​
​
Sign In
  • Support FanGraphs
    FanGraphs Membership
    FanGraphs Shirts
    FanGraphs Mugs
    Gift a Membership
    Donate to FanGraphs
  • Fantasy
    Fantasy Tools
    Fantasy Player Rater
    Auction Calculator
    Ottoneu Fantasy Baseball
    Signup, FAQ, Blog Posts
  • Blogs
    Blog Roll

    FanGraphs
    • Yankees Patch Their Third Baseman-Shaped Hole With Ryan McMahon
    • Mariners Bolster Lineup by Acquiring Josh Naylor From Diamondbacks
    • Nick Allen and the Meritocratic Tyranny of the Batting Order
    • José Soriano Can Get You to Whiff, but He Won’t Strike You Out
    Podcasts: Effectively Wild

    FanGraphs Prospects

    RotoGraphs
    • Lineup Analysis (7/27/25)
    • Pitcher Playing Time Changes: July 25, 2025
    Podcasts: The Sleeper and The Bust | Field of Streams | Beat the Shift

    Community Research
    • Effectively Wild's Preseason Predictions Game Update: Ben Clemens

    Archived Blogs: The Hardball Times | NotGraphs | TechGraphs | FanGraphs+
    Archived THT: THT Live | Dispatch | Fantasy | ShysterBall
    Archived Podcasts: FanGraphs Audio | Chin Music | UMP: The Untitled McDongenhagen Project | Stealing Home | Doing It For Bartolo | OttoGraphs |
  • Projections
    2025 Pre-Season Projections
    ZiPS, ZiPS DC
    Steamer
    Depth Charts
    ATC
    THE BAT, THE BAT X
    OOPSY
    2025 600 PA / 200 IP Projections
    Steamer600, Steamer600 (Update)
    2025 Updated In-Season Projections
    ZiPS (RoS), ZiPS (Update), ZiPS DC (RoS)
    Steamer (RoS), Steamer (Update)
    Depth Charts (RoS)
    ATC DC (RoS)
    THE BAT (RoS), THE BAT X (RoS)
    OOPSY DC (RoS)
    3-Year Projections
    ZiPS 2026, ZiPS 2027
    On-Pace Leaders
    Every Game Played, Games Played %
    Cy Young Award Projections

    Auction Calculator
  • Scores
    Today
    Live Scoreboard, Probable Pitchers
    Live Daily Leaderboards
    Win Probability & Box Scores
    2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020, 2019
    AL Games
    COL (3) @ BAL (4)Mid 4
    PHI (0) @ NYY (2)Bot 4
    TOR (2) @ DET (1)Bot 4
    LAD (3) @ BOS (0)Mid 3
    CHC (0) @ CHW (3)Mid 2
    ATL (0) @ TEX (0)Top 1
    WSN @ MIN20:10
    ATH @ HOU20:10
    SEA @ LAA21:35
    CLE @ KCR20:10
    NL Games
    MIA (5) @ MIL (1)Final
    ARI (0) @ PIT (0)Bot 6
    TBR (1) @ CIN (1)Top 4
    SDP (0) @ STL (1)Top 4
    NYM @ SFG22:15
  • Standings
    2025 Projected Standings
    2025 Playoff Odds, Playoff Odds Graphs
    2024 ZiPS Postseason Game-By-Game Odds
    AL East
    Blue Jays61420.0
    Yankees56464.5
    Red Sox55496.5
    Rays53508.0
    Orioles455715.5
    AL Central
    Tigers60440.0
    Guardians51518.0
    Royals50539.5
    Twins495310.0
    White Sox376622.5
    AL West
    Astros60430.0
    Mariners55485.0
    Rangers53507.0
    Angels495411.0
    Athletics436218.0
    NL East
    Mets59440.0
    Phillies58440.5
    Marlins49539.5
    Braves445714.0
    Nationals416117.5
    NL Central
    Brewers61420.0
    Cubs60420.5
    Reds53508.0
    Cardinals53518.5
    Pirates426119.0
    NL West
    Dodgers60430.0
    Padres55485.0
    Giants54496.0
    D-backs505310.0
    Rockies267633.5
  • Leaders
    Major League Leaders
    Batting: 2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, Career
    Pitching: 2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, Career
    Fielding: 2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, Career
    Major League Leaders - Rank
    Batting: Ranking Grid, Compare Players, Compare Stats
    Pitching: Ranking Grid, Compare Players, Compare Stats
    Splits Leaderboards
    Pitch-Type Splits Leaderboards
    Season Stat Grid

    Postseason Leaders
    Batting: 2024, (WS), (LCS), (LDS), (WCS), Career
    Pitching: 2024, (WS), (LCS), (LDS), (WCS), Career

    Spring Training Leaders
    Batting: 2025, 2024, 2023
    Pitching: 2025, 2024, 2023

    KBO Leaders
    Batting, Pitching
    NPB Leaders
    Batting, Pitching

    Minor League Leaders
    AAA: International League, Pacific Coast League
    AA: Eastern League, Southern League, Texas League
    A+: Midwest League, South Atlantic League, Northwest League
    A: California League, Carolina League, Florida State League
    CPX: Arizona, Florida
    R: Dominican Summer League
    College Leaders
    Batting, Pitching

    WAR Tools
    Combined WAR Leaderboards
    WAR Graphs
    WPA Tools
    WPA Inquirer
    Rookie Leaders
    Batters 2025, Pitchers 2025
    Splits Leaders
    Batters: vs L, vs R, Home, Away
    Pitchers: vs L, vs R, Home, Away
  • Teams
    Team Batting Stats
    2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020
    Team Pitching Stats
    2025, 2024, 2023, 2022, 2021, 2020
    Team WAR Totals (RoS)
    AL East
    Blue Jays  |  DC
    Orioles  |  DC
    Rays  |  DC
    Red Sox  |  DC
    Yankees  |  DC
    AL Central
    Guardians  |  DC
    Royals  |  DC
    Tigers  |  DC
    Twins  |  DC
    White Sox  |  DC
    AL West
    Angels  |  DC
    Astros  |  DC
    Athletics  |  DC
    Mariners  |  DC
    Rangers  |  DC
    NL East
    Braves  |  DC
    Marlins  |  DC
    Mets  |  DC
    Nationals  |  DC
    Phillies  |  DC
    NL Central
    Brewers  |  DC
    Cardinals  |  DC
    Cubs  |  DC
    Pirates  |  DC
    Reds  |  DC
    NL West
    D-backs  |  DC
    Dodgers  |  DC
    Giants  |  DC
    Padres  |  DC
    Rockies  |  DC
    Positional Depth Charts
    Batters: C, 1B, 2B, SS, 3B, LF, CF, RF, DH
    Pitchers: SP, RP
  • RosterResource
    Current Depth Charts
    AL East
    Blue Jays
    Orioles
    Rays
    Red Sox
    Yankees
    AL Central
    Guardians
    Royals
    Tigers
    Twins
    White Sox
    AL West
    Angels
    Astros
    Athletics
    Mariners
    Rangers
    NL East
    Braves
    Marlins
    Mets
    Nationals
    Phillies
    NL Central
    Brewers
    Cardinals
    Cubs
    Pirates
    Reds
    NL West
    D-backs
    Dodgers
    Giants
    Padres
    Rockies
    In-Season Tools
    2025 Closer Depth Chart
    2025 Injury Report
    2025 Payroll Pages
    2025 Transaction Tracker
    2025 Schedule Grid
    2025 Probables Grid
    2025 Lineup Tracker
    2025 Minor League Power Rankings
    Offseason Tools
    2025 Free Agent Tracker
    2025 Offseason Tracker
    2025 Opening Day Tracker
  • Prospects
    Prospects Home
    The Board
    The Board: Scouting + Stats!
    How To Use The Board: A Tutorial
    Farm System Rankings

    Top Prospects List
    20252024
    AL
    BALCHWATH
    BOSCLEHOU
    NYYDETLAA
    TBRKCRSEA
    TORMINTEX
    NL
    ATLCHCARI
    MIACINCOL
    NYMMILLAD
    PHIPITSDP
    WSNSTLSFG
    2025 Preseason Top 100
  • Glossary
    Library
    Batting Stats
    wOBA, wRC+, ISO, K% & BB%, more...
    Pitching Stats
    FIP, xFIP, BABIP, K/9 & BB/9, more...
    Defensive Stats
    UZR Primer, DRS, FSR, TZ & TZL, more...
    More
    WAR, UBR Primer, WPA, LI, Clutch
    Guts!
    Seasonal Constants
    Park Factors
    Park Factors by Handedness
  • Sign In
  • Intro
  • Features
  • Offense
    • Complete List (Offense)
    • OBP
    • OPS and OPS+
    • wOBA
    • wRC and wRC+
    • wRAA
    • Off
    • BsR
    • UBR
    • wSB
    • wGDP
    • BABIP
    • ISO
    • HR/FB
    • Spd
    • Pull%/Cent%/Oppo%
    • Soft%/Med%/Hard%
    • GB%, LD%, FB%
    • K% and BB%
    • Plate Discipline (O-Swing%, Z-Swing%, etc.)
    • Pitch Type Linear Weights
    • Pace
  • Defense
    • Overview
    • Def
    • UZR
    • DRS
    • Defensive Runs Saved – 2020 Update
    • Inside Edge Fielding
    • Catcher Defense
    • FSR
    • RZR
    • TZ / TZL
  • Pitching
    • Complete List (Pitching)
    • PitchingBot Pitch Modeling Primer
    • Stuff+, Location+, and Pitching+ Primer
    • ERA
    • WHIP
    • FIP
    • xFIP
    • SIERA
    • Strikeout and Walk Rates
    • Pull%/Cent%/Oppo%
    • Soft%/Med%/Hard%
    • GB%, LD%, FB%
    • BABIP
    • HR/FB
    • LOB%
    • Pitch Type Linear Weights
    • SD / MD
    • ERA- / FIP- / xFIP-
    • Plate Discipline (O-Swing%, Z-Swing%, etc.)
    • Pace
    • PITCHF/x
      • What is PITCHF/x?
      • Pitch Type Abbreviations & Classifications
      • Heat Maps
      • Common Mistakes
      • PITCHf/x Resources
  • WE/RE/LI
    • RE24
    • Win Expectancy
    • WPA
    • LI
    • WPA/LI
    • Clutch
  • Principles
    • DIPS
    • Regression toward the Mean
    • Replacement Level
    • Sample Size
    • Splits
    • Projection Systems
    • Linear Weights
    • Counting vs. Rate Statistics
    • Park Factors
    • Park Factors – 5 Year Regressed
    • Positional Adjustment
    • Aging Curve
    • League Equivalencies
    • Pythagorean Win-Loss
    • Luck
  • WAR
    • What is WAR?
    • WAR for Position Players
    • WAR for Pitchers
    • FDP
    • fWAR, rWAR, and WARP
    • WAR Misconceptions
  • Business

Shutdowns, Not Saves: The Logic and the Leaders from 2014

by Neil Weinberg
November 7, 2014

Who led the league in saves in 2014? Hopefully, you don’t know the answer off the top of your head. Saves aren’t a good measure of anything relating to player performance or talent and with so many things you could remember about the 2014 season, you probably don’t want to waste vital brain capacity on a random piece of trivia like who had the most saves.

The reason saves aren’t very useful is because the rule itself is not designed to provide much information. You can earn a save if you strikeout Miguel Cabrera, Victor Martinez, and J.D. Martinez in a one run game or you can earn a save if you allow five base runners against the bottom of the Padres’ order. You don’t earn a save if you preserve a tie, or if you preserve a lead in the 7th inning. Nearly everything about the rule is arbitrary, which leads you to find arbitrary results.

But the idea of something like a save is compelling for many people. There is a desire for a statistic that measures the number of a times a reliever comes in and pitches very well in an important spot. We can look at rate stats like ERA, FIP, or xFIP or cumulative numbers like RE24 or WAR, but it’s perfectly fine to want some sort of counting stat that tracks how many times a reliever slammed the door (or didn’t).

Luckily, we carry such a statistic here at FanGraphs. It’s called the Shutdown (SD). The logic is very simple. If a reliever posts a Win Probability Added (WPA) mark of 0.06 or greater in an individual game, they are given a “shutdown.” If their WPA for the game is -0.06 or worse, they are given the opposite, a “meltdown.” If it’s between the two, they are given neither.

This solves one of the key flaws in the save statistic. Relievers earn SD or MD based on the Win Expectancy of their appearance rather than a weird and arbitrary definition, which means that you can earn one without pitching in the 9th inning with a lead and finishing the game (other innings matter too!). Alternatively, if you enter in a tie game and give up the lead or if you enter down by a run and give up a lot of runs, you get dinged with a meltdown when before you would not have picked up a blown save.

Essentially, SD and MD set the same basic threshold of the average save or hold (that’s where the 6% WE comes from), but applies it to all reliever appearances rather than just a subset of them. There’s no reason not to credit or debit relievers who are pitching in tie games or when trailing, or those who pitch in non-save situations with the lead. This scaling means that 40 SD is roughly equivalent to the bar set by a 40 save closer. However, relievers will generally accumulate more meltdowns than blown saves because you can earn a meltdown in more situations than you can earn a blow save.

This statistic, inspired by Jeff Zimmerman, coined by Tom Tango, and implemented at FanGraphs provides a much better approximation of reliever performance that saves. It shouldn’t be the only metric you look at for relief pitches, but it’s a nice tool.

To that end, let’s take a look at some different ways to use SD and MD to identify some top performers from 2014 (all numbers are for relievers with 40 innings or more in relief).

Let’s open with save leaders and their number of save chances and their save percentage to get a sense of the baseline.

Name SV SV% SVOpps
Fernando Rodney 48 0.94 51
Craig Kimbrel 47 0.92 51
Greg Holland 46 0.96 48
Trevor Rosenthal 45 0.88 51
Kenley Jansen 44 0.90 49
Francisco Rodriguez 44 0.90 49
Huston Street 41 0.93 44
Jonathan Papelbon 39 0.91 43
Steve Cishek 39 0.91 43
David Robertson 39 0.89 44

So Fernando Rodney is the answer to the opening question. He locked down 48 games and blew just three saves. Greg Holland only saved 46 games but he had just 48 chances. If you like rate stats, maybe he’s your guy for 2014. But you’ll notice, if you’re up on your relievers, that a ton of great pitchers aren’t on this list at all. Let’s try something else. Let’s do the same thing, but now let’s look at SD, SD% and SDOpps (SD+MD).

Name SD SD% SDOpps
Tony Watson 44 0.846 52
Jonathan Papelbon 43 0.896 48
Zach Britton 43 0.896 48
Steve Cishek 42 0.875 48
Mark Melancon 40 0.833 48
Cody Allen 40 0.816 49
Joe Smith 40 0.889 45
Huston Street 38 0.905 42
Trevor Rosenthal 37 0.740 50
David Robertson 37 0.804 46

This is a much different list. We see Cishek, Street, Rosenthal, Papelbon, and Robertson again, but the other five names are new. Tony Watson was 2 for 9 in official save chances in 2014, but he was awesome in shutdown situations. Tyler Clippard, Pat Neshek, and Wade Davis are other names you’d see near the top of this table if it extended further.

Among relievers with at least 10 SDOpps, Ken Giles shares the best SD% at 90.5 (19 for 21) with Street. Fernando Rodney, for example, has just 25 SD in 32 opportunities, making his SD% (78.1) much lower than his SV% (94). There are plenty of fun examples to pull out and examine, but let’s peak at one more. Let’s look at pitchers with at least 20 save opportunities and see which pitches have the biggest differences in SV% and SD%.

Twenty nine pitches had 20 or more save chances and only Sergio Romo had a better SD% than SV% (85.4% to 82%). Here are the five biggest gaps.

Name SD% SV% Diff
Craig Kimbrel 0.769 0.92 -0.152
LaTroy Hawkins 0.731 0.88 -0.154
Fernando Rodney 0.781 0.94 -0.160
Aroldis Chapman 0.786 0.95 -0.162
Jenrry Mejia 0.667 0.90 -0.237

So while you probably won’t see pages and pages of posts about SD and MD on FanGraphs because we typically speak in runs and wins (above replacement) rather than counting stats like these, they’re a great tool if you’re looking for something that fills the niche of saves without being totally useless.

This link will provide you with the data used for this post if you want to play around, and as always, feel free to post questions in the comments section.





Stats To Avoid: Runs Batted In (RBI)
 
What Do We Know About Catcher Defense?

Neil Weinberg is the Site Educator at FanGraphs and can be found writing enthusiastically about the Detroit Tigers at New English D. Follow and interact with him on Twitter @NeilWeinberg44.

1 Comment
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Bull City Cock & Bull
10 years ago

In 2009, members of the Orioles Forum on MLB.com came up with an eyeball-test statistic called the STB, which approximates your Melt Down, but with much more, um, color.

http://www.forums.mlb.com/discussions/Baltimore_Orioles/_/_/ml-orioles/44115.1

0
    Yankees Patch Their Third Baseman-Shaped Hole With Ryan McMahon
    7/25 – Davy Andrews
     
    6
    Mariners Bolster Lineup by Acquiring Josh Naylor From Diamondbacks
    7/25 – Dan Szymborski
     
    20
    Nick Allen and the Meritocratic Tyranny of the Batting Order
    7/25 – Davy Andrews
     
    1
    José Soriano Can Get You to Whiff, but He Won’t Strike You Out
    7/25 – Jake Mailhot
     
    2
    Eric Longenhagen Prospects Chat: 7/25/25
    7/25 – Eric Longenhagen
    Tyler Mahle Addresses His 2018 FanGraphs Scouting Report
    7/25 – David Laurila
     
    1
    Can I Interest You in a Lightly Used Oriole?
    7/25 – Michael Baumann
     
    14
    2025 Trade Value Series Chat
    7/25 – Ben Clemens
     
    2
    2025 Trade Value: Nos. 1-10
    7/25 – Ben Clemens
     
    234
    Effectively Wild Episode 2352: Turn Every Paige
    7/25 – Ben Lindbergh
    RosterResource Chat - 7/24/25
    7/24 – Jason Martinez
     
    2
    The Cardinals DFA Erick Fedde as They Slide Further From Contention
    7/24 – Jay Jaffe
     
    11
You are going to send email to

Move Comment

Updated: Thursday, July 24, 2025 6:00 AM ETUpdated: 7/24/2025 6:00 AM ET
@fangraphs - Contact Us - Advertise - Terms of Service - Privacy Policy
sis_logo
All major league baseball data including pitch type, velocity, batted ball location, and play-by-play data provided by Sports Info Solutions.
mlb logo
Major League and Minor League Baseball data provided by Major League Baseball.
Mitchel Lichtman
All UZR (ultimate zone rating) calculations are provided courtesy of Mitchel Lichtman.
TangoTiger.com
All Win Expectancy, Leverage Index, Run Expectancy, and Fans Scouting Report data licenced from TangoTiger.com
Retrosheet.org
Play-by-play data prior to 2002 was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet.