Part of his responsibility is batting. His pitching has significantly more value, but that does not mean his batting does not have any value.

If your opinion is against pitchers hitting, argue for an eight man lineup.

Dan
Guest
Dan
2 years 29 days ago

Thanks for that incredibly valuable correction. I don’t know what we’d do without your pedantry.

Anon
Guest
Anon
2 years 29 days ago

A low value comment critical of another comment’s value, well done.

Fangraphs usually tries to capture value of players that is easily missed (base running etc.), but its contributors consistently ignore the value of pitcher offense.

Also, the poor quality of pitcher hitting is often used as a strawman to push for universal DH.

I don’t see why either of these ideas should draw a sarcastic response.

The Foils
Member
The Foils
2 years 28 days ago

Because you’re saying silly things in an annoying fashion, is why.

atoms
Guest
atoms
2 years 28 days ago

While it is literally true that he is receiving compensation for a job that technically involves making plate appearances as a batter in the major leagues, I believe what Dave might reasonably mean is that the amount of his compensation is pretty much entirely tied to his skill and performance as a pitcher.

grandbranyan
Member
grandbranyan
2 years 28 days ago

The reason he got 215 million dollars is because he is the best pitcher in MLB. Do you really think if he hit like Ben Sheets he would have only got 210 million, or if he hit like Carlos Zambrano he signs for 220 million?

Do AL pitchers routinely make less money because of the DH?

Russ Adams
Guest
Russ Adams
2 years 29 days ago

I’d be interested to see if any of the good hitting mediocre pitchers also achieved anything similar, maybe a Carlos Zambrano or something

olethros
Guest
olethros
2 years 28 days ago

Zambrano was quite a bit better than mediocre for a while, I’d bet he did that for a 3-5 year period before the wheels fell off.

Trev
Guest
Trev
2 years 28 days ago

In 1915 Babe Ruth started 28 games all as a pitcher. In those 28 games (in which he always batted 9th) he hit .362/.424/.662.

In those same games as a pitcher he allowed a line of .219/.299/.253.

B
Guest
B
2 years 28 days ago

The good hitting pitchers kinda ruin this for me. Mike Hampton did it back to back years in 98 and 99. Carlos Zambrano did it in 2002. Wainwright is even doing it this year too.

wpDiscuz